Effect of MIG Welding Process on Liquation Cracking of 6xxx Aluminum Alloys
Literature Overview and Problem Statement
This paper by Hao Yuxi, Xu Wugang, Xu Yujun, Sun Wei, and Li Yan from Liaoning Zhongwang Aluminum Precision Processing Co., Ltd., published in Light Alloy Fabrication Technology (轻合金加工技术), Volume 48, Issue 8, 2020, pages 61-65, addresses a problem that is all too familiar to anyone who welds 6xxx aluminum extrusions: liquation cracking. The materials are 6082 and 6061 aluminum alloy profiles with 2 mm wall thickness, and the process is MIG welding. The authors have used penetrant testing (PT), optical microscopy, tensile testing, and direct-reading spectroscopy to characterize the cracking behavior. This is a practical paper from a company that actually manufactures aluminum extrusions and welds them, so the findings are directly relevant to the shop floor. The problem is real: thin-wall 6xxx aluminum profiles are prone to liquation cracking during MIG welding, and the cracks are often not visible on the surface, which makes them particularly dangerous.
Liquation Cracking Mechanism: The Grain Boundary Liquid Film
The authors report that liquation cracking occurs during MIG welding of thin-wall 6082 and 6061 aluminum profiles, and they have identified the mechanism. During welding, the low-melting eutectic constituents in the alloy are heated and melted, and they migrate to the grain boundaries in the coarse grain layer. The liquid film that forms at the grain boundaries has a low melting point and a low strength, and when the thermal stress and the welding stress act on the joint, the liquid film cannot accommodate the strain, and it tears, producing a crack. This is a classic liquation cracking mechanism, and it is well known in the welding of aluminum alloys. The key factor is the presence of a coarse grain layer in the extrusion, which is formed during the extrusion process. The coarse grains have a large grain boundary area, and the low-melting eutectics tend to segregate to the grain boundaries, making them more susceptible to liquation cracking. The authors have confirmed this with optical microscopy, which shows the cracks following the grain boundaries in the coarse grain layer.
| Factor | Effect on Cracking | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Yield ratio (high) | Increased cracking tendency | Higher stress concentration at grain boundaries |
| Wall thickness (thin) | Increased cracking tendency | Less constraint, higher strain at grain boundaries |
| Heat input (high) | Increased cracking tendency | More melting of low-melting eutectics, wider HAZ |
| Coarse grain layer | Increased cracking tendency | More grain boundary area, more eutectic segregation |
Process Parameters and Material Factors: What the Authors Found
The authors report that reducing the yield ratio, increasing the wall thickness, and reducing the heat input can effectively reduce the cracking tendency. This is a practical set of recommendations, and it makes sense from a metallurgical standpoint. The yield ratio is a measure of the difference between the yield strength and the tensile strength, and a high yield ratio means that the material has less capacity to work harden and accommodate strain. In a welded joint, the thermal stress and the welding stress are superimposed on the base metal, and a high yield ratio means that the material will reach its yield point sooner and will have less plastic deformation capacity before failure. Reducing the yield ratio, for example by changing the temper condition, will increase the ductility and reduce the cracking tendency. Increasing the wall thickness is a design change that increases the constraint and reduces the strain at the grain boundaries, which also reduces the cracking tendency. Reducing the heat input is a process change that reduces the amount of low-melting eutectics that melt and the width of the HAZ, which reduces the cracking tendency. The authors have also used direct-reading spectroscopy to analyze the composition, and they have likely found that the content of magnesium and silicon, which form the low-melting eutectics in 6xxx alloys, is a key factor.
Countermeasures and Engineering Practice
This paper provides a clear set of countermeasures for liquation cracking in 6xxx aluminum alloy profiles, and they are all practical and implementable. The first is to reduce the yield ratio, which can be achieved by changing the temper condition or by using a different alloy. The second is to increase the wall thickness, which is a design change that may not always be possible, but it is effective. The third is to reduce the heat input, which can be achieved by using a lower welding current, a higher travel speed, or a pulsed MIG process. The authors have also used PT to detect the cracks, and this is a critical quality control measure. Liquation cracks are often not visible on the surface, and they can be missed by visual inspection. PT is a reliable method for detecting surface-breaking cracks, but it requires a clean surface and a proper technique. The practical lesson is to use PT on all welded 6xxx aluminum profiles, especially those with thin walls, and to verify the cracking tendency with a controlled test. In my experience, liquation cracking is a serious problem in 6xxx aluminum welding, and it is often caused by a combination of a high yield ratio, a thin wall, and a high heat input. The fix is to address all three factors, not just one. The paper is a solid contribution to the literature, and I would recommend it to any engineer who is welding 6xxx aluminum extrusions for structural applications. The next step would be to investigate the effect of the welding wire composition on the cracking tendency, because the current study does not address that variable in detail, and it is critical for process optimization.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd