ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Pulsed MIG Lap Welding of Dissimilar Aluminum Alloys 6061 and A356

Literature Overview

This paper by Nie Fuheng and colleagues from Dalian University of Technology and Suzhou Nonferrous Metals Research Institute investigates the pulsed MIG lap welding of 6061 wrought aluminum alloy to A356 cast aluminum alloy. The work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China and published in the Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering (Vol. 52, No. 24, 2016, pp. 65-71). The study analyzes the mechanical properties, microstructure, and elemental distribution of the dissimilar aluminum alloy joints.

Welding Process and Joint Configuration

The study utilizes DC pulsed MIG welding with a lap joint configuration. The key process parameters are:

Parameter Value
Welding method DC pulsed MIG
Joint type Lap joint
Base metal 1 6061 wrought aluminum alloy (bottom plate)
Base metal 2 A356 cast aluminum alloy (top plate)
Welding speed 10 mm/s (optimal)
Maximum lap shear strength 95 MPa

The study found that the highest joint strength was achieved when the A356 cast aluminum alloy was placed on top and the 6061 wrought aluminum alloy was on the bottom, with a welding speed of 10 mm/s.

Microstructural Analysis and Elemental Distribution

The microstructural analysis reveals significant differences between the two sides of the joint:

Region Microstructural Features Elemental Segregation
A356 side (partial fusion zone) Flaky Al-Fe-Si phase and granular Al-Fe-Mg-Si phase Fe and Mg segregation
6061 side (partial fusion zone) Grain boundary liquation forming Al-Mg-Si-Cu phase + Al solid solution depleted zone Fe segregation around the liquated phase
Weld zone Mixed microstructure with varying grain sizes -

The formation of Fe-rich phases (Al-Fe-Si and Al-Fe-Mg-Si) on the A356 side is attributed to the higher Fe content in cast aluminum alloys. These Fe-rich phases are known to weaken the joint by acting as crack initiation sites.

Fracture Behavior and Joint Strength

The tensile test results reveal that all specimens fractured in the weld zone, with the fracture mode characterized as mixed-type fracture. The maximum lap shear strength of 95 MPa is significantly lower than the strength of the 6061 base metal (approximately 310 MPa in the T6 condition), indicating a joint efficiency of only about 30%.

The study identifies the "triangle zone" as the weakest region of the joint. This is the region at the intersection of the weld toe and the lap joint interface, where stress concentration and microstructural defects combine to promote crack initiation.

Practical Insights from the Shop Floor

Dissimilar aluminum alloy welding is common in the automotive and aerospace industries, but it is also relevant to the pipe and fitting industry for applications such as transition joints and clad products. The following practical considerations are critical:

  1. Joint efficiency: The 95 MPa joint strength represents a joint efficiency of only about 30% relative to the 6061-T6 base metal. This is a major limitation for structural applications. In the pipe industry, joint efficiency is a critical design parameter, and values below 50% are generally unacceptable for pressure-containing applications.
  2. Fe-rich phases: The Fe content in cast aluminum alloys (A356 typically contains 0.12-0.20% Fe) leads to the formation of Fe-rich intermetallic phases during welding. These phases are brittle and act as crack initiation sites. In production, this can be mitigated by:
  1. Grain boundary liquation: The grain boundary liquation observed on the 6061 side is a form of hot cracking susceptibility. This occurs when the welding heat causes partial melting of the grain boundaries, leading to the formation of low-melting-point phases. In production, this can be controlled by:
  1. Triangle zone: The triangle zone is a critical region in lap joints. In production, this region should be inspected carefully using penetrant testing or ultrasonic testing to detect cracks and lack of fusion.

Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises an important question: why is the joint strength so low (95 MPa) when the filler metal and base metals are all aluminum alloys? The answer lies in the microstructural defects and the Fe-rich phases that form during welding. This highlights the importance of understanding the metallurgical interactions between dissimilar alloys.

Another consideration is the effect of welding speed on joint strength. The study found that 10 mm/s was optimal, but the reasons for this are not fully explained. In practice, welding speed affects heat input, which in turn affects the microstructure and the size of the fusion zone.

Study Insights and Implications

This study provides valuable insights into the challenges of welding dissimilar aluminum alloys. The key findings are:

For engineers working with dissimilar aluminum alloys, I recommend the following approach:

Conclusions

This study demonstrates that pulsed MIG lap welding of 6061 and A356 aluminum alloys produces joints with a maximum strength of 95 MPa, representing a joint efficiency of only about 30%. The primary cause of reduced strength is the formation of Fe-rich phases (Al-Fe-Si and Al-Fe-Mg-Si) on the A356 side, combined with grain boundary liquation on the 6061 side. The triangle zone is identified as the weakest region of the joint. For structural applications, the low joint efficiency is a significant limitation, and further process development is needed to improve joint strength. The findings highlight the importance of understanding metallurgical interactions in dissimilar aluminum alloy welding and the need for careful process control and joint design.