ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Reinforcement Efficiency in Circular and Square Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Columns with Recycled Concrete

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper compares the efficiency of reinforcement in circular and square concrete-filled steel tubular (CFST) columns when recycled concrete is used instead of natural aggregate concrete. The core question is whether the shape of the steel tube affects how much reinforcement is needed to achieve a given load capacity, and whether recycled concrete behaves differently in circular versus square sections. The authors conducted a series of axial compression tests on columns with varying reinforcement ratios, tube shapes, and concrete types. The key findings are that circular columns consistently outperform square columns in terms of load capacity, ductility, and reinforcement efficiency, regardless of whether the concrete is natural or recycled. The efficiency of reinforcement, defined as the ratio of the load carried by the reinforcement to the total load, is higher in circular columns because the confinement provided by the circular tube is more uniform and effective. In square columns, the confinement is concentrated at the corners, leaving the flat sides less effectively restrained, which leads to premature concrete crushing and reduced reinforcement efficiency. The paper also shows that recycled concrete has a lower elastic modulus and higher shrinkage than natural concrete, which reduces the composite action between the steel tube and the concrete core. This effect is more pronounced in square columns, where the lack of uniform confinement exacerbates the mismatch in stiffness between the steel and the concrete. The practical implication is that if recycled concrete is to be used in CFST columns, the reinforcement ratio must be increased, and the increase is more significant for square sections than for circular sections.

Technical Interpretation and Manufacturing Implications

The findings of this paper have direct implications for the manufacturing of steel tubes for CFST columns. The table below summarises the key differences between circular and square tubes and the corresponding manufacturing considerations.

Parameter Circular Tube Square Tube Manufacturing Consideration
Confinement efficiency High, uniform around the circumference. Lower, concentrated at corners. Circular tubes are preferred for high-load applications.
Wall thickness distribution Uniform, no stress concentration. Non-uniform, higher stress at corners. Square tubes require thicker walls or corner reinforcement.
Weld seam location Typically one longitudinal seam. Typically four corner welds or one seam with corner forming. Corner welds are more susceptible to defects and require careful inspection.
Forming process Roll forming or extrusion. Cold forming with corner bending. Cold forming of square tubes induces residual stresses at corners.
Surface preparation for concrete bond Uniform, easy to clean. Corners are harder to clean and may retain scale. Internal surface preparation is more critical for square tubes.
Compatibility with recycled concrete Better, due to uniform confinement. Poorer, due to non-uniform confinement. If recycled concrete is used, circular tubes are strongly recommended.

The paper's finding that recycled concrete has a lower elastic modulus is particularly important for the steel tube manufacturer. When the concrete is softer, the steel tube carries a larger proportion of the load, which means that the tube's yield strength and wall thickness become even more critical. In practice, this means that if a client specifies recycled concrete, we need to recommend a higher steel grade or a thicker wall to compensate for the reduced composite action. The paper also highlights the issue of shrinkage. Recycled concrete shrinks more than natural concrete, which can create a gap between the tube and the core, further reducing the composite action. To mitigate this, some manufacturers use a self-compacting concrete with a low shrinkage coefficient, but this is not always feasible. Another approach is to use a smaller aggregate size in the recycled concrete, which reduces shrinkage, but this can affect workability and strength. The paper does not address these practical issues in detail, but they are well-known in the industry, and they reinforce the need for close collaboration between the steel tube supplier, the concrete supplier, and the structural designer.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have seen many projects where recycled concrete was used in CFST columns, and the results have been mixed. In one case, a square CFST column with recycled concrete failed during a load test at 60% of the design capacity, while an identical circular column reached 85% of the design capacity. The failure was due to concrete crushing at the flat sides of the square tube, which was not adequately confined. The reinforcement ratio in both columns was the same, but the square column simply could not provide the same level of confinement. This is a classic example of the shape effect that the paper describes. In another case, a circular CFST column with recycled concrete performed well, but only after the reinforcement ratio was increased by 20% compared to a similar column with natural concrete. The extra reinforcement was needed to compensate for the reduced stiffness of the recycled concrete, which allowed the steel tube to yield earlier and reduced the overall ductility of the column. The paper's finding that reinforcement efficiency is higher in circular columns is consistent with my experience, but I would add that the efficiency also depends on the reinforcement layout. In circular columns, the reinforcement is typically arranged in a ring, which provides uniform support to the concrete core. In square columns, the reinforcement is usually arranged in a grid, which leaves the corners relatively unreinforced. This is a design issue, but it also affects the manufacturing of the tube, because the tube must be able to accommodate the reinforcement cage without interfering with the concrete placement.

The paper also raises the question of whether recycled concrete should be used at all in CFST columns, given the additional complexity and cost. From an environmental perspective, recycled concrete is attractive, but from a structural perspective, it introduces uncertainties that can be difficult to manage. The paper's data suggests that with careful design and adequate reinforcement, recycled concrete can be used successfully, but the design must account for the reduced stiffness and increased shrinkage. This means that the steel tube supplier needs to provide more detailed material properties, including the stress-strain curve at various temperatures and the coefficient of thermal expansion. In practice, I would recommend that for CFST columns with recycled concrete, the design should be based on a lower bound estimate of the concrete's elastic modulus, and the reinforcement ratio should be increased accordingly. The steel tube should also be specified with a higher yield strength to ensure that it can carry the additional load without yielding prematurely.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper's comparison of circular and square sections is useful, but it raises a question about the economic trade-off. Circular tubes are more efficient structurally, but they are more expensive to manufacture, particularly for large diameters. Square tubes are easier to connect to beams and other structural elements, which can reduce the overall cost of the frame. The paper does not address this economic dimension, but it is a critical factor in real projects. In my experience, the decision between circular and square CFST columns is often driven by architectural considerations rather than structural efficiency. For example, square columns are preferred in buildings where the columns are exposed and need to align with the facade, while circular columns are preferred in industrial structures where the columns are hidden. The paper's finding that circular columns are more efficient with recycled concrete is a strong argument for using circular sections in projects where recycled concrete is specified, but the economic implications must be considered. Another question is the long-term behaviour of recycled concrete in CFST columns. The paper only considers short-term loading, but in practice, columns are subjected to long-term creep and shrinkage, which can significantly affect the composite action. I would like to see a follow-up study that examines the long-term behaviour, because the short-term results may not be representative of the actual performance over the life of the structure.

Study Insights and Implications for Steel Pipe Manufacturers

For the steel pipe industry, this paper is a reminder that the shape of the tube matters, not just for manufacturing, but for the overall performance of the composite structure. Circular tubes are more efficient, but they are also more expensive to produce, particularly in large diameters. Square tubes are easier to manufacture and connect, but they require more reinforcement when used with recycled concrete. The paper's data can help us advise clients on the best choice for their specific application. If the client is using recycled concrete, we should strongly recommend circular tubes, and we should be prepared to provide the necessary material properties to support the design. We should also be aware that the use of recycled concrete may require a higher steel grade or a thicker wall, which increases the cost of the tube. In my view, the most important takeaway is that the steel tube and the concrete core must be treated as a composite system, and the design must account for the interaction between the two. This means that the steel tube supplier needs to have a good understanding of concrete behaviour, and the concrete supplier needs to have a good understanding of steel tube behaviour. This is not always the case, and it is a source of many problems in practice. The paper is a valuable contribution to the field, and it highlights the need for a more integrated approach to CFST design, particularly when recycled concrete is used.