ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Development of High-Nickel Braze-WC Composite Surfacing Electrodes

Literature Overview and Core Technical Content

The paper by Lei Guocai, published in Physical Testing in 2022, describes the development of a composite surfacing electrode that combines tungsten carbide (WC) hard particles with a high-nickel braze metal matrix. The author used YG8-type WC particles of 2 to 5 mm size as the wear-resistant phase, a CuZnNi alloy as the matrix, and added NiCrBSi alloy powder to increase the nickel and chromium content of the matrix. The electrodes were fabricated by sintering in a molybdenum wire hydrogen furnace, using SiC boats as molds. The results show that the WC particles are relatively uniformly distributed in the electrode, the nickel content in the matrix reaches 32.39% by mass, and the chromium addition improves the strength, corrosion resistance, and high-temperature oxidation resistance of the matrix. When applied by oxy-acetylene flame surfacing, the matrix has good fluidity and wettability with the substrate, and the deposit hardness exceeds 60 HRA. The author suggests this electrode is suitable for wear-resistant applications in the petroleum and mining industries.

Interpretation of Technical Points and Process Windows

This paper is essentially a materials development study, and it touches on several fundamental metallurgical principles that are directly relevant to surfacing technology. The first is the role of the matrix in a composite hardfacing deposit. The WC particles provide the primary wear resistance, but they are only effective if the matrix holds them in place and prevents them from being pulled out during abrasion. A matrix that is too soft will allow the particles to be dislodged, while a matrix that is too hard may crack or spall under impact. The author's choice of CuZnNi as the base matrix is interesting, because copper-based alloys have good toughness and are not prone to the cracking that often affects high-chromium iron or nickel-based hardfacing alloys. The addition of NiCrBSi powder serves two purposes: it raises the nickel content, which improves the matrix's corrosion resistance and high-temperature stability, and it introduces chromium and boron, which can form hard borides and carbides that further strengthen the matrix.

The sintering process is another key point. The use of a hydrogen furnace with molybdenum wire heating is a standard technique for producing cemented carbide and composite materials, because the hydrogen atmosphere prevents oxidation and allows for controlled sintering temperatures. The SiC boat is used as a mold, and it is interesting because SiC is a refractory material that can withstand the sintering temperature without reacting with the alloy. The result is an electrode that has a composite structure, with WC particles embedded in a metallic matrix. When this electrode is used for oxy-acetylene flame surfacing, the flame melts the matrix, which then wets the substrate and the WC particles. The key is to control the flame temperature and the travel speed so that the matrix melts but the WC particles do not dissolve or sink to the bottom of the deposit. If the temperature is too high, the WC will dissolve into the matrix, reducing the hardness of the deposit. If the travel speed is too slow, the particles may segregate, creating an uneven wear surface.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have seen this type of composite surfacing used in a variety of applications, from drill bits and stabilizers in the oil and gas industry to crusher hammers and chute liners in mining. The fundamental advantage of a composite deposit is that it combines the hardness of the ceramic phase with the toughness of the metallic matrix. However, the practical success of such a deposit depends heavily on the application. For pure abrasion, such as in a chute liner where the material slides over the surface, a high volume fraction of WC is desirable. For impact and abrasion, such as in a crusher hammer, the matrix must be tough enough to absorb the impact without cracking. The author's deposit hardness of greater than 60 HRA is equivalent to roughly 85 to 90 HRB, which is quite hard for a copper-based matrix. This suggests that the WC particles are contributing significantly to the overall hardness.

In my experience, the biggest issue with this type of electrode is the control of the welding process. Oxy-acetylene flame surfacing is a manual process, and the welder's skill determines the quality of the deposit. If the flame is too oxidizing, the matrix will oxidize and the deposit will be porous. If the flame is too reducing, the matrix may become brittle. The author's observation that the matrix has good fluidity and wettability is important, because it means the deposit will spread evenly over the substrate and form a strong metallurgical bond. However, I would caution that the dilution rate must be controlled. If the substrate is a low-alloy steel, the iron from the substrate will mix into the matrix, reducing its nickel content and potentially forming brittle intermetallic phases. This is a common cause of cracking in composite deposits.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this paper raises is the economic viability of this approach. The raw materials — YG8 WC particles, CuZnNi alloy, and NiCrBSi powder — are relatively expensive, and the sintering process adds further cost. The author suggests that the electrode is suitable for petroleum and mining applications, where the cost of downtime and replacement is high. This is a valid argument, but it requires a careful cost-benefit analysis for each specific application. In my experience, the decision to use a composite hardfacing material is usually driven by the severity of the wear and the cost of the alternative. For a component that wears out in a few weeks, a more expensive but longer-lasting deposit may be the most economical choice. For a component that lasts a year, a cheaper, simpler hardfacing may be sufficient.

Another question is the reproducibility of the sintering process. The author reports that the WC particles are relatively uniformly distributed, but this is a qualitative observation. In a production environment, the uniformity of the particle distribution would need to be verified by sampling and metallographic examination. The hydrogen furnace is also a safety concern, and it requires strict adherence to operating procedures to prevent explosions. This is a factor that would need to be considered if the process were to be scaled up.

Study Insights and Implications

The paper provides a useful contribution to the field of composite hardfacing, and it demonstrates a practical method for producing a WC-reinforced electrode with a high-nickel matrix. The key insight is that the matrix composition can be tailored to the application by adding alloying elements such as chromium and boron. For a plant engineer, the lesson is that composite hardfacing is not a simple matter of mixing WC particles with a metal matrix. The matrix must be designed to provide the right combination of toughness, corrosion resistance, and high-temperature stability. The paper also highlights the importance of process control during fabrication and application. The sintering parameters and the welding parameters must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired microstructure and properties. This is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the selection or development of wear-resistant surfacing materials.