Effect of Copper and Nickel Interlayers on the Interface of Aluminum/Steel Laser-MIG Lap Welds: A Veteran's View on Dissimilar Metal Joining
Literature Overview and Core Intent
This 2021 paper from Guangdong University of Technology addresses one of the most challenging problems in welding: joining aluminum to steel. The two metals have vastly different melting points, thermal conductivities, and coefficients of thermal expansion, and they form brittle intermetallic compounds (IMCs) when welded directly. The authors use laser-MIG hybrid welding with copper and nickel interlayers to join 304 stainless steel to 5052 aluminum alloy in a lap joint configuration.
The paper's core finding is that the interlayers reduce the thickness of the IMC layer and lower the hardness of the hardened layer at the interface. The copper interlayer reduces the hardened layer thickness by 75.00% and the average microhardness by 9.60%, while the nickel interlayer reduces the hardened layer thickness by 87.50% and the average microhardness by 4.60%.
Technical Points and Process Interpretation
The mechanism behind the interlayer effect is straightforward but elegant. When aluminum and steel are welded directly, the aluminum reacts with the iron to form FeAl, Fe2Al5, FeAl3, and other brittle IMCs. These compounds are hard and have low ductility, so the joint is brittle and prone to cracking. The copper and nickel interlayers react preferentially with the aluminum, forming Al-Cu and Al-Ni IMCs instead of Al-Fe IMCs. The Al-Cu and Al-Ni IMCs are less brittle and more ductile than the Al-Fe IMCs, and they also grow more slowly, so the IMC layer is thinner.
Table 1 summarizes the effect of the interlayers on the interface properties.
| Interface Condition | Hardened Layer Thickness (μm) | Reduction in Thickness (%) | Average Microhardness (HV) | Reduction in Hardness (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No interlayer | Reference | - | Reference | - |
| Copper interlayer | Reduced | 75.00 | Reduced | 9.60 |
| Nickel interlayer | Reduced | 87.50 | Reduced | 4.60 |
The nickel interlayer is more effective at reducing the IMC layer thickness, but the copper interlayer is more effective at reducing the hardness. This is because the Al-Cu IMCs are softer than the Al-Ni IMCs, even though the Al-Ni IMCs are thinner. The optimal choice depends on the application. If the joint is primarily in shear, the thickness of the IMC layer matters more. If the joint is in tension, the hardness matters more.
Integration with Manufacturing Practice
Dissimilar metal joints between aluminum and steel are used in automotive structures, shipbuilding, and increasingly in offshore wind and solar structures. The challenge is always the same: how do you get a strong, ductile joint without forming a thick layer of brittle IMCs?
The laser-MIG hybrid process is a good choice because it combines the deep penetration of the laser with the filler metal addition of the MIG process. The laser provides the heat input, and the MIG provides the filler metal. The interlayer can be applied as a coating on the steel surface or as a foil placed between the two metals.
In practice, the interlayer must be applied uniformly and with the correct thickness. If the interlayer is too thin, it will be consumed by the reaction with the aluminum, and the Al-Fe IMCs will form. If the interlayer is too thick, it will dilute the joint and reduce the strength. The optimal thickness depends on the welding parameters and the joint geometry.
The paper does not report the interlayer thickness, but I would expect it to be in the range of 10-100 μm. This is a critical parameter, and it must be controlled precisely.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper uses SEM/EDS to identify the IMCs and microhardness testing to measure the hardness distribution. This is a solid methodology, but it does not directly measure the joint strength. The authors do not report tensile or shear test results, so we do not know if the reduced IMC layer actually translates to a stronger joint. This is a significant gap.
Another question is the effect of the interlayer on the corrosion resistance of the joint. Aluminum and steel have different electrochemical potentials, and the joint is susceptible to galvanic corrosion. The IMC layer can accelerate or retard this corrosion, depending on its composition and thickness. The paper does not address this.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of dissimilar metal welding. It demonstrates that copper and nickel interlayers can effectively reduce the IMC layer thickness and the hardness of the hardened layer at the aluminum/steel interface. The mechanism is clear: the interlayers react preferentially with the aluminum, forming less brittle IMCs.
For a plant manager, the takeaway is that dissimilar metal joints can be improved by using interlayers, but the interlayer must be applied correctly and the welding parameters must be optimized. This is not a simple process; it requires careful control of the interlayer thickness, the welding speed, and the heat input.
Reference Value and Outlook
The paper is a good starting point for anyone working on aluminum/steel joints. The findings are clear and the methodology is sound. The next step would be to measure the joint strength and to evaluate the corrosion resistance. It would also be valuable to study the effect of the interlayer on the fatigue behavior of the joint.
I would recommend this paper to anyone who is joining aluminum to steel and is looking for a way to improve the joint quality. The copper and nickel interlayers are promising, but they are not a silver bullet. The joint must be designed carefully, and the welding process must be controlled precisely.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd