ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Multi-Pass Submerged Arc Surfacing: Microstructure and Property Development on 16Mn Steel

What the Paper Really Tells Us

This study by He Xiaofeng and colleagues from Shanghai University of Engineering Science is a classic piece of welding metallurgy work that every engineer responsible for cladding or hardfacing operations should read. The team deposited a single layer of metal on 16Mn steel thick plates using multi-pass submerged arc welding, then systematically examined how the thermal interaction between successive passes affects the heat-affected zone (HAZ), the weld metal microstructure, and the microhardness distribution.

The key finding is that the HAZ in both single-pass and multi-pass welds consists of three distinct zones: the incomplete normalizing zone, the normalizing zone, and the overheated zone. This is textbook behaviour for low-alloy structural steels, but what makes this work valuable is the careful documentation of how the subsequent passes modify the previously deposited weld metal. The weld metal itself is predominantly columnar dendritic structure with pro-eutectoid ferrite decorating the grain boundaries. When a later pass reheats an earlier pass, the grains grow somewhat. When an earlier pass is preheated by a later pass, the columnar growth is interrupted and equiaxed grains form.

Practical Implications for Cladding and Repair Operations

On the shop floor, this translates directly to how we plan the sequence of passes in any multi-layer cladding operation, whether it is for a pressure vessel internal surface, a wear plate, or a shaft repair. The thermal history of each weld bead is not independent. The interpass temperature, the bead sequence, and the travel speed all conspire to produce a final microstructure that is a patchwork of differently treated regions.

Zone Single-Pass Behaviour Multi-Pass Behaviour Practical Consequence
Incomplete normalizing zone Partial recrystallization Similar, but influenced by adjacent passes Hardness varies locally
Normalizing zone Fine-grained, improved toughness Re-normalized by subsequent passes Good toughness retained
Overheated zone Coarse grains, possible grain boundary ferrite Coarsening may continue if reheated Risk of reduced toughness
Weld metal columnar grains Columnar dendrites Reheated regions show grain growth Hardness drops in reheated zones
Weld metal equiaxed grains Not present in single pass Formed in preheated regions More uniform hardness

The hardness values are not uniform across the weld. They depend on the local cooling rate and the cumulative thermal input. This is not just an academic observation. When we are cladding a large vessel head or a thick-wall pipe end, we are often looking at hundreds of passes. If we do not control the interpass temperature carefully, we can end up with a cladding layer that has hard and soft bands running through it, which can lead to preferential corrosion or wear in service.

What the Shop Floor Cares About

In my experience, the practical questions that this paper helps answer are:

  1. What interpass temperature should we specify? The paper suggests that the thermal interaction is significant. For 16Mn, an interpass temperature in the range of 150 to 200°C is commonly used, but this must be verified against the specific cladding procedure.
  2. How do we ensure uniform hardness across a multi-pass cladding? The answer lies in controlling the heat input per pass and the bead overlap. If the overlap is too small, we get a scalloped hardness profile. If it is too large, we waste filler metal and risk excessive dilution.
  3. What happens if we stop and restart in the middle of a layer? The reheating effect described in the paper means that the restart region will have a different microstructure. This is a common source of localized soft zones in cladding.

Lessons from Real Projects

I recall a job where we were cladding the internal surface of a large separator vessel for a gas processing plant. The base material was 16MnR, and the cladding was a duplex stainless steel. We specified a multi-pass, multi-layer procedure. The first layer went down well, but the second layer developed a series of transverse cracks in the reheated zones. The investigation showed that the interpass temperature had crept up to over 300°C because the welder was working too fast and the cooling time between passes was too short. The reheated weld metal had a coarse, brittle microstructure, and the residual stresses from the thermal cycling were sufficient to initiate cracking.

The fix was simple: reduce the interpass temperature to 180°C, increase the cooling time between passes, and use a slightly lower heat input. The hardness profile across the cladding became much more uniform, and the cracks disappeared. This paper would have saved us a week of troubleshooting if we had read it before the job.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that is often overlooked: what is the actual service condition of the cladding? If the component is going to operate at elevated temperature, the reheated zones may undergo further microstructural changes. If it is going to be in a corrosive environment, the local hardness variations can create galvanic cells that accelerate attack.

Another point worth reflecting on is the role of the base material. 16Mn is a low-alloy steel with a carbon equivalent of about 0.35%. It is not particularly hardenable, but the HAZ can still be problematic if the cooling rate is too high. The paper shows that the overheated zone has a coarse microstructure, which is a potential weak point. In practice, we often specify a preheat of 100 to 150°C for 16Mn to slow the cooling rate and refine the HAZ.

Study Insights and Implications

The most important takeaway from this paper is that multi-pass welding is not simply the sum of single-pass welds. Each pass interacts with its neighbours, and the final microstructure is a complex function of the entire thermal history. This has direct implications for procedure qualification. When we qualify a cladding procedure, we must test the actual multi-pass configuration that will be used in production, not just a single pass.

For engineers involved in cladding, hardfacing, or repair welding, this paper is a reminder to think in terms of thermal cycles rather than individual passes. The interpass temperature, the bead sequence, and the heat input are all linked, and they all contribute to the final properties.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study is a solid contribution to the understanding of multi-pass submerged arc welding on low-alloy steel. It is particularly relevant for the fabrication of pressure vessels, heat exchangers, and pipe fittings where cladding is used to achieve corrosion resistance or wear resistance at a lower cost than using a solid alloy.

The work could be extended to other base materials and filler metals, and to different welding processes. For example, the same approach could be applied to electroslag cladding or laser cladding, where the thermal cycles are quite different. The industry would benefit from more studies that link the microstructure to actual service performance, rather than just hardness and grain size.

In my view, the paper is a good example of the kind of fundamental research that supports practical welding engineering. It does not give a complete answer, but it provides a framework for thinking about the problem. For a veteran engineer, it is a useful reference to have on the shelf.