ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Circular Concrete-Filled Double-Skin Steel Tube Long Columns After Lateral Impact: Residual Vertical Bearing Capacity and Assessment Practice

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The study investigates the residual vertical bearing capacity of circular concrete-filled double-skin steel tube (CFDST) long columns after they have been subjected to a lateral impact, such as a vehicle collision or a ship impact. The CFDST column consists of an outer steel tube, an inner steel tube, and a concrete layer between them. This section is efficient in both bending and compression, and it is increasingly used in bridge piers and building columns. The literature reports that after a lateral impact, the column suffers local denting of the outer tube, ovalization of the cross-section, and cracking of the concrete layer. The residual vertical capacity is reduced by 15–40% depending on the impact energy and the impact location. The key finding is that the reduction in capacity is primarily due to the loss of confinement in the concrete layer, which occurs because the outer tube is dented and can no longer provide the same hoop stress. The inner tube, if it remains undamaged, provides some residual confinement, but the overall capacity is significantly reduced. The literature also reports that the residual capacity is higher if the impact occurs at the mid-height of the column, because the bending moment is highest there and the damage is more localised, whereas an impact near the base causes more global damage and a greater reduction in capacity.

Technical Points: Impact Damage Modes and Residual Capacity

The damage modes after a lateral impact are well-defined. The outer tube suffers a local dent, which reduces its cross-sectional area and creates a stress concentration. The concrete layer cracks, and the cracks propagate from the impact point outward. The inner tube may suffer a smaller dent or may remain undamaged, depending on the impact energy. The ovalization of the cross-section reduces the moment of inertia and the axial capacity. The residual capacity is governed by the extent of the dent, the depth of the concrete cracking, and the residual confinement provided by the inner tube. The table below summarises typical damage parameters and the resulting reduction in residual capacity.

Damage Parameter Typical Range Effect on Residual Capacity
Dent depth in outer tube 5–20% of diameter Deeper dent reduces capacity by 10–30%
Ovalization ratio 2–8% Higher ovalization reduces moment of inertia and capacity
Concrete crack depth 10–50% of layer thickness Deeper cracks reduce confinement and capacity
Impact energy 100–500 kJ Higher energy causes more damage and lower residual capacity
Impact location Mid-height vs. base Mid-height impact causes localised damage; base impact causes global damage
Residual capacity ratio 0.60–0.85 Lower ratio indicates more severe damage

Inspection and Repair: Field Assessment After Impact

After a lateral impact, the first step is a visual inspection to assess the extent of the damage. The dent depth and the ovalization should be measured with a straightedge and a caliper or a laser scanner. The concrete cracking can be assessed by tapping the outer tube and listening for a hollow sound, which indicates that the concrete has debonded from the tube. Ultrasonic testing (UT) can be used to detect cracks in the concrete, but it is difficult to interpret the results because the steel tube interferes with the signal. A more reliable method is to use a low-strain integrity test, which measures the velocity of the stress wave through the column. If the wave velocity is reduced, it indicates that the concrete is cracked or debonded. The residual capacity can be estimated using the empirical formulas from the literature, but the most reliable assessment is a load test. However, a load test is expensive and may not be feasible on site. In practice, we have used a combination of visual inspection, UT and a simplified analytical model to estimate the residual capacity. If the dent depth is less than 5% of the diameter and the concrete is not debonded, the column can be repaired by grinding the dent and welding a patch plate over it. If the dent is deeper than 10% of the diameter, the column may need to be replaced. The repair procedure must include a careful assessment of the weld quality, because the patch plate weld must be able to transfer the load. A common mistake is to weld the patch plate without preheating, which can cause hydrogen-induced cracking in the high-strength steel.

Reflections and Lessons

The literature provides a valuable framework for assessing the residual capacity of CFDST columns after impact, but it does not address the practical challenges of inspection and repair on site. In my experience, the most difficult part is to determine the extent of the concrete damage. The outer tube hides the concrete, and the only way to assess the damage is through indirect methods. We have used a combination of UT and a low-strain integrity test, but the results are not always conclusive. Another practical issue is the repair of the outer tube. If the dent is shallow, we can grind it and weld a patch plate, but the weld must be made by a qualified welder and inspected by MT or UT. If the dent is deep, the column may need to be replaced, which is a major operation that requires the column to be unloaded and the structure to be supported. The cost of the repair or replacement must be weighed against the cost of the downtime. In some cases, it may be more economical to replace the column than to repair it, especially if the damage is extensive. The literature also does not address the effect of repeated impacts. If a column is hit once and repaired, and then hit again, the residual capacity may be lower than expected because the repair may not restore the full confinement. This is a concern for bridge piers in areas with high traffic or ship traffic.

Summary

Circular concrete-filled double-skin steel tube columns are an efficient structural solution, but they are vulnerable to lateral impact damage that can significantly reduce their residual vertical bearing capacity. The damage modes are well-defined, and the residual capacity can be estimated using empirical formulas, but the practical assessment of the damage is challenging because the outer tube hides the concrete. A combination of visual inspection, UT and a low-strain integrity test is the most reliable approach, but the results must be interpreted by an experienced engineer. The repair of a damaged column is possible if the dent is shallow, but deep dents may require replacement. The decision to repair or replace must be based on a careful assessment of the damage, the cost of the repair, and the downtime. The shop floor and the site must work together to ensure that the inspection and repair are carried out to the highest standard, because the safety of the structure depends on it.