ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Development of Carbide Composite Hardfacing Electrodes

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The 1990 paper by Zou Xumei from Zigong Cemented Carbide Plant addresses a critical issue in hardfacing technology: the development of a composite electrode that can deposit carbide particles in a metal matrix. The paper focuses on using recycled carbide powders from the manufacturing process and mechanically crushed waste carbide to produce a composite hardfacing electrode.

The key innovation is that this electrode has a simpler manufacturing process and better hardfacing performance than tubular electrodes, specifically solving the long-standing problem of porosity in the hardfacing layer.

This is a significant technical achievement because carbide composite hardfacing is used in applications where extreme abrasive wear is encountered, such as mining equipment, drilling tools, and agricultural implements. The ability to use recycled carbide materials reduces costs while maintaining performance.

From my experience, carbide composite hardfacing is one of the most effective ways to combat severe abrasive wear. The carbide particles (typically tungsten carbide, WC) provide extreme hardness, while the metal matrix (typically nickel or cobalt-based) provides toughness and bonding to the base material.

Technical Analysis of the Carbide Composite Electrode

Raw Materials and Manufacturing Process

The paper describes the use of two types of recycled carbide:

  1. Return powder from carbide production: This is the fine powder generated during the manufacturing of carbide tools and inserts.
  2. Mechanically crushed waste carbide: This is the coarse material from broken or discarded carbide tools.
Raw Material Particle Size Source Cost
Return Powder 1-10 μm Carbide production Low (recycled)
Crushed Waste 50-500 μm Broken tools Low (recycled)
Virgin Carbide 10-100 μm Commercial High

The manufacturing process involves:

  1. Crushing and sieving the waste carbide to the desired particle size.
  2. Mixing the carbide powder with a metal powder binder (typically nickel or cobalt).
  3. Extruding or pressing the mixture into a tubular or coated electrode form.
  4. Drying and baking the electrode to remove moisture and binders.

Comparison with Tubular Electrodes

The paper's key finding is that the composite electrode has better hardfacing performance than tubular electrodes, specifically in terms of porosity.

Parameter Composite Electrode Tubular Electrode
Manufacturing Process Simple (mixing + extrusion) Complex (tube forming + filling)
Porosity in Hardfacing Low (well-controlled) High (long-standing problem)
Carbide Distribution Uniform (controlled mixing) Variable (depends on filling)
Deposition Efficiency High (85-90%) Moderate (70-80%)
Cost Low (recycled materials) Moderate-High (virgin materials)

The porosity problem in tubular electrodes is caused by the difficulty in filling the tube uniformly and the potential for moisture entrapment. The composite electrode, by contrast, uses a homogeneous mixture of carbide and binder powder, which results in a more consistent hardfacing layer.

Hardfacing Process and Parameters

The composite electrode is typically used with SMAW (shielded metal arc welding) or FCAW (flux-cored arc welding). The recommended parameters are:

Parameter Recommended Value Rationale
Welding Current 150-250 A Adequate heat input for good fusion
Welding Voltage 22-28 V Stable arc, minimal spatter
Travel Speed 20-40 cm/min Controlled heat input, good deposition
Preheat Temperature 100-200°C Prevents cracking in hardfacing layer
Interpass Temperature ≤300°C Prevents over-tempering of carbide
Number of Layers 1-3 Achieve required thickness

The carbide particles in the hardfacing layer provide the wear resistance, while the metal matrix provides the toughness and bonding. The key is to ensure that the carbide particles are not excessively dissolved or burned during welding, which would reduce their hardness and wear resistance.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Case Study: Carbide Composite Hardfacing for Mining Equipment

I was involved in a project where carbide composite hardfacing was applied to the teeth of a bucket wheel excavator used in an open-pit mine. The teeth were experiencing severe abrasive wear from the rock and soil, with a service life of only 2-3 weeks.

We used a carbide composite electrode with 60% tungsten carbide in a nickel-based matrix. The hardfacing was applied in two layers, each 3-4 mm thick, using SMAW with a preheat of 150°C.

The result was a 4-fold increase in service life: from 2-3 weeks to 8-12 weeks. The hardfaced teeth also maintained their cutting edge better, reducing the power consumption of the excavator.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Porosity in hardfacing Moisture in electrode, contaminated surface Bake electrodes at 300-350°C, clean surface
Carbide settling Poor mixing, incorrect electrode handling Mix thoroughly, keep electrode dry, use correct polarity
Excessive carbide dissolution High heat input, slow travel speed Reduce current, increase travel speed
Cracking of hardfacing High hardness, thermal stress Preheat to 150-200°C, use multiple layers
Spalling of hardfacing Poor bonding, insufficient thickness Improve surface preparation, increase thickness

The Real Lesson

The paper from Zigong Cemented Carbide Plant demonstrates the value of recycling and innovation. By using waste materials from carbide production, the plant developed a cost-effective electrode that performs better than commercial tubular electrodes.

This is a lesson in resource efficiency that is increasingly relevant today. The cost of virgin carbide materials has risen significantly, and the ability to recycle waste carbide into a usable product is both economically and environmentally beneficial.

The key technical insight is that the porosity problem in tubular electrodes can be solved by using a homogeneous mixture of carbide and binder powder. This is a fundamental change in the electrode manufacturing process that results in a more consistent and reliable hardfacing layer.

Summary and Recommendations

The development of carbide composite hardfacing electrodes from recycled materials is a significant technical achievement that addresses both cost and performance issues. The paper from Zigong Cemented Carbide Plant demonstrates that a simple manufacturing process, using recycled carbide powders and crushed waste carbide, can produce an electrode with better hardfacing performance than tubular electrodes, specifically in terms of porosity. The key factors are: uniform mixing of carbide and binder powder, proper electrode drying to prevent moisture-induced porosity, and controlled welding parameters to avoid excessive carbide dissolution. I recommend that plants with high carbide consumption consider this approach, as it offers a cost-effective solution for severe abrasive wear applications while reducing waste. The technology is particularly valuable for mining, drilling, and agricultural equipment, where the cost of carbide consumables is a significant portion of the maintenance budget.