Heat Transfer Model for MIG Spot Welding with Spray Transfer
Literature Overview
Wu Chuansong, Wu Lin, and Chen Dinghua (1991) from Harbin Institute of Technology present a numerical heat transfer model for MIG spot welding with spray transfer. This is a classic paper from the early 1990s, but its insights remain highly relevant today. The authors challenge the conventional approach to welding heat transfer modelling, which treats MIG and TIG welding as essentially the same process with different arc efficiency values. They argue that this oversimplification ignores a critical physical phenomenon: the transfer of molten metal droplets into the weld pool carries significant heat, and this heat is deposited inside the pool, not just on the surface.
Technical Points and Model Development
The conventional approach to welding heat transfer assumes that heat from the arc is deposited on the workpiece surface according to a Gaussian distribution. The arc efficiency factor η is used to account for the fraction of arc energy that actually reaches the workpiece. For TIG welding, this is a reasonable approximation because there is no significant droplet transfer. For MIG welding with spray transfer, however, the molten droplets carry a substantial amount of heat into the weld pool interior.
The authors propose a new model that includes two heat sources:
- Surface heat flux — the arc heat deposited on the workpiece surface, described by a Gaussian distribution q(r).
- Volumetric heat source — the heat carried by the molten droplets, deposited inside the weld pool, described by a distribution ΔH(r, z).
They also account for the fluid flow in the weld pool, which significantly affects heat transfer and the resulting weld geometry. The model successfully simulates the characteristic "finger-like" penetration profile that is commonly observed in MIG welds with spray transfer.
| Heat Source | Location | Distribution | Physical Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arc heat flux q(r) | Workpiece surface | Gaussian | Energy from the arc column |
| Droplet heat ΔH(r, z) | Weld pool interior | Volumetric | Heat carried by molten droplets |
Engineering Practice and Shop Floor Implications
The finger-like penetration profile is a well-known characteristic of MIG welds with spray transfer. It is caused by the momentum and heat of the droplets penetrating into the weld pool, creating a deep, narrow penetration zone. This is often desirable because it allows for deep penetration with a relatively narrow weld bead, which is beneficial for thick-section welding.
However, the finger-like profile also has a downside: it can create a weld with a high depth-to-width ratio, which increases the risk of solidification cracking and can make the weld more sensitive to lack of fusion at the root. In my experience, this is particularly problematic in thick-section welding where the weld is made in multiple passes. The finger-like penetration of the first pass can create a narrow root that is difficult to fuse with subsequent passes.
The model presented in this paper is valuable because it allows engineers to predict the weld geometry before welding, which is essential for process design. If you know the welding parameters, you can estimate the penetration depth and width, and then design the joint preparation and welding sequence accordingly.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question I would raise is how the model handles the transition from spray transfer to globular transfer. In real welding, the transfer mode changes with current, and the heat and momentum transfer characteristics change accordingly. The model appears to focus on spray transfer, which is a reasonable simplification for many applications, but it limits the model's applicability.
I would also like to see how the model performs for pulsed MIG welding, where the droplet transfer is controlled by the pulse waveform. In pulsed MIG, the droplet detachment is more controlled, and the heat input per droplet can be varied over a wider range. This could be a useful extension of the model.
Another practical concern is the computational complexity of the model. In 1991, numerical simulation of welding heat transfer was a significant undertaking. Today, with modern computational tools, such models can be run much more efficiently, but the physical understanding remains the same.
Study Insights and Practical Outlook
This paper is a foundational contribution to welding heat transfer modelling. It correctly identifies that MIG welding cannot be treated as simply TIG welding with a different efficiency factor. The droplet transfer is a fundamental part of the MIG process, and it must be accounted for in any accurate heat transfer model.
For production engineers, the practical value of this work is in understanding why MIG welds have the characteristic finger-like penetration profile. This understanding is essential for:
- Process design — predicting penetration depth and width for given parameters.
- Defect analysis — understanding why lack of fusion or cracking occurs in certain joint configurations.
- Procedure qualification — ensuring that the welding procedure produces the intended weld geometry.
In my view, the next step for this line of research is the development of coupled thermal-fluid-stress models that can predict not just the weld geometry, but also the residual stresses and distortion. This would be invaluable for thick-section welding, where residual stress management is critical. The foundation laid by this paper is an important step towards that goal.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd