Bending Performance of Internal and External Flange Connections in Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes
Literature Overview
This paper investigates the bending performance of two types of flange connections used in concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) structures: internal flanges and external flanges. The authors conducted a series of full-scale tests on CFST members with each type of connection, subjected them to bending loads, and compared the failure modes, the load-displacement curves, and the stiffness and strength of the connections.
For those of us who have supplied steel tubes and flanges for CFST structures, this paper is directly relevant. Flange connections are commonly used in CFST towers, masts, and other structures where the members are prefabricated and assembled on site. The choice between an internal flange and an external flange is a significant design decision, and it affects the cost, the fabrication complexity, and the structural performance.
Core Technical Points
1. The Two Types of Flange Connections
In a CFST member, a flange connection is used to join two segments of the steel tube. The flange is a plate that is welded to the end of the tube, and the two flanges are bolted together.
- An external flange is a plate that is welded to the outside of the tube. The bolt circle is outside the tube diameter. This is the more common type, because it is easier to fabricate and the bolts are accessible for tightening.
- An internal flange is a plate that is welded to the inside of the tube. The bolt circle is inside the tube diameter. This type is less common, because the bolts are not accessible for tightening, and the fabrication is more complex.
2. The Bending Performance
The paper's key finding is that the internal flange connection has a higher bending stiffness and a higher bending strength than the external flange connection, but it also has a lower ductility.
The reason is that the internal flange is closer to the neutral axis of the section, which means that the bolt forces are smaller for a given bending moment. However, the internal flange also creates a discontinuity in the concrete core, which can lead to a stress concentration and a premature failure.
The external flange, on the other hand, is farther from the neutral axis, which means that the bolt forces are larger for a given bending moment. This results in a lower stiffness and a lower strength, but the connection is more ductile, because the bolts can yield and redistribute the load.
3. The Effect of the Concrete Core
The paper also examines the effect of the concrete core on the bending performance. The concrete core provides a significant contribution to the bending stiffness and strength, but it also affects the behavior of the flange connection.
In a CFST member with an internal flange, the concrete core is continuous through the connection, which provides a load path for the compressive forces. In a member with an external flange, the concrete core is interrupted by the flange, which creates a discontinuity and a potential weakness.
The paper recommends that the concrete core should be continuous through the connection, and that the internal flange should be designed to allow the concrete to flow through it, using a series of holes or a ring with a larger opening.
Engineering Practice Implications
4. What This Means for the Fabricator
This paper has direct implications for the fabrication of CFST members with flange connections. The key practical points are:
- The internal flange is more difficult to fabricate than the external flange, because the weld is on the inside of the tube, and the access is limited. The welding procedure must be qualified for the specific joint configuration, and the welder must be able to access the joint.
- The internal flange requires a larger opening in the tube to allow the concrete to flow through. This opening must be designed to maintain the strength of the flange and the tube.
- The bolt holes in the internal flange must be accurately drilled, because the bolts are not accessible for tightening, and any misalignment will cause problems during assembly.
- The external flange is easier to fabricate, but it requires a larger flange plate and a larger bolt circle, which increases the material cost.
5. A Real Project Case
I recall a project where a CFST tower used external flange connections. The flanges were fabricated with a bolt circle that was too small for the required bolt size, and the bolts were overloaded during the assembly. The problem was detected during the tightening, and the flanges had to be replaced.
The lesson is that the flange design must be verified by calculation, not just by the fabrication drawing. The bolt size, the bolt circle, and the flange thickness must be checked against the applied loads, and the design must be reviewed by an independent engineer.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises an important question: what is the appropriate design method for flange connections in CFST members? The current standards provide design methods for flange connections in steel structures, but they do not account for the presence of the concrete core.
The paper's tests show that the concrete core has a significant effect on the bending performance, and that the design method should be modified to account for this effect. The paper proposes a simplified method that uses the composite section properties to calculate the bolt forces, but this method needs to be validated with more tests.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of flange connections in CFST structures. It provides experimental data on the bending performance of internal and external flanges, and it offers practical guidance for the design and fabrication of these connections.
For those of us in the pipe industry, the key takeaways are:
- The choice between an internal flange and an external flange is a significant design decision that affects the cost, the fabrication complexity, and the structural performance.
- The internal flange has a higher stiffness and strength, but it is more difficult to fabricate and it has a lower ductility.
- The external flange is easier to fabricate, but it requires a larger flange plate and a larger bolt circle.
- The concrete core has a significant effect on the bending performance, and the design method should account for this effect.
- The flange design must be verified by calculation, and the fabrication must be performed to tight tolerances.
The paper is a good example of the kind of research that supports the design and fabrication of CFST structures. It provides the experimental data and the practical guidance that engineers need to make informed decisions.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd