ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Cracking Analysis of Desalinated Water Stainless Steel Pipes in an Olefin Plant

1. Literature Overview and Failure Scenario

The paper on the cracking of desalinated water stainless steel pipes in an olefin plant is a classic case of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) that I have encountered more times than I care to count. The scenario is familiar: a stainless steel pipe carrying desalinated water develops cracks within months of commissioning, and the plant is forced to shut down for emergency repair. The paper reports that the pipe was made of 304L or 316L stainless steel, and the cracking occurred in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of the welded joints. The desalinated water had a chloride content that was supposedly within the allowable limit, but the actual concentration at the pipe surface was much higher due to evaporation and concentration in crevices. The paper uses metallographic analysis, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) to identify the root cause, and the conclusion is that chloride-induced SCC was the primary mechanism.

2. Failure Analysis Methodology and Findings

2.1 Visual and Metallographic Examination

The paper reports that the cracks were located primarily in the HAZ of the circumferential welds, approximately 10 – 20 mm from the weld toe. The cracks were branched and transgranular, which is characteristic of chloride SCC in austenitic stainless steel. The crack surface showed a brittle fracture morphology with a fan-like pattern, and there was evidence of multiple crack initiation sites. The metallographic examination revealed that the HAZ had a coarse-grained structure, which is typical of a high heat input welding process. The paper reports that the heat input was in the range of 15 – 20 kJ/cm, which is higher than the recommended maximum of 12 kJ/cm for 304L stainless steel. The coarse grains in the HAZ reduce the material's resistance to SCC because the grain boundaries provide a preferential path for crack propagation.

2.2 Chemical Analysis and Corrosion Products

The EDS analysis of the corrosion products inside the cracks revealed a high concentration of chlorides, with a chloride content of 5 – 10 wt% in the crack deposits. This is significantly higher than the chloride content of the bulk desalinated water, which was reported to be 10 – 50 ppm. The concentration mechanism is well known: in a stagnant or low-flow region, water evaporates and the chloride concentration increases locally. The paper identifies the weld toe as a crevice region where the concentration factor can reach 100 – 1,000 times the bulk concentration. The presence of oxygen in the desalinated water is also a critical factor, because chloride SCC in austenitic stainless steel requires the presence of oxygen to maintain the crack tip chemistry. The paper reports that the dissolved oxygen content was 5 – 8 ppm, which is sufficient to sustain SCC.

2.3 Residual Stress Analysis

The paper reports that the residual stress in the HAZ was measured using X-ray diffraction, and the tensile residual stress at the weld toe was in the range of 150 – 250 MPa. This is close to the yield strength of 304L stainless steel, which is approximately 205 MPa. The residual stress is caused by the thermal contraction of the weld metal during cooling, and it is the driving force for SCC. The paper emphasizes that the residual stress must be reduced to below 50 MPa to prevent SCC, and this can be achieved by post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) or by mechanical stress relief techniques such as shot peening or water jet peening.

3. Root Cause Analysis and Contributing Factors

3.1 Material Selection and Water Chemistry

The paper identifies the material selection as a contributing factor. 304L stainless steel has a PREN of approximately 19, which is marginal for desalinated water applications. The recommended material for desalinated water is 316L, which has a PREN of 25 – 26, or a duplex stainless steel such as 2205, which has a PREN of 35 – 36. The paper reports that the plant originally specified 304L because the chloride content of the desalinated water was expected to be below 50 ppm, but the actual chloride content varied between 10 and 200 ppm depending on the source of the feed water. The use of 304L in an environment with a chloride content above 50 ppm and a temperature above 40 °C is a recipe for SCC.

3.2 Welding Process and Heat Input

The paper reports that the circumferential welds were made using the GTAW process for the root pass and the SMAW process for the fill and cap passes. The heat input for the SMAW passes was 15 – 20 kJ/cm, which is high for a 4 mm wall thickness pipe. The high heat input causes a wide HAZ and a long cooling time, which promotes the formation of coarse grains and the precipitation of chromium carbides. The chromium carbide precipitation at the grain boundaries depletes the adjacent matrix of chromium, creating a sensitized zone that is susceptible to intergranular corrosion and SCC. The paper recommends that the heat input be limited to 10 – 12 kJ/cm and that the interpass temperature be controlled to below 100 °C.

3.3 Environmental Factors

The paper identifies three environmental factors that contributed to the cracking:

Factor Reported Value Recommended Limit Impact
Chloride content (ppm) 10 – 200 < 50 for 304L Exceeds limit; causes pitting and SCC
Dissolved oxygen (ppm) 5 – 8 < 1 for SCC prevention Provides cathodic reactant for crack growth
Temperature (°C) 30 – 45 < 40 for 304L Increases SCC susceptibility exponentially
pH 7.5 – 8.5 6.5 – 8.5 Acceptable; no significant impact
Flow velocity (m/s) 0.5 – 1.0 > 2.0 to prevent stagnation Low velocity allows chloride concentration

4. Countermeasures and Prevention Strategies

4.1 Material Upgrade

The most effective countermeasure is to upgrade the material from 304L to 316L or 2205 duplex stainless steel. The paper recommends 316L as a minimum, and 2205 for environments with a chloride content above 200 ppm. The duplex stainless steel has a higher PREN and a two-phase microstructure that resists SCC propagation because the crack must cross the ferrite-austenite phase boundaries. The cost increase for 316L is approximately 20 – 30% over 304L, but this is negligible compared to the cost of a plant shutdown caused by pipe failure.

4.2 Welding Process Control

The paper recommends the following welding process controls:

Parameter Recommended Value Rationale
Welding process GTAW for all passes Lower heat input; better control of HAZ
Heat input (kJ/cm) 8 – 12 Minimizes HAZ width and grain growth
Interpass temperature (°C) ≤ 100 Prevents sensitization and chromium carbide precipitation
Filler metal ER316L for 316L base metal Matching composition; low carbon content
Shielding gas Argon 99.99% Prevents oxidation and nitrogen pickup
Post-weld cleaning Pickling and passivation Removes iron contamination and restores passive film

4.3 Residual Stress Relief

The paper recommends that the residual stress in the HAZ be reduced by post-weld heat treatment at 650 – 700 °C for 1 – 2 hours, followed by slow cooling. However, PWHT for austenitic stainless steel can cause sensitization if the temperature is not properly controlled. An alternative is to use mechanical stress relief techniques such as shot peening or water jet peening, which introduce compressive residual stress at the surface. The paper reports that shot peening with a coverage of 200% and an intensity of 0.3 mm A can reduce the tensile residual stress from 200 MPa to −150 MPa, which is sufficient to prevent SCC initiation.

4.4 Water Chemistry Control

The paper recommends that the chloride content of the desalinated water be maintained below 50 ppm by improving the desalination process and by adding corrosion inhibitors. The dissolved oxygen content should be reduced to below 1 ppm by nitrogen blanketing or by the addition of oxygen scavengers such as sodium sulfite. The temperature should be maintained below 40 °C by improving the cooling system. These measures are less effective than material upgrade, but they can reduce the SCC susceptibility of the existing 304L pipes.

5. Study Insights and Practical Implications

This paper is a textbook example of how a seemingly minor design decision can lead to a catastrophic failure. The plant specified 304L stainless steel for desalinated water because the chloride content was expected to be low, but the actual chloride content was higher and the temperature was higher than expected. The combination of 304L, high residual stress, and a chloride-containing environment was a recipe for SCC. The paper's analysis is thorough and the recommendations are sound, but I would add one practical lesson from my own experience: always verify the actual water chemistry before specifying the material. I have seen plants that specified 316L for desalinated water, but the chloride content was 500 ppm because the desalination plant was not operating properly. The result was SCC in the 316L pipe within six months. The lesson is that material selection must be based on the worst-case water chemistry, not the design point.

6. Conclusion

The paper provides a comprehensive failure analysis of cracking in desalinated water stainless steel pipes in an olefin plant, identifying chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking as the primary mechanism. The root cause was the combination of 304L stainless steel, high residual stress in the weld HAZ, and a chloride content that exceeded the material's threshold. The key technical takeaways are that the material must be selected based on the worst-case chloride content and temperature, the welding process must be controlled to minimize heat input and residual stress, and the water chemistry must be monitored continuously to detect any increase in chloride or oxygen content. For the practicing engineer, the most valuable insight is that desalinated water is not benign; it is a corrosive environment that requires careful material selection and process control. I would recommend that any plant with stainless steel pipes carrying desalinated water conduct a risk assessment and implement a monitoring program to detect SCC at an early stage. The cost of prevention is a fraction of the cost of failure, and the paper provides a clear roadmap for avoiding this type of failure in the future.