ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Application of Carbide Surfacing Welding in 125m³ Blast Furnace Bell and Hopper

Literature Overview

This paper by Ma Lingyun from Laiwu Iron and Steel Group's Sintering Plant addresses a critical maintenance issue in blast furnace operation: the rapid wear of the bell and hopper, which are essential components of the charging system. The bell and hopper must maintain a tight seal to prevent gas leakage, and they are subjected to severe abrasive wear from the burden materials (coke, ore, and limestone) as they are charged into the furnace.

The author describes a practical solution: applying a layer of hard carbide alloy (TDGC-1) on the contact surfaces of the bell and hopper using surfacing welding with a soft-core 667 electrode. The 667 electrode produces a deposit of Stellite-type alloy (索尔玛依特合金), which provides excellent wear resistance. The paper also describes a clever engineering solution: inserting an asbestos insulation blanket between two steel plates to control the heat input and prevent distortion.

The paper is short and practical, reflecting the pragmatic approach of a plant engineer solving a specific problem. It is not a research paper in the academic sense but rather a case study of a successful repair that extended the service life of the bell and hopper.

Core Technical Points

The Bell and Hopper: Function and Failure Modes

The blast furnace bell and hopper are the primary charging components. The hopper receives the burden material from the skip or conveyor, and the bell opens to allow the material to fall into the furnace. The bell and hopper must maintain a gas-tight seal when closed to prevent the escape of blast furnace gas, which is both a safety hazard and a loss of energy.

The failure modes are:

  1. Abrasive wear - The burden materials (coke, ore, sinter) are hard and abrasive, causing rapid wear on the contact surfaces.
  2. Erosive wear - The gas flow and the falling material create erosive conditions.
  3. Thermal fatigue - The bell and hopper are subjected to cyclic heating and cooling, which can cause thermal fatigue cracking.
  4. Corrosion - The blast furnace gas contains sulfur and other corrosive components.

The contact surfaces between the bell and hopper are the most critical areas. If these surfaces wear, the seal is compromised, and gas leakage occurs. The author identifies the sealing performance as a key concern and focuses on improving the wear resistance of these surfaces.

The TDGC-1 Carbide Alloy

The TDGC-1 alloy is a tungsten carbide-based hardfacing material. It is applied using a surfacing welding process, typically with a 667 electrode, which is a soft-core electrode that deposits a Stellite-type alloy.

The composition of the deposited metal is approximately:

Element Typical Composition (%) Function
C 0.7-1.2 Hardness, carbide formation
Cr 25-30 Corrosion resistance, carbide formation
W 4-8 Hardness, wear resistance
Si 1-2 Deoxidation, fluidity
Fe Balance Matrix

The hardness of the deposited metal is typically 40-50 HRC, which provides excellent wear resistance. The Stellite-type alloy is a cobalt-based alloy, but the 667 electrode is a soft-core electrode that deposits a nickel-based or iron-based alloy with similar properties at a lower cost.

Welding Procedure

The welding procedure for applying the TDGC-1 alloy to the bell and hopper is critical. The key parameters are:

Parameter Recommended Range Critical Considerations
Preheat temperature 200-300°C Prevents cracking due to thermal stress
Interpass temperature 250-350°C Controls the cooling rate and microstructure
Welding current 150-220A Depends on electrode diameter
Welding voltage 22-28V Affects arc stability
Welding speed 15-25 cm/min Controls the bead width and heat input
Electrode diameter 3.2-5.0mm Larger diameter for higher deposition
Heat input 10-20 kJ/cm Controls the dilution and hardness

The author emphasizes the importance of controlling the heat input and the cooling rate. The carbide alloy is susceptible to cracking if the cooling rate is too fast, and the heat input must be controlled to prevent excessive dilution of the carbide alloy with the base metal.

The Asbestos Insulation Blanket

One of the most interesting aspects of this paper is the use of an asbestos insulation blanket between two steel plates. This is a practical engineering solution to a common problem: controlling the heat input and preventing distortion during surfacing welding.

The bell and hopper are large components, and the surfacing welding process can cause significant distortion due to the thermal expansion and contraction of the base metal. By inserting an asbestos insulation blanket between two steel plates, the heat is more evenly distributed, and the distortion is reduced.

This technique is particularly useful for large, thin-walled components where distortion is a concern. The asbestos blanket acts as a thermal barrier, slowing the heat transfer and allowing the heat to spread more evenly.

Integration with Engineering Practice

The Economics of Repair vs. Replacement

The decision to repair or replace a worn bell and hopper is a classic engineering economic decision. The cost of a new bell and hopper is significant, and the downtime required for replacement is also costly. In many cases, repair is more economical.

The author reports that the service life of the repaired bell and hopper was significantly longer than the original. This is a key finding: the surfacing welding not only restored the worn surfaces but also improved the wear resistance, extending the service life.

In my experience, the economics of repair vs. replacement depend on several factors:

  1. The cost of the new component - This includes the manufacturing cost, transportation, and installation.
  2. The cost of downtime - The lost production during the repair or replacement.
  3. The expected service life - The repaired component may last longer than the original if the hardfacing is properly applied.
  4. The availability of skilled welders - Surfacing welding requires skilled welders who are familiar with the process and the materials.

The Importance of Preheat and Interpass Temperature

The author emphasizes the importance of preheat and interpass temperature control. This is a critical point that is often overlooked in practice.

The carbide alloy is a high-hardness material that is susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking. The preheat reduces the cooling rate, allowing hydrogen to diffuse out of the weld metal before it can cause cracking. The interpass temperature control prevents the build-up of residual stress that can cause cracking.

In practice, the preheat and interpass temperature must be monitored carefully. A simple method is to use a temperature-indicating crayon or an infrared thermometer to measure the temperature at regular intervals.

The Asbestos Insulation Technique: A Practical Solution

The use of an asbestos insulation blanket is a clever practical solution. However, it raises a concern: asbestos is a known carcinogen, and its use is restricted in many countries. In modern practice, alternative insulation materials, such as ceramic fiber blankets, should be used.

The principle remains the same: controlling the heat distribution and preventing distortion. The insulation blanket is placed between the component and a backing plate or between two layers of the component to reduce the temperature gradient and the resulting thermal stress.

Quality Control and Inspection

The quality of the surfacing weld must be verified to ensure that it will perform as intended. The key quality control measures are:

  1. Visual inspection - Check for cracks, porosity, and lack of fusion.
  2. Hardness testing - Verify that the hardness of the deposited metal is within the specified range.
  3. Dimensional inspection - Verify that the dimensions of the repaired component are within tolerance.
  4. Non-destructive testing - Use magnetic particle or dye penetrant testing to detect surface cracks.

The author does not mention these quality control measures explicitly, but they are essential for a successful repair.

Key Questions and Reflections

Why Did the Repair Work?

The paper reports that the repaired bell and hopper had a longer service life than the original. This is a significant finding, but the reasons are not fully explained.

One possible explanation is that the hardfacing alloy provides better wear resistance than the original material. The TDGC-1 alloy is a tungsten carbide-based material that is specifically designed for abrasive wear resistance. The original bell and hopper may have been made of a plain carbon steel or a low-alloy steel that did not have sufficient wear resistance.

Another possible explanation is that the hardfacing process improved the surface finish and the sealing performance. The surfacing weld can be ground and machined to a precise finish, which improves the seal.

What Are the Limitations of the Repair?

The repair has several limitations:

  1. The hardfacing layer is thin - The surfacing weld is typically 3-5mm thick, which limits the service life. Once the hardfacing layer is worn through, the repair must be repeated.
  2. The hardfacing layer is brittle - The carbide alloy is hard but brittle, and it may crack under impact loading.
  3. The repair is labor-intensive - Surfacing welding is a slow process, and the repair requires skilled welders.

The Role of the Welding Procedure

The welding procedure is critical to the success of the repair. The author emphasizes the importance of preheat, interpass temperature, and the use of the asbestos insulation blanket. These are all measures to control the thermal cycle and prevent cracking.

In practice, the welding procedure must be qualified before the repair is performed. This involves welding test coupons, performing mechanical tests, and verifying that the properties of the deposited metal meet the requirements.

Study Insights and Implications

The Value of Practical Solutions

This paper is a good example of a practical solution to a real problem. The author did not conduct a comprehensive research program but instead applied known principles and techniques to solve a specific problem.

The key insight is that the repair was successful because it was based on a sound understanding of the failure modes and the welding process. The author understood that the bell and hopper fail due to abrasive wear, and he selected a hardfacing alloy that provides excellent abrasive wear resistance.

The Importance of Heat Control

The use of the asbestos insulation blanket is a practical example of heat control in surfacing welding. This technique is not widely known, but it is effective in preventing distortion and cracking.

The principle is simple: the insulation blanket reduces the temperature gradient, which reduces the thermal stress. This is particularly important for large components where the thermal stress can be significant.

The Need for Skilled Welders

Surfacing welding requires skilled welders who understand the process and the materials. The welder must be able to control the heat input, the bead placement, and the interpass temperature.

In many plants, the welders are trained in structural welding but not in surfacing welding. This can lead to problems, such as excessive dilution, lack of fusion, or cracking.

Reference Value and Outlook

Reference Value

This paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the maintenance of blast furnace charging equipment. It provides:

  1. A clear description of the failure modes of the bell and hopper.
  2. A practical solution using TDGC-1 carbide alloy and 667 electrode.
  3. A description of the welding procedure and the use of the asbestos insulation blanket.
  4. Data on the service life improvement.

Outlook

The use of hardfacing to extend the service life of blast furnace components is a well-established practice. However, the specific techniques and materials are constantly evolving.

Future developments may include:

  1. Improved hardfacing alloys - New alloys with better wear resistance and toughness.
  2. Automated hardfacing - Robotic systems that can apply hardfacing more consistently and efficiently.
  3. Composite hardfacing - The use of composite materials that combine hard particles with a tough matrix.

The technique described in this paper is a practical example of the application of hardfacing technology. It provides a baseline for future developments.

Summary

The application of TDGC-1 carbide alloy surfacing welding to extend the service life of the blast furnace bell and hopper is a practical and effective solution. The use of the 667 soft-core electrode to deposit a Stellite-type alloy provides excellent wear resistance, and the use of the asbestos insulation blanket controls the heat input and prevents distortion. The repair extended the service life of the bell and hopper significantly, demonstrating the value of hardfacing technology in extending the service life of wear-prone components. The key lessons are the importance of proper preheat and interpass temperature control, the value of heat control techniques such as the insulation blanket, and the need for skilled welders who understand the surfacing welding process. For engineers involved in blast furnace maintenance, this paper provides a practical reference for solving a common problem. The technique can be adapted to other wear-prone components, and the principles of heat control and material selection are broadly applicable. The main limitation is that the hardfacing layer is thin and brittle, so the repair must be repeated periodically, and the welding procedure must be carefully controlled to ensure the quality of the repair.