ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

External Alternating Magnetic Field Effects on MIG Welding Arc and Spray Transfer — A Practical Examination

Literature Overview

This paper from Jiangsu Aviation Technical College and Nanchang Hangkong University, published in Hot Working Technology (2023), investigates the effect of an external alternating magnetic field on the MIG welding arc and spray transfer. The authors, Han Qi and Jiang Shuyuan, used a high-speed photography system to capture images of the arc and the droplet transfer under different magnetic field conditions. They applied a force analysis to explain the observed phenomena. The results showed that at a magnetic field frequency of 40 Hz and an excitation current of 0–1.0 A, the arc rotated periodically clockwise and counterclockwise around the wire axis, with expansion and contraction. The conductive fluid at the wire tip consisted of a liquid cone, a liquid stream, and small spherical droplets. At 0 A excitation current, the liquid cone and stream were vertical with no deflection, and droplets transferred smoothly. At 0.2 and 0.6 A, the stream was short and thick, deflecting at a small angle. At 0.8 and 1.0 A, the stream was elongated, the conductive fluid formed an "S" shape, and the deflection angle was large.

Magnetic field effects on welding arcs are a well-known phenomenon, particularly in pipe welding where the arc can be deflected by the magnetic field of the welding current itself (arc blow). This paper provides a systematic study of how an external alternating magnetic field affects the arc and droplet transfer, which is relevant to understanding and controlling arc blow in pipe welding.

Technical Interpretation

The paper's key findings can be summarized as follows:

Excitation Current (A) Arc Behavior Droplet Transfer Behavior
0 No deflection, arc stable Smooth transfer, no deflection
0.2 Small angle deflection, clockwise/counterclockwise rotation Short thick stream, small angle deflection
0.6 Moderate angle deflection, periodic rotation Short thick stream, moderate angle deflection
0.8 Large angle deflection, "S" shape Elongated stream, large angle deflection
1.0 Very large angle deflection, pronounced "S" shape Elongated stream, periodic clockwise/counterclockwise rotation

The force analysis explains the mechanism. The alternating magnetic field induces a Lorentz force on the charged particles in the arc and on the conductive fluid at the wire tip. The direction of the force alternates with the magnetic field, causing the arc and the fluid to rotate and deflect periodically. At low excitation currents, the force is small, and the arc remains relatively stable. At high excitation currents, the force is large enough to cause significant deflection and even "S" shape distortion of the conductive fluid.

The practical significance is that an external magnetic field can be used to control the arc and droplet transfer. This has potential applications in:

Engineering Practice

In the pipe industry, magnetic field effects are most commonly encountered as arc blow:

  1. DC welding on magnetic pipe. When welding carbon steel pipe with DC, the magnetic field of the welding current can interact with the residual magnetism in the pipe, causing the arc to deflect. This is a major problem in root pass welding of large-diameter pipe, where the arc can blow to one side, causing lack of fusion or undercut.
  2. Magnetic particle inspection (MPI). After welding, MPI is used to detect surface defects. The magnetic field used for MPI can leave residual magnetism in the pipe, which causes arc blow during subsequent welding operations. This is a well-known problem in pipeline construction.
  3. Cladding and overlay welding. When welding CRA cladding onto carbon steel pipe, the magnetic field of the welding current can interact with the ferromagnetic base metal, causing arc deflection and inconsistent cladding thickness.

The paper's findings suggest that an external alternating magnetic field could be used to counteract arc blow. By applying a controlled alternating magnetic field, the arc can be stabilized and maintained in the desired position.

Key Reflections and Lessons Learned

I have seen arc blow cause significant problems in pipe welding:

The lesson is that magnetic field effects are not just a laboratory curiosity — they are a real production problem. Understanding the mechanism, as described in this paper, is the first step to controlling it.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a systematic study of the effect of an external alternating magnetic field on the MIG welding arc and droplet transfer. The high-speed photography and force analysis are well executed, and the results are clearly presented.

For pipe fabricators, the takeaway is that magnetic field effects must be considered when welding ferromagnetic materials. If arc blow is a problem, an external magnetic field controller may be a viable solution. The paper's findings on the effect of excitation current on arc deflection provide a useful reference for designing such a controller.

The practical application of this research is still in its early stages, but the potential is significant. In the future, I expect to see magnetic field controllers integrated into welding systems for pipe fabrication, particularly for root pass welding and cladding applications.