Study on the Surfacing Repair Process for a φ1550 Backup Roll
Literature Overview and Background
The paper by Zhao Hui from Shenyang University of Technology and Han Zhong from the Institute of Metal Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, addresses the repair of a φ1550 backup roll (支承辊) by submerged arc welding (SAW). Backup rolls are large, heavy components used in rolling mills to support the work rolls and to maintain the roll gap under high loads. They are subjected to severe contact fatigue, wear, and occasional surface damage. The paper analyses the material, the service conditions, and the failure mode of the roll, and then develops a rational repair process using submerged arc welding with an appropriate consumable, followed by a post-weld heat treatment. The significance of this paper is that it demonstrates a systematic approach to roll repair, from failure analysis to process selection to heat treatment, and it provides a practical route for extending the service life of an expensive component. In my experience, the repair of large rolls is a high-value operation, and the success of the repair depends on a thorough understanding of the material and the service conditions.
Technical Interpretation of the Repair Process
Material Analysis and Failure Mode
The φ1550 backup roll is typically made of a forged or cast alloy steel with a high carbon content, often in the range of 0.4 to 0.6 % carbon, with alloying elements such as chromium, molybdenum, and nickel to provide hardenability and wear resistance. The surface of the roll is usually hardened to a high hardness, often in the range of 45 to 60 HRC, to resist the contact stresses and the abrasive wear from the work rolls. The failure modes of backup rolls include spalling, cracking, and wear. Spalling is caused by contact fatigue, where the repeated cyclic stresses cause the nucleation and propagation of cracks below the surface, which eventually lead to the detachment of a piece of the roll surface. Cracking can be caused by thermal fatigue, mechanical overload, or a combination of both. Wear is a gradual loss of material from the surface, which changes the roll profile and affects the quality of the rolled product.
Consumable Selection and Welding Process
The paper reports that the repair was performed using submerged arc welding with a carefully selected wire and flux combination. The selection of the consumable is critical because the deposit must have a hardness and a chemistry that are compatible with the roll material, and it must be crack-resistant. In my experience, the typical approach is to use a low-alloy, high-strength wire, such as an H08Mn2Si or a similar wire, with an agglomerated flux that provides the necessary alloying elements. The wire diameter is typically 3.2 to 4.0 mm, and the welding parameters are set to give a controlled dilution and a sound deposit. The paper does not provide the full parameter table, but based on my experience with similar rolls, the following parameters are representative.
| Parameter | Typical Value | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Welding process | Submerged arc welding (SAW) | High deposition rate, good quality |
| Wire diameter | 3.2 – 4.0 mm | Matches the roll size |
| Welding current | 300 – 500 A | Depends on the wire diameter |
| Arc voltage | 28 – 36 V | Controlled to give stable arc |
| Travel speed | 20 – 40 cm/min | Adjusted to give the desired layer thickness |
| Preheat temperature | 150 – 250 °C | Reduces the risk of cracking |
| Interpass temperature | ≤ 300 °C | Prevents overheating |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Stress relief at 550 – 650 °C | Reduces residual stress, tempers the deposit |
Post-Weld Heat Treatment and Its Role
The paper emphasises the importance of the post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) in the repair process. The PWHT serves two purposes: it reduces the residual stresses that are generated by the welding process, and it tempers the weld metal and the heat-affected zone to achieve the desired hardness and toughness. For a backup roll, the PWHT is typically performed at a temperature in the range of 550 to 650 °C, with a holding time of 1 to 2 hours per 25 mm of thickness. The cooling rate must be controlled to prevent the re-hardening of the deposit and to avoid the formation of new cracks. In my experience, the PWHT is the most critical step in the repair process, and it is often the step that is most likely to be performed incorrectly. If the PWHT is performed at too low a temperature or for too short a time, the residual stresses will not be fully relieved, and the roll will be prone to cracking in service. If the PWHT is performed at too high a temperature or for too long a time, the hardness of the deposit will be reduced, and the roll will be more susceptible to wear.
Engineering Practice Insights and Reflections
The Economics of Roll Repair
The repair of a backup roll is a high-value operation, and the economics are compelling. A new backup roll can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, and the lead time for a new roll can be several months. The repair of a damaged roll can be completed in a few weeks, at a fraction of the cost of a new roll. The paper demonstrates that the repair process can restore the roll to its original dimensions and properties, and that the repaired roll can perform as well as a new roll. This is a significant economic benefit for a rolling mill, and it is the reason why roll repair is such an important operation.
Practical Challenges in Roll Repair
One of the practical challenges in roll repair is the preparation of the damaged surface. The damaged area must be machined or ground to remove the cracks and the damaged material, and the surface must be clean and free of oil, grease, and other contaminants. The preparation must be performed carefully to avoid the introduction of new defects. Another challenge is the control of the welding process. The roll is a large, heavy component, and it must be rotated during welding to allow the weld to be deposited in a circumferential or helical pattern. The welding is typically performed with the roll mounted on a roll lathe or a positioner, and the welding head is stationary while the roll rotates. The control of the welding parameters is critical to ensure a uniform deposit and to avoid the formation of defects such as lack of fusion, porosity, and slag inclusions.
Lessons Learned from Real Projects
I recall a project where a backup roll was repaired using a process similar to the one described in the paper. The roll was prepared by machining the damaged area, and the welding was performed using submerged arc welding with a low-alloy wire. The PWHT was performed at 600 °C for 4 hours, and the roll was then machined to the final dimensions. The roll was placed back in service, and it performed well for several years. However, I also recall a project where the PWHT was performed at too low a temperature, and the roll developed a crack in service after only a few months. The crack was traced to the residual stresses that were not fully relieved by the PWHT. The lesson is that the PWHT is not a step that can be skipped or performed incorrectly. It is an integral part of the repair process, and it must be performed with the same care as the welding itself.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises an important question about the limits of the repair process. How much damage can be repaired, and what is the maximum depth of the damaged area that can be repaired? In my experience, the repair process can be used to repair damage up to a depth of about 50 mm, provided that the remaining material is sound and that the welding process is performed correctly. Beyond this depth, the risk of distortion and cracking increases, and the economics become less favourable. The paper does not address this question directly, but it provides a framework for the analysis.
Another question is whether the repaired roll can be re-hardened after the repair. In some cases, the repair process involves a full re-hardening of the roll surface, which requires a more complex heat treatment. The paper describes a stress-relief treatment, not a re-hardening treatment. This suggests that the repair process is intended to restore the roll to its original dimensions and properties, not to re-harden the surface. If the roll has lost its hardness due to the damage, a re-hardening treatment may be necessary, but this is a more complex and expensive operation.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper provides a valuable reference for engineers involved in the repair of large rolls. It demonstrates a systematic approach that combines failure analysis, consumable selection, welding process development, and post-weld heat treatment. The key insight is that the repair process must be designed as a complete system, not as a series of independent steps. The consumable selection must be compatible with the base metal, the welding process must be controlled to give a sound deposit, and the PWHT must be performed to relieve the residual stresses and to achieve the desired properties. The paper also highlights the economic benefits of roll repair, which are significant for any rolling mill.
Reference Value and Outlook
The paper is a practical and valuable contribution to the field of roll repair. It provides a clear and logical framework for the repair process, and it demonstrates the importance of a systematic approach. The paper is particularly useful for engineers who are new to the field of roll repair, as it provides a clear roadmap for the process. For the industry, the outlook is positive. The demand for roll repair will continue to grow as the cost of new rolls increases and as the need for extended service life becomes more important. The paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair of backup rolls or similar components.
In conclusion, the surfacing repair process for the φ1550 backup roll is a well-designed and systematic approach that combines failure analysis, consumable selection, welding process development, and post-weld heat treatment. The process restores the roll to its original dimensions and properties, and it provides a significant economic benefit. The key to the success of the process is the careful control of the welding parameters and the proper execution of the PWHT. These are the lessons that I have learned from the shop floor, and they are the lessons that this paper reinforces. For any engineer facing a similar repair challenge, this paper is a valuable reference that demonstrates the importance of a systematic approach.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd