ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing Repair Technology for Roller Press Rolls: A Practical Review

1. Literature Overview and Background

The five papers under review collectively address a critical maintenance problem in the cement industry: the wear and repair of roller press rolls and vertical mill grinding components. These components operate in the most abrasive environment in the entire clinker production line, processing raw materials with high silica content at pressures reaching 150-200 MPa. The papers span from 2006 to 2013, reflecting a period of rapid adoption of roller presses in Chinese cement plants and the accompanying learning curve in maintenance practices.

Zhang Xinsheng and colleagues from Tangshan Jidong Cement (Topic 1) provide a company-wide perspective, reporting on 24 roller presses across four specifications operating in 14 subsidiaries. The criticality is underscored by their observation that after the installation of dispersing classifiers, the roller press has become the bottleneck equipment whose reliability directly determines cement dispatch capability. Pan Yuancan (Topic 2) presents a case study from Baoshan Kungang Jiahua Cement, documenting a specific failure progression from initial foreign material damage to catastrophic roll surface spalling. Zhao Yunfeng (Topic 3) addresses a different equipment family, the MLS3726 vertical mill, and proposes a novel online hardfacing method that avoids the costly and time-consuming removal of 36-tonne grinding rollers. Shi Qingguo (Topic 4) from the same Jidong group combines both applications, covering grinding table liners and roller press rolls. Zhang Xiubao from the Zhengzhou Research Institute of Mechanical Engineering (Topic 5) brings a research perspective, analyzing the metallurgical requirements for hardfacing alloys when grinding slag, a material with distinct abrasive characteristics compared to clinker.

The collective significance of these papers lies in their documentation of both the technical and economic dimensions of wear management. The capital cost of a roller press roll pair is substantial, and the production loss during maintenance downtime directly impacts plant profitability. The papers demonstrate that hardfacing repair is not merely a maintenance activity but a strategic operational decision requiring careful material selection, process control, and quality assurance.

2. Technical Analysis of Hardfacing Repair Methods

2.1 Roller Press Roll Surface Wear Mechanisms

The wear mechanism on roller press rolls is primarily three-body abrasive wear, where the feed material acts as the abrasive medium between the two rolls and the material bed. The papers identify several distinct wear patterns that require different repair strategies.

Wear Pattern Typical Location Cause Repair Strategy
Uniform surface wear Roll face across working width Normal abrasive wear from feed material Rebuild with hardfacing alloy to restore diameter
Localized pitting Random distribution Foreign material (metal, hard nodules) impact Spot repair with compatible electrode
Spalling (剥落) Surface layer, often large flakes Subsurface cracking due to fatigue and hydrogen embrittlement Complete removal of damaged layer, rebuild with buffer + wear layer
Edge wear Roll edges Material bypass and edge grinding Hardfacing with higher hardness alloy
Ring wear Circumferential bands Feed segregation or material buildup Grind out and rebuild with matching alloy

Pan Yuancan's paper (Topic 2) provides a particularly instructive failure analysis. The initial damage occurred when iron foreign material entered the roller press during trial production. The surface was damaged but not immediately repaired due to the small affected area. By May 2008, the damage had progressed to surface spalling, reducing the material crushing rate and impacting production throughput. The first repair attempt used 707 electrodes, but the hardfaced layer spalled again shortly after. The analysis concluded that the base metal and the 707 electrode were metallurgically incompatible. The second attempt used 506 electrodes as a buffer layer beneath the 707 hardfacing, which extended service life to 1-2 months, but spalling recurred, and in some cases, the base metal itself spalled with the hardfaced layer.

This failure progression illustrates a fundamental principle in hardfacing repair: the repair alloy must be compatible with the base metal, and the welding procedure must account for the thermal and metallurgical effects of the process. The 707 electrode is a high-carbon, high-chromium alloy designed for extreme abrasion resistance, but its high hardness and low toughness make it unsuitable for direct application to a low-alloy steel base without a proper transition layer. The 506 electrode, a low-hydrogen type, provides better compatibility but still does not address the fundamental issue of hydrogen-induced cracking in the base metal.

2.2 Welding Process Optimization

The papers collectively describe a multi-layer hardfacing approach that has become standard practice in the industry. The process involves three distinct layers, each serving a specific metallurgical function.

The first layer, or buffer layer, is deposited directly onto the base metal. Its purpose is to provide a transition between the base metal's composition and the hardfacing alloy, reducing the dilution effect and preventing cracking. The buffer layer should have sufficient toughness to accommodate the thermal stresses from subsequent layers. For roller press rolls, the typical buffer layer material is a low-hydrogen electrode with a carbon equivalent compatible with the base metal. The paper by Pan Yuancan suggests that the 506 electrode serves this purpose adequately, but the subsequent spalling indicates that additional measures were necessary.

The intermediate layers build up the required thickness while gradually transitioning to the wear-resistant alloy. The number of layers depends on the required rebuild thickness, which typically ranges from 10 to 25 mm for roller press rolls. Each layer must be deposited with controlled interpass temperature to prevent overheating and excessive dilution.

The final wear layer provides the abrasion resistance. The choice of alloy depends on the specific wear mechanism and the material being processed. For clinker grinding, the typical alloy is a high-chromium, high-carbon martensitic or ledeburitic steel with hardness in the range of 55-65 HRC. The papers mention 707 electrodes as one option, but the industry has since developed more sophisticated alloys with improved toughness and wear resistance.

2.3 Online Hardfacing for Vertical Mill Grinding Rolls

Zhao Yunfeng's paper (Topic 3) addresses a specific operational challenge: the MLS3726 vertical mill in their plant does not have an automatic roller lifting function. The grinding rollers are connected to the pressure frame through spherical steel balls, and the hydraulic system can only lift the pressure frame, not the three individual rollers. Consequently, maintenance requires removing the 36-tonne rollers, which is time-consuming and labor-intensive.

The proposed solution involves online hardfacing of the grinding rollers without removing them from the mill. This method requires careful planning and execution to ensure safety and quality. The paper describes the procedure, which involves positioning the mill in a specific orientation, securing the rollers, and performing the hardfacing operation through access ports. The key advantage is the elimination of the dismantling and reassembly time, which can reduce maintenance downtime from several days to a single shift.

However, online hardfacing introduces specific challenges. The work is performed in a confined space with limited access, which affects the welder's ability to maintain consistent travel speed and electrode angle. The mill's structure may cause heat buildup in areas that are difficult to cool, potentially affecting the welding quality. Additionally, the grinding rollers may not be in an optimal position for welding, requiring the use of specialized fixtures or welding positioners.

The paper's contribution lies in demonstrating that with proper planning and execution, online hardfacing can be a viable alternative to complete roller removal, particularly in plants where the mill design does not facilitate easy roller extraction.

2.4 Material Selection for Slag Grinding Applications

Zhang Xiubao's paper (Topic 5) addresses the specific requirements for hardfacing when grinding slag, a byproduct of blast furnace ironmaking. The paper notes that China produces tens of millions of tonnes of slag annually, most of which is used as cement admixture. The mineral composition of slag falls within the C2AS, CAS2, CS, and C2S crystallization regions of the CaO-SiO2-Al2O3 ternary phase diagram.

The critical difference between slag and clinker grinding lies in the material's grindability. Slag has a different hardness and fracture characteristics compared to clinker, which affects the wear mechanism on the grinding components. The paper emphasizes that when slag is ground together with other materials in the clinker grinding system, the differences in grindability cause preferential grinding of the softer components, leading to an imbalance in the finished product's particle size distribution.

For hardfacing purposes, the slag's abrasive characteristics require an alloy with specific properties. The paper discusses the metallurgical considerations, including the need for a hardfacing alloy with sufficient toughness to withstand the impact of slag particles while maintaining high hardness for abrasion resistance. The ternary phase diagram analysis provides a framework for understanding the slag's mineralogy and predicting its abrasive behavior.

3. Integration with Engineering Practice

3.1 Root Cause Analysis of Hardfacing Failures

The failure progression documented in Pan Yuancan's paper (Topic 2) provides an excellent case study for root cause analysis. The initial damage from foreign material was a localized event that, if properly repaired at the time, might not have progressed to the observed catastrophic spalling. The delay in repair allowed the damage to propagate, eventually leading to surface layer spalling.

The first repair with 707 electrodes failed because of metallurgical incompatibility between the electrode and the base metal. The 707 electrode is designed for hardfacing applications where the base metal has a similar composition or where a buffer layer is used. Direct application to a low-alloy steel base results in excessive dilution, which alters the hardfacing alloy's composition and reduces its performance. Additionally, the high hardness of the 707 deposit creates a sharp hardness gradient at the fusion line, which is a preferred site for crack initiation under cyclic loading.

The second repair with 506 buffer layer and 707 hardfacing extended service life but still failed after 1-2 months. The spalling in this case involved the base metal, indicating that the problem was not just the hardfacing alloy but the base metal's condition. The repeated welding cycles had likely introduced hydrogen into the base metal, causing hydrogen-induced cracking. The 506 electrode is a low-hydrogen type, but the welding process itself, particularly if proper preheat and post-weld heat treatment were not performed, can introduce hydrogen into the heat-affected zone.

This failure sequence demonstrates the importance of a systematic approach to hardfacing repair. The repair procedure must address not just the surface damage but also the condition of the base metal. Pre-weld inspection should include ultrasonic testing to detect subsurface cracks and delamination. The welding procedure must specify preheat temperature, interpass temperature control, and post-weld heat treatment to minimize hydrogen content and residual stress.

3.2 Quality Control and Acceptance Criteria

The papers collectively emphasize the importance of quality control in hardfacing operations. The acceptance criteria for a hardfaced roll surface typically include:

Parameter Acceptance Criteria Test Method
Surface hardness 55-65 HRC (wear layer) Hardness testing
Hardness uniformity ±3 HRC across surface Hardness mapping
Surface crack density No through-thickness cracks Visual inspection, PT
Porosity No visible porosity Visual inspection
Surface profile Within ±2 mm of design Profile measurement
Bond strength No delamination Hammer test, UT

The papers do not provide specific acceptance criteria, but the industry practice is well established. The critical requirement is that the hardfaced surface must have no cracks that can propagate into the base metal during operation. Surface checks or cracks that are confined to the hardfacing layer are generally acceptable, as they do not affect the roll's structural integrity. However, any crack that extends into the base metal requires immediate repair.

3.3 Economic Considerations

The economic case for hardfacing repair versus roll replacement is compelling. The cost of a new roller press roll pair can be several hundred thousand dollars, while the cost of hardfacing repair is typically 10-20% of the replacement cost. Additionally, the lead time for a new roll pair can be several months, while hardfacing repair can be completed in 3-5 days.

However, the economic analysis must account for the production loss during maintenance downtime. The papers indicate that roller press downtime directly impacts cement dispatch capability. A single day of downtime on a 5000 t/d production line can result in a production loss of 5000 tonnes, which at a market price of $50-60 per tonne represents a revenue loss of $250,000-300,000. This economic reality underscores the importance of minimizing downtime, which is the driving force behind the development of online hardfacing methods.

3.4 Practical Lessons from the Field

The papers collectively provide several practical lessons that are directly applicable to plant operations.

First, the importance of preventing foreign material ingress cannot be overstated. The initial damage in Pan Yuancan's case was caused by iron foreign material entering the roller press. Proper screening and magnetic separation of the feed material is the most cost-effective preventive measure. The plant should also establish a protocol for responding to foreign material events, including immediate inspection and, if necessary, prompt repair before the damage progresses.

Second, the choice of hardfacing alloy must be based on a thorough understanding of the base metal composition and the service conditions. The compatibility between the base metal and the hardfacing alloy is critical. The welding procedure should specify the preheat temperature, interpass temperature, and post-weld heat treatment based on the carbon equivalent of the base metal. For roller press rolls, which are typically made of low-alloy steel with a carbon equivalent of 0.40-0.50, a preheat of 200-250°C is generally required.

Third, the hardfacing operation should be planned and executed with the same rigor as any other critical welding operation. The welders must be qualified for the specific hardfacing procedure, and the welding parameters must be monitored and documented. The use of automated hardfacing systems, where feasible, can improve consistency and reduce human error.

4. Study Insights and Implications

4.1 Metallurgical Considerations

The papers highlight several metallurgical factors that influence the success of hardfacing repair. The most critical is the dilution effect, which occurs when the base metal melts and mixes with the deposited hardfacing alloy. The dilution rate depends on the welding process and parameters. For manual arc welding with covered electrodes, the dilution rate is typically 10-20%. For submerged arc welding, it can be 30-50%.

The dilution effect is particularly important for the first layer of hardfacing. The first layer has the highest dilution, which means its composition is significantly affected by the base metal. This is why a buffer layer is often used: the buffer layer absorbs the dilution and provides a transition zone with intermediate properties. The subsequent layers have progressively lower dilution and approach the nominal composition of the hardfacing alloy.

The papers also emphasize the importance of controlling the interpass temperature. Excessive interpass temperature can cause grain growth in the heat-affected zone, reducing toughness and increasing the risk of cracking. Conversely, too low an interpass temperature can lead to hydrogen accumulation and cold cracking. The recommended interpass temperature for roller press roll hardfacing is typically 150-250°C.

4.2 Process Optimization

The papers collectively suggest several process optimization opportunities. The use of automated hardfacing systems, such as submerged arc welding with a mechanized carriage, can improve deposition rate and consistency. The development of specialized hardfacing alloys with improved toughness and wear resistance has been an ongoing trend. The industry has moved from simple high-carbon alloys to more sophisticated compositions with controlled carbide size and distribution.

The papers also highlight the importance of proper surface preparation before hardfacing. The damaged surface must be ground or machined to remove all cracks, spalled areas, and contaminated material. The surface should be inspected with magnetic particle testing to ensure that no subsurface cracks remain. The welding should be performed on a clean, dry surface with no oil, grease, or moisture.

4.3 Future Directions

The papers suggest several areas for future development. The online hardfacing method described in Topic 3 represents a significant advance in reducing downtime. The development of portable hardfacing equipment and automated welding systems can further improve the efficiency and quality of online repairs. The use of laser cladding and other advanced deposition technologies may offer advantages in terms of dilution control and surface quality.

The papers also point to the need for better predictive maintenance strategies. The wear rate of roller press rolls depends on many factors, including the material being processed, the operating pressure, and the feed size distribution. The development of wear monitoring systems, such as laser profilometry or ultrasonic thickness measurement, can enable condition-based maintenance rather than fixed-interval maintenance.

5. Conclusion

The five papers collectively provide a comprehensive overview of hardfacing repair technology for roller press rolls and vertical mill grinding components. The key technical points can be summarized as follows: the wear mechanism on roller press rolls is primarily three-body abrasive wear, requiring a hardfacing alloy with high hardness and sufficient toughness; the repair procedure must include a buffer layer to ensure metallurgical compatibility between the base metal and the hardfacing alloy; the welding process must be carefully controlled to minimize hydrogen content and residual stress; and the quality of the repair must be verified through proper inspection and testing.

The practical lessons from the field are equally important. The prevention of foreign material ingress is the most cost-effective measure to extend roll service life. The choice of hardfacing alloy must be based on a thorough understanding of the base metal and service conditions. The hardfacing operation should be planned and executed with the same rigor as any other critical welding operation, with qualified welders and documented welding parameters.

The economic case for hardfacing repair is compelling, particularly when the production loss during downtime is considered. The development of online hardfacing methods represents a significant advance in reducing maintenance downtime and improving plant availability. The papers demonstrate that with proper material selection, process control, and quality assurance, hardfacing repair can provide a reliable and cost-effective solution for extending the service life of roller press rolls and vertical mill grinding components. The insights from these papers are directly applicable to plant operations and provide a solid foundation for developing effective wear management strategies.