Control of Porosity Defects in Automatic MIG Welding of Aluminium Alloys
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Geng Jinghe and colleagues from Qingdao Sifang Alstom Railway Transportation Equipment addresses one of the most persistent and costly defects in aluminium fabrication: porosity in automatic MIG welds. The authors analyse the causes from both process and environmental perspectives, and provide specific control measures that are refreshingly quantitative.
Porosity in aluminium welds is fundamentally a hydrogen problem. Hydrogen is highly soluble in liquid aluminium but almost insoluble in the solid state. As the weld pool solidifies, the dissolved hydrogen is rejected at the solid-liquid interface and forms gas bubbles. If the bubbles cannot escape before the pool freezes, they become trapped as pores. The consequences are severe: reduced static strength, dramatically reduced fatigue life, and in pressure-tight or leak-tight applications, outright rejection.
Analysis of Process Factors
The paper identifies three key process factors. First, the arc length must be kept consistent with the weld width. If the arc length is too long, the arc becomes unstable and the shielding gas coverage degrades, allowing atmospheric moisture and nitrogen to enter the weld pool. If the arc length is too short, the arc can dig into the pool and create turbulence that traps bubbles.
Second, for PC position welding, the macroscopic pool morphology must be considered. The authors recommend increasing the arc stiffness to ensure penetration while maintaining a V-shaped pool profile, which is favourable for gas escape. This is a subtle but important point. A V-shaped pool has a wider surface area relative to its volume, which means bubbles have a shorter path to the surface and a higher probability of escaping before solidification.
Third, the welding circuit resistance must be less than 10 ohms at all positions within the work area. High circuit resistance causes voltage drop, which destabilises the arc and leads to erratic wire feed and poor shielding. In a large structure such as a train body, the ground connection can be a significant source of resistance, and the paper correctly emphasises checking the resistance at every position where welding will be performed.
Analysis of Environmental Factors
The environmental factors are equally important. The paper states that gas flow rates above 25 L/min significantly reduce porosity. This is counterintuitive to many welders who believe that higher gas flow is always better. In reality, excessive gas flow creates turbulence at the nozzle exit, which can entrain air and actually degrade shielding. The 25 L/min threshold appears to be the point where the shielding is adequate for the specific nozzle and torch configuration used.
The humidity control requirement is critical. The paper specifies that the welding environment humidity must be strictly controlled below 65%. This is not just about the ambient air. The filler wire, the base metal surface, and the shielding gas all contribute to the total hydrogen input. In a humid environment, the wire surface absorbs moisture, and the base metal surface can develop a hydrated oxide layer that releases hydrogen when heated by the arc.
Practical Control Measures and Shop Floor Lessons
In my experience, the most common cause of porosity in aluminium MIG welding is not the welding parameters but the preparation. The base metal must be degreased and mechanically cleaned immediately before welding. The oxide layer on aluminium is tenacious and hydrophilic; it absorbs moisture from the air and releases hydrogen when the arc strikes. A wire brush is not sufficient; the surface must be chemically clean and dry.
The filler wire storage is another frequently overlooked factor. Aluminium wire should be stored in a dry, temperature-controlled environment and used within a short time after opening the package. If the wire has been exposed to humid air, it will pick up moisture on its surface, and that moisture will end up in the weld pool.
The paper's recommendation to keep the circuit resistance below 10 ohms is a practical checklist item that I would add to every welding procedure qualification. In a large structure, I have seen resistance values above 20 ohms at positions far from the ground clamp, and the resulting welds were full of porosity. The fix was not to change the welding parameters but to add additional ground clamps to reduce the resistance.
Integration with Engineering Practice
For a production shop, the porosity control measures can be organised into a simple checklist. Before starting a welding shift, verify the following: the base metal surface is clean and dry, the filler wire is from a dry storage and has been loaded correctly, the shielding gas flow is set to the specified value, the humidity is below 65%, and the circuit resistance at the welding position is below 10 ohms. If any of these checks fail, do not start welding.
The paper also implies that the welding procedure qualification should include a porosity test, not just a tensile test. In my experience, the most reliable porosity test is radiographic testing, which can detect pores as small as 0.5 mm. For critical applications, a section through the weld should be examined metallographically to quantify the pore size and distribution.
The fatigue life penalty from porosity is substantial. A weld with 5% porosity by area can have its fatigue life reduced by 30% to 50% compared to a sound weld. For a train body that is designed for a 30-year service life with millions of load cycles, this is an unacceptable risk. The porosity control measures described in this paper are not optional; they are essential for the structural integrity of the vehicle.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd