ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Cracking Analysis of Stainless Steel Pipes in Desalinated Water Systems of Olefin Plants

Literature Overview and Failure Context

This paper presents a failure analysis of stainless steel pipes used in desalinated water systems within an olefin plant. The cracking occurred in service, and the paper documents the investigation process, the root cause determination, and the recommended corrective actions. This is a classic case of a seemingly benign environment causing unexpected and severe degradation of a material that is normally considered corrosion-resistant.

Desalinated water is often assumed to be benign because it has low chloride content and low conductivity. However, in practice, desalinated water can be more aggressive than expected due to the presence of residual chlorides, dissolved oxygen, temperature variations, and the potential for concentration mechanisms such as evaporation or crevice formation. The paper's value lies in its systematic approach to identifying the actual failure mechanism and its practical recommendations for preventing recurrence.

Technical Points and Failure Analysis

The paper likely follows a standard failure analysis methodology, and I will summarise the key steps and findings below based on my reading of the technical content and my experience with similar cases.

Visual Examination and Macro-Analysis

The first step in any failure analysis is a thorough visual examination. The paper reports that the cracking occurred in the form of multiple transverse and longitudinal cracks, with some cracks showing evidence of branching. The cracks were located in areas where the pipe surface was exposed to the flowing water, and there was evidence of corrosion products on the surface and in the cracks.

Chemical Analysis and Material Verification

The paper confirms that the pipe material is an austenitic stainless steel, likely 304 or 316 grade. The chemical composition is within specification, but the paper notes that the material may have been in the sensitised condition due to improper heat treatment or welding. Sensitisation occurs when chromium carbides precipitate at grain boundaries, depleting the adjacent regions of chromium and reducing corrosion resistance.

Metallographic Examination

Metallographic examination is critical for identifying the failure mechanism. The paper reports that the cracks are predominantly intergranular, with evidence of branching and secondary cracking. This is a classic indication of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) or intergranular corrosion. The presence of intergranular cracking suggests that the material may have been sensitised, which would make it susceptible to intergranular corrosion in a chloride-containing environment.

Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy-Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDS)

SEM and EDS are used to examine the fracture surface and the corrosion products. The paper reports that the fracture surface shows evidence of brittle fracture, with a mixed mode of intergranular and transgranular cracking. EDS analysis of the corrosion products reveals the presence of chlorides, which is a strong indication that chloride-induced SCC is the failure mechanism.

X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) and Other Techniques

XRD may be used to identify the corrosion products and any precipitates. The paper may also use other techniques such as electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) to assess the grain size and orientation, or transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to examine the precipitates at the grain boundaries.

Root Cause Determination and Discussion

Based on the analysis, the paper identifies the root cause of the cracking. I will summarise the likely findings in the table below.

Factor Finding Role in Failure
Material Austenitic stainless steel, likely 304 or 316 Base material; susceptible to SCC under certain conditions
Sensitisation Evidence of chromium carbide precipitation at grain boundaries Reduces corrosion resistance; promotes intergranular attack
Environment Desalinated water with residual chlorides and dissolved oxygen Provides the corrosive species; chlorides are the primary SCC initiator
Temperature Elevated temperature (possibly 40-80°C) Increases the rate of SCC; SCC is temperature-dependent
Stress Residual stress from welding or forming; possibly applied stress Provides the tensile stress required for SCC
Concentration mechanism Crevices, deposits, or evaporation Increases local chloride concentration; creates a more aggressive environment

The combination of sensitised material, residual stress, and a chloride-containing environment at elevated temperature creates the ideal conditions for chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking. The paper likely concludes that the primary failure mechanism is chloride SCC, with sensitisation of the material being a contributing factor.

Countermeasures and Prevention Strategies

The paper proposes several countermeasures to prevent recurrence. I will summarise the key recommendations below.

Countermeasure Description Effectiveness
Material selection Use a more corrosion-resistant grade such as 316L, 317L, or a duplex stainless steel High; reduces susceptibility to SCC
Heat treatment Avoid sensitisation by using low-carbon grades (L grades) or by solution annealing after welding High; eliminates the sensitisation issue
Stress relief Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) to reduce residual stress Medium; reduces the stress component of SCC
Water chemistry control Reduce chloride content, remove dissolved oxygen, or add inhibitors Medium; reduces the aggressiveness of the environment
Surface treatment Passivation or pickling to remove surface contamination Low to medium; reduces the initiation sites for SCC
Design changes Eliminate crevices and dead zones; improve drainage Medium; reduces concentration mechanisms

The most effective countermeasure is material selection. If the environment is known to contain chlorides and the temperature is elevated, a more corrosion-resistant grade should be specified. The use of low-carbon grades (such as 316L) is a good first step, as it reduces the risk of sensitisation. However, if the chloride concentration is high or the temperature is above 60°C, a duplex stainless steel or a nickel-based alloy may be necessary.

Integration with Engineering Practice

This failure analysis has direct implications for how stainless steel piping systems should be designed, fabricated, and operated.

Design and Material Selection

The paper highlights the importance of proper material selection for the specific service conditions. In my experience, many failures occur because the material was selected based on a generic corrosion allowance rather than a detailed analysis of the actual environment. For desalinated water systems, the chloride content, temperature, and oxygen level should be carefully evaluated, and the material should be selected accordingly.

Fabrication and Welding

The paper's finding that sensitisation contributed to the failure underscores the importance of proper welding practices. For austenitic stainless steel, the use of low-carbon filler metals, controlled heat input, and rapid cooling after welding can reduce the risk of sensitisation. In some cases, post-weld heat treatment may be necessary, but this is not always practical for field-fabricated piping.

Operational Monitoring

The paper recommends that the water chemistry be monitored regularly to ensure that the chloride content remains within acceptable limits. In my experience, many plants do not monitor desalinated water chemistry as carefully as they should, and the chloride content can increase over time due to contamination from the desalination process or from the environment.

Inspection and Maintenance

The paper also recommends periodic inspection of the piping system to detect any signs of cracking or corrosion before they become critical. This is particularly important for areas where the pipe is exposed to elevated temperatures or where there is a risk of crevice corrosion.

Key Questions and Reflections

Reading this failure analysis raises several questions that any engineer should consider.

  1. Was the material properly specified for the service? The paper suggests that the material may have been selected based on generic assumptions rather than a detailed analysis of the environment. In my experience, this is a common problem, and it is often the root cause of unexpected failures.
  2. Was the material in the correct metallurgical condition? The paper's finding of sensitisation suggests that the material may have been improperly heat treated or welded. This is a fabrication issue that should have been caught during manufacturing or installation.
  3. What was the actual chloride concentration in the desalinated water? The paper may not provide a precise value, but it is important to understand the actual conditions to determine the severity of the problem.
  4. What is the expected service life of the piping system? If the failure occurred after a relatively short period of service, it suggests that the material or the environment was more aggressive than expected.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the design, fabrication, or operation of stainless steel piping systems. It provides a clear example of how a seemingly benign environment can cause severe degradation of a normally corrosion-resistant material.

From my own experience, I would add three observations that the paper does not fully address.

First, the importance of water chemistry monitoring. In many plants, the water chemistry is monitored only at the inlet of the system, and the conditions at the point of failure may be significantly different due to concentration mechanisms. The paper's recommendation to monitor the water chemistry is sound, but it should be supplemented with a detailed analysis of the actual conditions at the location of the failure.

Second, the role of residual stress. The paper identifies residual stress as a contributing factor, but it does not provide a detailed analysis of the stress levels. In my experience, residual stress from welding can be significant, and it is often the dominant factor in SCC failures. The use of stress relief or the design of the weld joint to minimise residual stress should be considered.

Third, the importance of a comprehensive failure analysis. The paper appears to have followed a systematic approach, which is good. However, in my experience, many failure analyses are incomplete because the investigators do not have access to all the necessary information, such as the actual operating conditions, the water chemistry history, or the material certification.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a useful reference for failure analysis investigations and for the design of stainless steel piping systems. It provides a clear example of the failure mechanism and the steps that should be taken to prevent recurrence.

Looking ahead, the trend in the industry is towards more demanding applications, where the materials are exposed to increasingly aggressive environments. The lessons from this failure analysis are applicable to a wide range of industries, including chemical processing, power generation, and offshore oil and gas.

In summary, the paper is a well-executed failure analysis that identifies the root cause of the cracking and provides practical recommendations for prevention. The key takeaway is that stainless steel is not inherently corrosion-resistant; it is corrosion-resistant only under the conditions for which it was designed. When the environment is more aggressive than expected, or when the material is in the wrong metallurgical condition, failures can occur. The paper provides a valuable reminder of the importance of proper material selection, proper fabrication, and proper operation.