Surface Hardfacing of New Rolling Mill Frames
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The 2000 paper by Zhang Liangfeng from Xiangtan Electromechanical College addresses a different aspect of hardfacing: applying wear-resistant surfaces to new rolling mill frames rather than repairing worn components. This is a proactive approach that recognizes the frame's surface will experience severe wear from the rolling process, and applying a hardfacing layer before commissioning can extend the frame's service life significantly.
The paper focuses on the process analysis and the technical aspects of surface hardfacing on cast steel frames. This is particularly relevant for new equipment where the initial investment in hardfacing can pay dividends in reduced downtime and maintenance costs over the equipment's life.
From my experience in steel plants, rolling mill frames are among the most critical components in the entire production line. A frame failure or excessive wear can shut down the entire mill, costing thousands of dollars per hour in lost production. The decision to hardface new frames is often a trade-off between initial cost and long-term reliability.
Technical Analysis of the Surface Hardfacing Process
Frame Material and Hardfacing Compatibility
Rolling mill frames are typically made of cast steel (ZG230-450, ZG270-500, or similar grades) due to their complex geometry and high load-bearing requirements. The hardfacing material must be compatible with the cast steel base in terms of:
- Coefficient of thermal expansion (to avoid thermal stress cracking)
- Metallurgical compatibility (to avoid brittle intermetallic compounds at the interface)
- Weldability (to avoid hydrogen-induced cracking)
| Parameter | Cast Steel Frame | Hardfacing Material |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Grade | ZG270-500 | Martensitic stainless (13Cr) |
| Carbon Content | 0.25-0.35% | 0.10-0.20% |
| Hardness (as-cast) | 150-200 HB | 40-50 HRC (after hardfacing) |
| Coefficient of Thermal Expansion | ~12 × 10⁻⁶/°C | ~11 × 10⁻⁶/°C |
| Weldability | Fair (requires preheat) | Good (low carbon) |
Process Parameters for Frame Hardfacing
The paper emphasizes the importance of process analysis, which means understanding the heat input, deposition rate, and distortion control. For a large frame, the main challenges are:
- Distortion: The frame is a large, complex casting. Uneven heating during welding can cause significant distortion, affecting the alignment of the rolling rolls.
- Cracking: Cast steel has a higher carbon content than wrought steel, making it more susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking.
- Dilution: The hardfacing layer must maintain its hardness and wear resistance, so dilution must be controlled.
| Parameter | Recommended Value | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat Temperature | 200-300°C | Prevents cold cracking in cast steel HAZ |
| Interpass Temperature | 250-350°C | Maintains preheat effect, prevents over-tempering |
| Welding Process | SAW or FCAW | High deposition rate for large areas |
| Welding Current (FCAW) | 250-350 A | Adequate penetration with controlled dilution |
| Welding Voltage | 25-30 V | Stable arc, minimal spatter |
| Travel Speed | 30-50 cm/min | Balanced heat input and deposition |
| Post-Weld Heat Treatment | 550-600°C × 2-4 h | Stress relief, tempering of hardfacing |
Deposition Strategy
For large frames, the deposition strategy is critical. The paper suggests a systematic approach:
- Buttering layer: Apply a soft, ductile layer (e.g., austenitic stainless steel) directly on the cast steel to prevent cracking at the interface.
- Build-up layers: Apply the hardfacing material in multiple passes, using a weave technique to ensure uniform coverage.
- Final layer: Apply the wear-resistant alloy with controlled parameters to achieve the desired hardness.
In my experience, the buttering layer is essential when hardfacing cast steel. Without it, the hardfacing will crack due to the high carbon content of the base material and the difference in thermal expansion between the hardfacing and the base.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Hardfacing of a New Plate Mill Frame
I was involved in a project where a new plate mill frame was hardfaced before installation. The frame was a ZG270-500 casting weighing approximately 40 tonnes. The wear-resistant surface was applied to the areas where the rolling rolls contact the frame, specifically the roll chock seats.
The procedure we followed:
- Preheated the frame to 250°C using gas burners, maintaining the temperature throughout the hardfacing process.
- Applied a buttering layer of ER309L austenitic stainless steel (3 mm thick) using GTAW to prevent cracking at the interface.
- Applied the hardfacing layer using FCAW with a martensitic stainless steel wire (13Cr-4Ni), achieving a hardness of 42-48 HRC.
- Stress-relieved at 580°C for 4 hours, then cooled at 30°C/hour to 150°C.
- Machined the hardfaced surface to the required dimensions and surface finish (Ra 3.2 μm).
The frame has been in service for 8 years without any significant wear on the hardfaced surfaces. The original estimate was that the frame would need re-machining after 3-4 years, but the hardfacing has extended the service life significantly.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking at interface | High carbon in cast steel, insufficient buttering | Use austenitic buttering layer, increase preheat |
| Distortion | Uneven heat input, high residual stress | Use balanced welding sequence, lower interpass |
| Porosity | Contaminated surface, moisture in flux/wire | Clean surface, bake flux at 300-350°C |
| Lack of fusion | Low current, incorrect torch angle | Increase current, maintain proper angle |
| Hardness variation | Inconsistent parameters | Use automated welding, monitor interpass |
The Real Lesson
The paper from 2000 is a good example of applying hardfacing to new equipment rather than waiting for failure. This proactive approach is often overlooked in favor of reactive maintenance, but the economics are clear: hardfacing a new frame costs about 5-10% of the frame's original cost, while replacing a worn frame costs 100% plus downtime.
The key is to identify the wear-prone areas early and apply hardfacing before the equipment goes into service. This requires close collaboration between the equipment manufacturer, the hardfacing contractor, and the plant maintenance team.
Summary and Recommendations
Surface hardfacing of new rolling mill frames is a cost-effective proactive maintenance strategy that can extend equipment life by 2-3 times. The critical factors are: proper material selection (martensitic stainless steel for wear resistance), adequate preheat (200-300°C) to prevent cracking, a buttering layer to ensure metallurgical compatibility with cast steel, and controlled heat input to minimize distortion. The paper from Xiangtan Electromechanical College provides a solid technical foundation, but the real success lies in careful execution and quality control. I recommend that any plant considering this approach conduct a thorough wear analysis of the frame surfaces, develop a detailed welding procedure specification, and ensure that the hardfacing contractor has experience with large castings. The investment in hardfacing new frames is a small price to pay for the significant reduction in downtime and maintenance costs over the equipment's life.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd