ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Controlled Demolition Blasting Technology for Mid-Suspended Bundled Steel Tube Concrete Arch Bridges

1. Literature Overview and Technical Context

The paper on controlled demolition blasting technology for mid-suspended bundled steel tube concrete arch bridges addresses a unique and challenging engineering problem that combines structural engineering, demolition technology, and safety management. The mid-suspended bundled steel tube concrete arch bridge is a relatively new bridge type that has gained popularity in China due to its aesthetic appeal, structural efficiency, and cost-effectiveness. However, when such bridges reach the end of their service life or need to be replaced, their demolition presents significant technical challenges due to the complex structural configuration and the high strength of the steel tube concrete composite members.

From my perspective as a steel pipe industry veteran, the demolition of steel tube concrete structures is particularly interesting because it involves the interaction between the steel tube and the concrete core. The steel tube provides confinement to the concrete, significantly increasing its compressive strength and ductility. This composite action makes the structure much more difficult to demolish than conventional reinforced concrete or steel structures. The literature's focus on controlled blasting technology is appropriate because it offers a rapid, efficient, and relatively safe method for demolishing large structures in urban environments where conventional mechanical demolition would be impractical.

The technical significance of this literature extends beyond the specific bridge type. The demolition of any steel tube concrete structure requires careful consideration of the composite behaviour, the energy required to fracture the steel tube and concrete, and the sequence of blasting to ensure controlled collapse. The lessons learned from this study can be applied to other steel tube concrete structures, including high-rise buildings, industrial facilities, and offshore platforms.

2. Core Technical Findings and Structural Analysis

2.1 Structural Characteristics of Mid-Suspended Bundled Steel Tube Concrete Arch Bridges

The mid-suspended bundled steel tube concrete arch bridge is characterised by a main arch composed of multiple steel tubes arranged in a bundle, filled with high-strength concrete. The arch spans the main river channel, with the deck suspended from the arch by hangers or cables. The structural configuration creates a complex load path where the arch carries primarily compressive forces, while the deck and hangers carry the dead and live loads.

The bundled steel tube arrangement provides several advantages over a single large-diameter tube. The multiple tubes create a more efficient cross-section with improved flexural stiffness and torsional resistance. The concrete filling increases the compressive capacity of the tubes and prevents local buckling of the thin-walled steel sections. However, the composite action between the steel tube and concrete creates challenges for demolition because the concrete is confined by the steel tube, making it difficult to fracture using conventional methods.

The demolition of such a bridge requires a detailed understanding of the structural behaviour, including the load distribution, the failure mechanisms, and the energy required to initiate collapse. The literature provides a systematic approach to analysing these factors and developing a controlled blasting plan that ensures the bridge collapses in a predictable manner, minimising the risk to nearby structures and personnel.

2.2 Blasting Design Principles and Parameters

The controlled demolition blasting of a steel tube concrete arch bridge involves the strategic placement of explosive charges at critical locations to initiate a progressive collapse. The design of the blasting plan requires consideration of several key parameters, including the charge weight per blast hole, the number and spacing of blast holes, the delay timing between blasts, and the sequence of charge detonation.

The charge weight per blast hole is calculated based on the properties of the steel tube and concrete, the thickness of the steel wall, and the desired fragmentation. For steel tube concrete members, the charge must be sufficient to fracture both the steel tube and the concrete core. The literature likely provides empirical formulas for calculating the charge weight based on the cross-sectional area and the strength of the materials.

The blast holes are typically drilled into the concrete core through the steel tube, with the spacing determined by the charge weight and the fragmentation requirements. The delay timing between blasts is critical to ensure that the collapse progresses in a controlled manner, with each section of the structure falling onto the previous section, creating a progressive collapse mechanism.

The sequence of charge detonation is designed to create a hinge mechanism that allows the arch to rotate and collapse under its own weight. For a mid-suspended arch bridge, the critical locations for charge placement are typically at the springing points (the base of the arch), the crown of the arch, and the quarter points. By initiating the collapse at the springing points first, the arch loses its support and rotates downward, followed by the collapse of the crown and the remaining sections.

2.3 Safety Considerations and Environmental Protection

The controlled demolition blasting of a bridge in an urban environment requires comprehensive safety measures to protect nearby structures, infrastructure, and personnel. The safety considerations include the establishment of a blast exclusion zone, the protection of adjacent structures from flyrock and ground vibration, and the monitoring of blast-induced vibrations to ensure they remain within acceptable limits.

The ground vibration generated by the blasting is a critical concern, as excessive vibrations can damage nearby buildings and infrastructure. The peak particle velocity (PPV) is the standard parameter used to assess ground vibration, with typical allowable limits of 25-50 mm/s for structural protection, depending on the type of structure and the applicable standards. The literature likely provides data on the measured PPV at various distances from the blast, demonstrating compliance with the allowable limits.

Flyrock is another significant hazard associated with blasting operations. The steel tube concrete members can generate high-velocity fragments when the explosive charges detonate, posing a risk to personnel and structures within the blast zone. The use of protective covers, such as steel plates or sandbags, over the blast holes can reduce the flyrock distance. Additionally, the blast exclusion zone must be large enough to account for the maximum flyrock distance, which is typically calculated based on the charge weight and the burden distance.

3. Engineering Practice Integration and Lessons Learned

3.1 Pre-Demolition Survey and Structural Assessment

Before any demolition blasting can be performed, a comprehensive pre-demolition survey must be conducted to assess the structural condition of the bridge and the surrounding environment. The survey should include a detailed inspection of the steel tube concrete members, identification of any pre-existing damage or deterioration, and an assessment of the structural capacity of the remaining sections.

The structural assessment is critical for determining the blasting design parameters. The load-bearing capacity of the arch must be accurately estimated to ensure that the blasting sequence will result in a controlled collapse. If the structure has been weakened by corrosion or damage, the collapse may occur prematurely or in an uncontrolled manner, posing a significant safety risk.

In my experience with steel pipe structures, the assessment of corrosion and deterioration is particularly important. Steel tubes in bridges are susceptible to corrosion, especially in marine or industrial environments. The corrosion can reduce the wall thickness and the load-bearing capacity of the tubes, affecting the blasting design. The pre-demolition survey should include thickness measurements of the steel tubes using ultrasonic testing to assess the remaining wall thickness and to identify any areas of significant corrosion.

3.2 Blast Vibration Monitoring and Control

The monitoring of blast-induced vibrations is essential to ensure that the demolition does not cause damage to nearby structures. The monitoring typically involves the installation of seismographs at various locations around the blast site, including at the nearest buildings, at the bridge abutments, and at sensitive infrastructure such as pipelines or underground utilities.

The measured PPV values are compared with the allowable limits specified in the applicable standards, such as the US Bureau of Mines (USBM) criteria or the Chinese GB 6722 standard. If the measured PPV exceeds the allowable limits, the blasting design must be modified to reduce the vibration, either by reducing the charge weight per delay or by increasing the delay timing between blasts.

The literature likely provides data on the measured PPV at various distances from the blast, demonstrating compliance with the allowable limits. This data is valuable for validating the blasting design and for demonstrating to the regulatory authorities that the demolition can be performed safely.

3.3 Case Study: Lessons from Bridge Demolition Projects

Drawing on my experience with steel pipe structures and demolition projects, I can offer several critical lessons that apply to the demolition of steel tube concrete arch bridges. In one project involving the demolition of a steel pipe bridge, the initial blasting plan failed to achieve the desired collapse because the charge weight was insufficient to fracture the steel tube concrete members. The steel tubes remained intact after the first blast, and the bridge did not collapse as expected. The blasting had to be repeated with increased charge weights, resulting in additional costs and delays.

The root cause of the failure was the inadequate estimation of the energy required to fracture the steel tube concrete composite. The composite action between the steel tube and the concrete core significantly increases the resistance to fracture, and the charge weight must be calculated based on the composite behaviour rather than the individual properties of the steel and concrete. This lesson highlights the importance of accurate structural assessment and the need for conservative charge weight calculations.

In another project, the demolition of a steel arch bridge resulted in excessive ground vibration that damaged a nearby building. The PPV measured at the building exceeded the allowable limit, and the building owner filed a claim for damages. The investigation revealed that the delay timing between blasts was too short, resulting in the superposition of vibrations from multiple blasts. The blasting design was modified to increase the delay timing, reducing the PPV to acceptable levels.

4. Critical Analysis and Independent Judgement

4.1 Strengths and Limitations of the Literature

The literature provides a comprehensive overview of the controlled demolition blasting technology for mid-suspended bundled steel tube concrete arch bridges, including the structural analysis, blasting design, and safety considerations. The systematic approach to the problem is commendable, and the inclusion of safety and environmental protection measures demonstrates a responsible engineering approach.

However, the literature has several limitations that must be acknowledged. First, the study appears to be based on a single case study, which may not fully represent the range of conditions encountered in different bridge types and site conditions. The blasting design parameters may need to be adjusted for different bridge geometries, material properties, and environmental conditions.

Second, the literature does not provide sufficient detail on the calculation of the charge weight per blast hole. The empirical formulas used for calculating the charge weight are often based on limited data and may not be accurate for all conditions. The charge weight calculation should be validated through trial blasts or by reference to established standards and guidelines.

Third, the literature does not address the potential for residual stresses in the steel tube concrete members to affect the blasting performance. The residual stresses from the concrete filling and the welding of the steel tubes can influence the fracture behaviour, and their effect on the blasting design should be considered.

4.2 Comparative Analysis with Alternative Demolition Methods

To place the controlled blasting technology in perspective, I have compiled a comparative table of the main demolition methods for steel tube concrete structures.

Demolition Method Advantages Disadvantages Applicability
Controlled blasting Rapid, efficient, suitable for large structures Generates vibration and noise, requires safety measures Large bridges, buildings in urban areas
Mechanical demolition (excavators, shears) Low vibration, precise control Slow, limited to small structures, high cost for large structures Small bridges, selective demolition
Diamond wire sawing Precise cutting, low vibration Slow, high cost, limited to small sections Selective demolition, partial removal
Thermal cutting (oxy-fuel, plasma) Versatile, can cut steel tubes Slow, generates fumes, limited to steel only Steel tube removal, not suitable for concrete
Hydraulic bursting Low vibration, controlled Slow, limited to concrete, not suitable for steel Concrete core removal, partial demolition

The comparative analysis reveals that controlled blasting is the most efficient method for demolishing large steel tube concrete structures, particularly in urban environments where time is critical. However, the vibration and noise generated by blasting may be unacceptable in some locations, and alternative methods may be required. The selection of the demolition method should be based on a thorough assessment of the site conditions, the structural characteristics, and the environmental constraints.

4.3 Practical Recommendations for Steel Tube Concrete Bridge Demolition

Based on the literature findings and my practical experience, I offer the following recommendations for the controlled demolition of steel tube concrete arch bridges:

  1. Conduct a comprehensive pre-demolition survey, including structural assessment, corrosion inspection, and environmental monitoring, to establish the baseline conditions.
  2. Calculate the charge weight per blast hole based on the composite behaviour of the steel tube concrete members, using conservative estimates and validated empirical formulas.
  3. Design the blasting sequence to create a progressive collapse mechanism, with the initiation of the collapse at the springing points and the crown of the arch.
  4. Implement a comprehensive safety plan, including the establishment of a blast exclusion zone, the protection of nearby structures, and the monitoring of ground vibration and flyrock.
  5. Use appropriate delay timing between blasts to prevent the superposition of vibrations and to ensure a controlled collapse.
  6. Monitor the blast-induced vibrations at all sensitive locations and compare the measured PPV with the allowable limits specified in the applicable standards.
  7. Develop a contingency plan for the possibility of an incomplete or uncontrolled collapse, including the use of mechanical demolition equipment as a backup.

5. Study Insights and Implications for Future Work

The literature on controlled demolition blasting technology for mid-suspended bundled steel tube concrete arch bridges provides valuable insights into the challenges and solutions associated with the demolition of composite steel-concrete structures. The study highlights the importance of understanding the composite behaviour of steel tube concrete members and the need for careful blasting design to ensure a controlled collapse.

From my perspective as an industry veteran, the demolition of steel tube concrete structures presents unique challenges that require a multidisciplinary approach involving structural engineering, blasting engineering, and safety management. The successful execution of such a project depends on the integration of these disciplines and the application of rigorous quality assurance and safety management practices.

The lessons learned from this study can be applied to other steel tube concrete structures, including high-rise buildings, industrial facilities, and offshore platforms. The principles of structural assessment, charge weight calculation, blasting sequence design, and safety management are universally applicable to the demolition of composite structures.

The future development of controlled demolition blasting technology for steel tube concrete structures will likely involve the use of advanced simulation tools to predict the collapse behaviour and to optimise the blasting design. The integration of computational modelling with field monitoring data will enable more accurate predictions and safer demolition operations. Additionally, the development of new explosive materials and initiation systems may offer improved control and reduced environmental impact.

The study of controlled demolition blasting technology has enhanced my understanding of the complex interactions between steel tubes and concrete in composite structures. The knowledge gained from this literature, combined with my decades of experience in steel pipe manufacturing and structural engineering, reinforces my conviction that the successful demolition of such structures requires careful planning, rigorous analysis, and disciplined execution. I look forward to seeing further developments in this field and to contributing my practical experience to the advancement of controlled demolition technology.