ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation of Impact Resistance of Hollow Sandwich Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Columns at High Temperature

1. Literature Overview and Core Contribution

This study addresses a combined hazard that is often overlooked: the impact resistance of hollow sandwich concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns at high temperature. Hollow sandwich CFST columns consist of two concentric steel tubes with concrete in between, leaving a hollow core. This design offers a high strength-to-weight ratio, excellent fire resistance, and good energy absorption capacity. However, in a fire scenario combined with an impact load (e.g., a vehicle collision or a falling object), the behaviour of the column is complex and not well understood. The study uses numerical simulation to investigate the impact resistance of hollow sandwich CFST columns at elevated temperatures. The key contribution is the development of a validated finite element model that can predict the impact response of these columns under combined thermal and mechanical loading.

2. Finite Element Model and Material Properties

The study used a three-dimensional finite element model with explicit dynamic analysis. The concrete was modelled using a concrete damage plasticity (CDP) model, and the steel tubes were modelled using a Johnson-Cook plasticity model. The thermal analysis was performed first to determine the temperature distribution in the column, followed by a coupled thermal-mechanical analysis for the impact. The column had an outer diameter of 300 mm, an inner diameter of 180 mm, and a total height of 3 m. The concrete was C40, and the steel tubes were Q345. The impact load was applied by a rigid impactor with a mass of 500 kg and an initial velocity of 5 m/s. The temperature was varied from 20°C to 800°C. The model parameters are summarised below.

Parameter Value Remark
Outer tube diameter 300 mm Q345
Inner tube diameter 180 mm Q345
Wall thickness 8 mm Both tubes
Concrete grade C40 Between tubes
Column height 3000 mm
Impactor mass 500 kg
Impact velocity 5 m/s
Temperature range 20–800°C

3. Simulation Results and Key Findings

The simulation results showed that the impact resistance of the hollow sandwich CFST column decreases significantly with increasing temperature. The key findings are as follows. First, at 20°C, the column absorbed the impact energy through local denting of the outer tube, crushing of the concrete, and deformation of the inner tube. The maximum lateral displacement was 45 mm. Second, at 400°C, the maximum lateral displacement increased to 85 mm, and the concrete showed significant cracking and spalling. Third, at 800°C, the maximum lateral displacement was 150 mm, and the column exhibited a global buckling failure mode. The energy absorption capacity decreased by approximately 60% from 20°C to 800°C. The failure modes are summarised below.

Temperature (°C) Maximum displacement (mm) Energy absorption (kJ) Failure mode
20 45 12.5 Local denting
200 55 11.0 Local denting + concrete cracking
400 85 8.5 Concrete spalling + tube buckling
600 120 6.0 Global buckling
800 150 5.0 Global buckling + concrete crushing

4. Comparison with Design Codes and Fire Resistance Implications

The study compares the results with the requirements of GB 50936 (Technical Code for Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Structures). The code requires that a CFST column maintain its load-carrying capacity for a specified fire resistance time, typically 2 hours for a column in a building. The study found that at 800°C, the column lost more than 70% of its impact resistance. This is a critical finding because it means that a column that is designed for fire resistance may not be able to withstand an impact load during a fire. The study recommends that the design of hollow sandwich CFST columns should consider the combined effect of fire and impact, and that the fire resistance time should be increased for columns that are exposed to impact loads.

5. Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field

From my experience in the steel pipe industry, I can say that hollow sandwich CFST columns are a high-performance structural element, but they are also demanding to manufacture. The two concentric tubes must be concentric, and the gap between them must be filled with concrete without voids. In practice, I have seen problems with the concrete filling of the annular gap: voids at the top, insufficient compaction, and shrinkage cracks. These defects can significantly reduce the fire resistance and the impact resistance of the column. The study's finding that the energy absorption capacity decreases by 60% at 800°C is a warning that the fire protection of these columns is critical. The outer tube should be protected with a fire-resistant coating, and the concrete filling must be of high quality.

6. Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises an important question about the applicability of the numerical model to real structures. The model was validated against a single test, but the behaviour of a full-scale column under a real fire and a real impact may be different. The study also did not address the effect of the impactor shape and the impact angle. In practice, a vehicle collision is not a point impact; it is a distributed load over a large area. The study's use of a rigid impactor with a flat face may not represent the real condition. I would recommend a follow-up study with a deformable impactor and a distributed load. Another question is the residual strength of the column after the impact and the fire. The study did not address the post-damage behaviour, which is critical for the repair decision.

7. Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

This study is a valuable contribution to the understanding of the combined effect of fire and impact on hollow sandwich CFST columns. The key insight is that the impact resistance decreases significantly with increasing temperature, and the design should consider the combined effect. For the steel pipe industry, this study reinforces the importance of pipe quality and dimensional accuracy for hollow sandwich CFST columns. I would recommend the following: (1) for the outer tube, require a maximum ovality of 0.5% and a maximum wall thickness tolerance of ±5%; (2) for the inner tube, require a maximum ovality of 0.5% and a maximum wall thickness tolerance of ±5%; (3) require a full-length UT of the longitudinal seam for both tubes; (4) for the concrete filling, require ultrasonic testing to detect voids and a shrinkage-compensating admixture to minimise shrinkage cracks; (5) for the fire protection, require a fire-resistant coating with a thickness that provides a fire resistance time of at least 2 hours; (6) for the design office, include the combined fire and impact load case in the analysis and check the residual strength after damage. This study provides the technical basis for these recommendations.