Radial Temperature Difference Action Mode of Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes in Natural Environment
Introduction
The radial temperature difference in a concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) is a phenomenon that many engineers overlook, but it has caused real problems in the field. The literature topic 2583 addresses the action mode of this temperature difference in a natural environment. When a CFST column is exposed to sunlight, the steel tube heats up faster than the concrete core because of the difference in thermal diffusivity. This creates a radial temperature gradient that causes differential expansion between the steel and the concrete. The steel tube expands more than the concrete, creating a tensile stress in the concrete and a compressive stress in the steel. If the temperature difference is large enough, the concrete core can crack, and the steel tube can yield.
I have seen the effects of this phenomenon on a bridge project in a desert climate where the daytime temperature reached 50 degrees Celsius and the nighttime temperature dropped to 20 degrees Celsius. The CFST columns developed visible cracks in the concrete core after a few months of exposure. The cracks were not structural, but they caused concern among the client and required extensive investigation. The literature provides a framework for predicting the magnitude of this temperature difference, and this framework is essential for preventing such problems.
Temperature Gradient Analysis and Key Parameters
The literature identifies several factors that influence the radial temperature difference in a CFST column. The most important factors are the solar radiation intensity, the ambient temperature, the wind speed, and the thermal properties of the steel and concrete. The solar radiation intensity is the dominant factor because it determines the heat flux into the steel tube. The ambient temperature sets the boundary condition, and the wind speed affects the convective heat transfer coefficient on the outer surface of the tube. The thermal properties of the steel and concrete determine how quickly the heat is transferred through the composite section.
The table below summarizes the key parameters and their typical ranges based on the literature and my field observations.
| Parameter | Typical Range | Effect on Radial Temperature Difference | Practical Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solar radiation intensity | 500-1000 W/m² | Directly proportional to temperature difference | Highest in summer, clear skies, low latitudes |
| Ambient temperature | -20 to 50 °C | Sets the baseline, affects the rate of change | Extreme in desert and continental climates |
| Wind speed | 0-10 m/s | Inverse relationship, higher wind reduces temperature difference | Important for exposed columns, less for enclosed |
| Steel tube thickness | 10-30 mm | Thicker tube reduces temperature difference | Thicker tube acts as a thermal buffer |
| Concrete core diameter | 200-1000 mm | Larger diameter increases temperature difference | Larger core takes longer to reach equilibrium |
| Thermal diffusivity of steel | 1.2 x 10⁻⁵ m²/s | Determines heat transfer rate in steel | Steel responds quickly to solar radiation |
| Thermal diffusivity of concrete | 0.8 x 10⁻⁶ m²/s | Determines heat transfer rate in concrete | Concrete responds slowly, creating the gradient |
The literature proposes a simplified action mode that models the temperature difference as a linear gradient from the outer surface of the steel tube to the center of the concrete core. This linear approximation is valid for most practical cases, but it breaks down for very large diameter columns where the temperature distribution becomes non-linear. I have seen this on a 1200 mm diameter column where the temperature at the steel-concrete interface was significantly different from the linear prediction. The non-linearity was caused by the heat capacity of the concrete core, which acted as a thermal mass that delayed the temperature rise.
The maximum radial temperature difference typically occurs in the late afternoon when the solar radiation has been heating the tube for several hours, but the concrete core has not yet reached thermal equilibrium. The literature suggests that the maximum temperature difference can reach 20 to 30 degrees Celsius in extreme conditions. This temperature difference translates into a stress of approximately 5 to 10 MPa in the concrete core, which is significant compared to the tensile strength of concrete, typically 2 to 4 MPa.
Practical Implications for Pipe Manufacturing and Installation
The radial temperature difference in a CFST column has several practical implications for the manufacturing and installation of the steel pipe. The first implication is the effect on the concrete core. If the concrete core is not designed to resist the tensile stress caused by the temperature difference, it will crack. These cracks are not structural, but they can affect the durability of the column by providing a path for moisture and chlorides to reach the steel tube. I have seen this on a coastal project where the concrete core cracked, and the cracks allowed seawater to penetrate, causing corrosion of the steel tube from the inside.
The second implication is the effect on the steel tube. The temperature difference causes the steel tube to expand more than the concrete core, creating a compressive stress in the steel. If this compressive stress is added to the axial compressive stress from the applied load, the steel tube can yield prematurely. I have seen a case where a CFST column failed in local buckling at a load that was 15 percent below the design capacity because the temperature-induced compressive stress was not accounted for in the design.
The third implication is the effect on the weld joints. The temperature difference causes a differential expansion between the steel tube and the concrete core, which creates a shear stress at the interface. This shear stress can cause debonding of the concrete core from the tube wall, especially if the interface has a low bond strength. I have seen this on a project where the concrete core debonded from the tube wall after a few years of service, and the column lost its composite action. The fix is to use shear studs or a ribbed tube wall to improve the bond, but this adds cost and complexity.
The literature also highlights the importance of the installation orientation. A column that is exposed to direct sunlight on one side will have a larger temperature difference than a column that is shaded. I have seen a project where the columns on the south side of a building developed cracks in the concrete core, while the columns on the north side did not. The design had assumed a uniform temperature distribution, but the actual distribution was highly non-uniform.
Summary and Recommendations
The study of the radial temperature difference action mode of CFST columns in a natural environment reveals that this phenomenon is significant and must be accounted for in the design. The maximum temperature difference can reach 20 to 30 degrees Celsius, and this can cause cracking of the concrete core and premature yielding of the steel tube. The most important lesson is that the design must consider the actual environmental conditions at the project site, not just the ambient temperature. The solar radiation intensity, wind speed, and orientation of the column all affect the temperature difference. I recommend that engineers use the simplified linear gradient model for preliminary design, but verify it with a detailed thermal analysis for large diameter columns or extreme climates. The concrete core should be designed with a tensile strength that exceeds the temperature-induced stress, or a shrinkage-compensating admixture should be used to prevent cracking. The steel tube should be designed with a safety factor that accounts for the temperature-induced compressive stress, and the bond between the steel and concrete should be improved with shear studs or a ribbed surface. Finally, the installation orientation should be considered in the design, and the columns should be protected from direct sunlight if possible.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd