Numerical Analysis of Interfacial Stress Evolution in Aluminum/Steel MIG Arc Brazing-Welding
Literature Overview and Core Question
This paper from the Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering (机械工程学报, 2021, Vol. 57, No. 2, pp. 87-96) by Qin Guoliang, Geng Peihao, Chen Yong, and Ren Wenjian from Shandong University addresses a problem that has become increasingly important in modern manufacturing: how to join aluminum to steel. The authors use numerical simulation to analyze the stress evolution at the interface of a lap joint between 1 mm thick 5052 aluminum alloy and 2 mm thick galvanized steel, welded by MIG arc brazing-welding.
The core question is: what happens to the residual stress at the aluminum/steel interface during and after welding? The authors develop a combined heat source model to account for the asymmetric distribution of the arc heat and the enthalpy of the overheated molten droplets, and they use thermal-elastic-plastic finite element analysis to calculate the stress and strain fields.
This is not just an academic exercise. Dissimilar metal joints between aluminum and steel are increasingly used in automotive, aerospace, and other industries to reduce weight and improve fuel efficiency. The joint must be strong enough to carry loads, and the residual stress distribution determines whether the joint will fail in service.
Technical Points and Numerical Simulation Analysis
Heat Source Model
The authors recognize that the lap joint configuration creates an asymmetric heat distribution. The arc heat is not uniformly distributed, and the molten droplets carry additional enthalpy that affects the temperature field. They propose a combined heat source:
- Asymmetric four-ellipsoid heat source — This models the arc heat distribution, accounting for the asymmetry caused by the lap joint configuration. The four ellipsoids represent the different regions of the arc, with different heat intensities.
- Uniform volumetric heat source — This models the heat input from the molten droplets. The droplets are assumed to have a uniform temperature and enthalpy, and they deposit heat uniformly over the weld pool.
The combination of these two heat sources provides a more accurate representation of the actual heat input than a single symmetric heat source. This is important because the temperature field determines the stress field, and errors in the temperature field propagate to errors in the stress field.
Stress and Strain Analysis
The authors use thermal-elastic-plastic finite element analysis to calculate the stress and strain fields. This involves:
- Thermal analysis — Calculate the temperature field at each time step during welding and cooling.
- Mechanical analysis — Calculate the stress and strain fields based on the temperature field and the material properties.
The key results are:
| Location | Residual Stress Distribution |
|---|---|
| Steel base metal near the brazing interface | Compressive stress near the weld, transitioning to tensile stress with increasing distance from the weld center |
| Aluminum side weld metal | Tensile stress equal to the room-temperature yield strength of the aluminum alloy |
| Weld root | Stress reduces to zero or becomes compressive |
| Brazing interface | Large stress difference between the two sides of the interface |
Effect of Heat Input
The authors also investigate the effect of welding heat input on the residual stress distribution. They find:
- The residual stress difference at the interface increases with increasing heat input.
- The interfacial shear strength decreases with increasing heat input.
- The distribution of the stress difference follows an n-shaped (inverted U) curve across the interface.
This is a critical finding. It means that the welding heat input must be carefully controlled to minimize the residual stress difference and maximize the joint strength. Excessive heat input increases the stress difference and reduces the joint strength.
Engineering Practice and Shop Floor Relevance
Why This Matters in Dissimilar Metal Joining
Aluminum/steel joints are used in a wide range of applications:
- Automotive body structures (aluminum panels to steel frames).
- Heat exchangers (aluminum fins to steel tubes).
- Electrical connections (aluminum busbars to steel terminals).
- Structural applications (aluminum cladding to steel structures).
The challenge is that aluminum and steel have very different physical and metallurgical properties:
| Property | Aluminum (5052) | Steel (Galvanized) |
|---|---|---|
| Melting point (°C) | 607 - 649 | 1425 - 1540 |
| Thermal conductivity (W/m·K) | 138 | 50 |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (×10⁻⁶/K) | 23.8 | 12.0 |
| Elastic modulus (GPa) | 70 | 200 |
| Yield strength (MPa) | 193 | 250 - 400 |
The difference in thermal expansion is particularly problematic. When the joint cools, the aluminum contracts more than the steel, creating a stress concentration at the interface. This stress can lead to:
- Cracking at the interface.
- Delamination of the joint.
- Premature failure under cyclic loading.
Practical Implications for Joint Design
The numerical analysis shows that the residual stress at the interface is not uniform. There is a stress concentration at the weld root, and the stress state changes from compressive to tensile across the joint. This has implications for joint design:
- Joint geometry — The lap joint configuration creates a stress concentration at the edge of the overlap. The joint should be designed to minimize this concentration, perhaps by using a scarf joint or a transition joint.
- Filler material — The filler material should have a coefficient of thermal expansion between that of aluminum and steel, to reduce the thermal mismatch stress. However, this is difficult to achieve in practice.
- Heat input control — The welding heat input should be minimized to reduce the residual stress difference. However, insufficient heat input leads to lack of fusion.
Failure Modes and Countermeasures
The most common failure mode for aluminum/steel joints is interfacial fracture. The crack initiates at the interface, where the stress concentration is highest, and propagates along the interface.
The countermeasures are:
- Proper surface preparation — The galvanized steel surface must be cleaned to remove contaminants and ensure good wetting by the filler metal.
- Controlled heat input — The heat input must be sufficient to achieve good wetting but not so high that it degrades the zinc coating or creates excessive intermetallic compounds.
- Post-weld heat treatment — In some cases, a post-weld heat treatment can reduce the residual stress and improve the joint strength.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a good example of how numerical simulation can be used to understand a complex welding process. The authors have developed a sophisticated heat source model that accounts for the specific characteristics of the MIG arc brazing-welding process, and they have used this model to predict the residual stress distribution.
The key insight is that the residual stress at the interface is not just a function of the material properties — it is also a function of the welding process parameters. By controlling the heat input, the welding engineer can influence the residual stress distribution and, consequently, the joint strength.
From my perspective, the most important lesson is that dissimilar metal joints require careful consideration of the stress state. The joint may pass a static strength test, but fail in service due to fatigue or stress corrosion cracking. The welding engineer must think beyond the immediate weld quality and consider the long-term behavior of the joint.
Reference Value and Outlook
This work was published in 2021, and the field of dissimilar metal joining is advancing rapidly. New techniques such as friction stir welding, ultrasonic welding, and laser brazing are being developed to overcome the challenges of aluminum/steel joining.
However, the fundamental issue remains: the thermal mismatch between aluminum and steel creates residual stress that can lead to joint failure. Numerical simulation is a valuable tool for understanding this issue and developing solutions.
For welding engineers, the lesson is to use simulation as a tool, but not to rely on it exclusively. The simulation must be validated against experimental data, and the results must be interpreted with an understanding of the physical processes involved.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd