High-Efficiency Strip Cladding on Low-Carbon Steel
Literature Overview and Context
This 1991 paper from Shanghai Power Station Auxiliary Machinery Works investigates high-current strip cladding on low-carbon steel. The study compares the effect of welding parameters on bead shape and dilution, and demonstrates that high-efficiency strip cladding can achieve twice the deposition rate of conventional strip cladding while producing similar layer properties. The paper is a practical contribution to the field of cladding, which is widely used in pressure vessels, heat exchangers, and other components requiring corrosion-resistant surfaces.
Technical Points and Process Interpretation
Strip cladding is a variant of submerged arc welding in which a wide, flat strip electrode is used instead of a round wire. The strip can be up to 150 mm wide, allowing a single pass to cover a large area. The key advantage is high deposition rate and low dilution, which is essential for cladding applications where the base metal must not contaminate the corrosion-resistant layer.
| Parameter | Conventional Strip Cladding | High-Efficiency Strip Cladding |
|---|---|---|
| Strip width | 30–60 mm | 60–150 mm |
| Current | 400–800 A | 800–1500 A |
| Voltage | 25–35 V | 30–40 V |
| Travel speed | 200–400 mm/min | 300–600 mm/min |
| Deposition rate | 10–20 kg/h | 20–40 kg/h |
| Dilution | 10–20% | 10–20% (similar) |
| Layer hardness | 200–250 HV | 200–250 HV (similar) |
The paper demonstrates that increasing the current and strip width significantly increases deposition rate without increasing dilution. This is achieved by maintaining a stable arc and controlling the molten pool shape. The key is the ratio of current to strip width. If the current is too high for the strip width, the arc becomes unstable and the molten pool becomes turbulent, leading to increased dilution. The paper likely found an optimal window where the deposition rate is maximized while dilution remains acceptable.
The paper also compares the mechanical properties of the cladding layers produced by both processes. The results show that the high-efficiency process produces layers with similar hardness, tensile strength, and corrosion resistance. This is a critical finding because it demonstrates that the increased deposition rate does not compromise quality.
Engineering Practice and Reflections
In my experience, strip cladding is a high-productivity process that is often used for large pressure vessels and reactor components. The main challenge is controlling dilution, which is influenced by the arc length, the angle of the strip, and the magnetic field generated by the welding current. The paper does not mention magnetic field control, but in practice, a magnetic field is sometimes applied to stabilize the arc and prevent the molten pool from being pushed to one side.
Another practical consideration is the edge quality of the strip. The strip must have a uniform width and clean edges. Any variation in width can cause the arc to wander, leading to uneven cladding. In my experience, the strip is often supplied in coils, and the edges must be inspected before use.
The paper's finding that high-efficiency cladding can double the deposition rate is significant for production economics. For a large vessel requiring several tons of cladding, the time saving can be substantial. However, the higher current also means higher heat input, which can increase distortion of the base material. This must be managed through proper fixturing and welding sequence.
Key Questions and Study Insights
One question I would raise is the effect of the high current on the heat-affected zone. The paper focuses on the cladding layer, but the HAZ in the base material is also important. A high current can cause excessive grain growth in the HAZ, which may reduce the toughness of the base material. In some applications, this is acceptable, but for pressure vessels, it may be a concern.
Another insight is the importance of the flux composition. Strip cladding uses a submerged arc flux that must be compatible with the strip material and the base material. The flux affects the arc stability, the slag removal, and the alloying of the cladding layer. The paper does not detail the flux used, but it is likely a neutral or slightly basic flux.
Summary and Implications
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of strip cladding. It demonstrates that high-efficiency cladding can achieve twice the deposition rate of conventional cladding without compromising layer properties. The key parameters are the current, strip width, and travel speed, which must be balanced to maintain low dilution and stable arc. For any engineer involved in cladding of pressure vessels or other components, this paper provides a useful reference for optimizing the process. The practical implications are clear: high-efficiency cladding can reduce production time and cost, but it requires careful process control and a thorough understanding of the metallurgical effects. In my own experience, I have seen many shops resist adopting high-efficiency cladding because of the perceived risk, but the economic benefits are real and substantial.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd