Repair of MLS Vertical Mill Grinding Rollers by Surfacing Welding
Literature Overview and Core Technical Content
The paper by Fu Jinqiang and Yang Wei, published in New Century Cement Guide in 2015, addresses a practical problem that every cement plant with an MLS vertical mill eventually faces: the grinding rollers wear out, and the question is whether to replace them or repair them. The authors describe both offline and online surfacing repair methods, and they introduce two specific pieces of tooling — a mounting jig for offline repair and a curved welding gun for online repair. The key technical claim is that the segmented, split-type structure of the MLS roller makes it particularly suitable for online repair, and that the ZD90X-O series wear-resistant welding wire delivers excellent abrasion resistance in service. The paper also documents the repair of a real MLS mill, which validates the approach.
Interpretation of Technical Points and Process Windows
The MLS grinding roller is a split-type structure, meaning it is assembled from segments rather than being a single monolithic casting. This design choice has a direct consequence for repair strategy. When the roller is disassembled, each segment can be handled individually, which makes offline repair feasible. The authors designed a mounting jig specifically for this purpose, allowing the roller to be rotated and positioned for welding without the need for a large, dedicated fixture. For online repair, they developed a curved welding gun that can reach the worn surface while the roller remains installed in the mill, with the pressure frame raised hydraulically. This is a significant practical improvement, because it avoids the long downtime associated with dismantling the entire grinding assembly.
The repair procedure differs between the two routes. Offline repair involves two main steps: cutting out the damaged or worn material, then building it back up with surfacing weld. Online repair is essentially a build-up operation only, since the worn surface is accessible directly. In both cases, the choice of welding consumable is critical. The ZD90X-O series wire is a high-alloy, carbide-forming type that produces a hard, wear-resistant deposit. In my experience, the hardness of such deposits typically falls in the range of 55 to 65 HRC, depending on the dilution rate and the number of passes. The dilution from the base metal must be controlled, because excessive dilution will soften the deposit and reduce its abrasion resistance. This is usually managed by using a low current, short arc length, and weaving technique that limits penetration.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
I have seen this exact scenario play out in cement plants and in mineral processing facilities. The grinding roller is one of the highest-wear components in the entire mill system, and it operates under a combination of abrasive wear from the material being ground and impact loading from the grinding bed. The wear pattern is not uniform; the roller ends typically wear faster than the middle, and the surface develops a characteristic wavy profile. If this profile is not corrected, the grinding efficiency drops, the mill vibrates, and the wear accelerates. The paper's emphasis on proper preparation — cutting out the damaged material before building it up — is exactly right. I have seen repairs fail because the welder simply deposited new metal over a cracked or spalled surface, and the crack propagated through the repair within weeks.
The online repair route is attractive from a cost and downtime perspective, but it has its own challenges. The welding environment is confined, the visibility is poor, and the operator must work in awkward positions. The curved gun described in the paper addresses the accessibility issue, but the welder still needs to maintain a consistent travel speed and arc length to produce a uniform deposit. Preheating is also a concern. The roller is a large, massive component, and if it is cold, the first pass of weld will cool rapidly, creating a hard, crack-sensitive HAZ. In practice, I would recommend a preheat of at least 150 to 200°C, maintained throughout the welding process, and a post-weld stress relief or slow cooling in insulating blankets.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that the paper does not fully address is the economic break-even point between repair and replacement. In my experience, the decision is not simply about the cost of the welding consumables and labor. It must account for the downtime, the risk of the repair failing, and the remaining life of the roller after repair. If the roller is already near its dimensional limit, a repair may not be justified. The paper's case study, however, shows that a well-executed repair can extend the service life significantly, and the ZD90X-O wire performed well in the field. This aligns with my own observations that high-quality surfacing consumables, applied with proper procedure control, can achieve wear life comparable to or better than the original material.
Study Insights and Implications
The practical takeaway from this paper is that repair is a legitimate and often preferable option for large, expensive wear components, provided that the repair is planned and executed with the same rigor as a new fabrication. The tooling innovations described — the mounting jig and the curved gun — are examples of the kind of practical engineering that makes a repair feasible. For a plant engineer, the lesson is to develop a repair procedure, qualify it, and have the consumables and tooling on hand before the failure occurs. Waiting until the roller is worn out and then scrambling to find a solution is a recipe for extended downtime and poor-quality repairs. The paper is a useful reference for any plant that operates MLS mills, and it reinforces the principle that surfacing repair is a specialized skill that requires both metallurgical understanding and practical welding craftsmanship.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd