Hardfacing Repair of Rolling Mill Guide Plate Heads
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The 1994 paper by Wan Weiguo from Maanshan Iron and Steel Company (Masteel) addresses a very specific and painful problem: the rapid wear of guide plate heads in a wire rod mill. The paper describes the situation at Masteel's No. 3 Rolling Mill, which produced 200,000 tonnes of wire rod annually. The inlet guide plates, specifically the K15 type, were consuming significant resources due to their short service life.
The guide plate consists of two parts: the base body and the guide plate head. The head is the wear-prone component, and the mill had tried several materials:
- Cast iron: Poor performance, low life.
- High-chromium nickel alloy: Expensive, brittle, prone to fracture, also low life.
- 45 steel (medium carbon): Average service life of only half a shift before the head developed deep grooves.
The paper describes the hardfacing repair approach to extend the life of the 45 steel guide plate heads. This is a practical solution that addresses the root cause: the guide plate head material was not suitable for the abrasive wear conditions in the wire rod mill.
From my experience in rod and bar mills, guide plates are critical components that guide the billet or rod through the rolling stands. The wear on these components is severe due to the high temperature (800-1000°C), the abrasive scale, and the high-speed contact with the rod. A guide plate failure can cause cobbles, which are among the most costly and dangerous events in a rolling mill.
Technical Analysis of the Hardfacing Repair
Wear Mechanisms and Material Selection
The guide plate head experiences several wear mechanisms simultaneously:
- Abrasive wear: From the hot rod and scale particles.
- Adhesive wear: From metal-to-metal contact at high temperature.
- Impact wear: From the rod entering the guide at high speed.
- Thermal fatigue: From cyclic heating and cooling.
| Material | Hardness | Toughness | Wear Resistance | Cost | Service Life |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cast Iron | 200-250 HB | Low | Poor | Low | Very short |
| High-Cr-Ni Alloy | 40-50 HRC | Low (brittle) | Moderate | High | Short (fracture) |
| 45 Steel (unhardfaced) | 180-220 HB | Good | Poor | Low | Half shift |
| 45 Steel + Hardfacing | 45-55 HRC | Moderate | Excellent | Moderate | Extended |
The paper's key finding is that hardfacing the 45 steel head with a suitable wear-resistant alloy can significantly extend its service life. The hardfacing material must have:
- High hardness (45-55 HRC) for abrasive wear resistance.
- Adequate toughness to resist impact and avoid fracture.
- Good hot hardness to maintain properties at operating temperatures.
Hardfacing Process and Parameters
The paper describes the hardfacing repair of the guide plate head, which involves:
- Removing the worn surface by grinding or machining.
- Preheating the head to 150-250°C.
- Applying the hardfacing layer using SMAW or FCAW.
- Controlling the interpass temperature to avoid overheating.
- Post-weld treatment (stress relief or tempering) as required.
| Parameter | Recommended Value | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat Temperature | 150-250°C | Prevents cracking in 45 steel |
| Interpass Temperature | ≤300°C | Controls dilution and prevents over-tempering |
| Welding Process | SMAW (E309L or E312) | Good compatibility with 45 steel |
| Welding Current | 100-150 A | Adequate penetration without excessive dilution |
| Electrode Diameter | 3.2 mm | Good control for small components |
| Number of Layers | 2-3 | Achieve required thickness and hardness |
| Post-Weld Tempering | 200-300°C × 1 h | Reduces residual stress, maintains hardness |
The Critical Role of Dilution
For the guide plate head, dilution control is critical because the 45 steel base has a carbon content of 0.42-0.50%, which is high enough to cause hardening and cracking in the HAZ. The hardfacing material must be applied with minimal dilution to maintain its properties.
In my experience, the best approach is to apply the first layer with low current and high travel speed to minimize dilution, then apply subsequent layers with higher current to achieve the required thickness. The total hardfacing thickness should be at least 3-5 mm to provide adequate wear allowance.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Guide Plate Hardfacing in a Rod Mill
I supervised a similar repair program at a rod mill that was experiencing guide plate failures every 4-6 hours. The mill was producing 8 mm wire rod at 90 m/s, and the guide plates were wearing out rapidly.
We implemented the following program:
- Developed a hardfacing procedure using a martensitic stainless steel electrode (E410NiMo) on a 45 steel base.
- Preheated the guide plate heads to 200°C using a resistance heater.
- Applied the hardfacing in two layers, each 2-3 mm thick, using a weave technique.
- Tempered at 250°C for 1 hour after welding.
- Machined the hardfaced surface to the original dimensions.
The result was a 10-fold increase in service life: from 4-6 hours to 40-60 hours. The hardfaced guide plates were also more consistent in performance, reducing the number of cobbles caused by guide plate wear.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking in HAZ | High carbon in 45 steel, insufficient preheat | Increase preheat to 250°C, use low-hydrogen electrodes |
| Porosity | Contaminated surface, moisture in electrode | Clean surface, bake electrodes at 300-350°C |
| Excessive dilution | High current, slow travel speed | Reduce current for first layer, increase travel speed |
| Spalling of hardfacing | Insufficient thickness, poor adhesion | Increase hardfacing thickness, improve surface preparation |
| Distortion | Excessive heat input | Use intermittent welding, back-step technique |
The Real Lesson
The paper from Masteel highlights a common problem in rolling mills: the cost of consumables and the downtime associated with guide plate replacement. The solution is not to find a better material, but to apply a hardfacing layer to a cost-effective base material.
This approach is particularly valuable in today's environment where mills are pushing for higher speeds and tighter tolerances. The guide plate must maintain its dimensions and surface finish to ensure the rod is properly guided through the mill. A worn guide plate can cause surface defects on the rod, which are unacceptable for high-quality wire rod.
Summary and Recommendations
The hardfacing repair of rolling mill guide plate heads is a practical and cost-effective solution to a chronic maintenance problem. The paper from Masteel demonstrates that hardfacing a 45 steel base with a suitable wear-resistant alloy can extend service life by 5-10 times compared to the unhardfaced material. The critical factors are: proper preheat (150-250°C) to prevent cracking, controlled dilution to maintain hardfacing properties, and adequate hardfacing thickness (3-5 mm) to provide wear allowance. I recommend that any mill experiencing guide plate wear issues consider this approach, as it offers a significant return on investment through reduced downtime, lower consumable costs, and improved product quality. The key is to develop a robust welding procedure and train the maintenance welders in the proper technique, as the success of the repair depends on consistent execution.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd