ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Aluminum/Steel Dissimilar Metal MIG Brazing Joint Corrosion Performance

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Li Jie et al. from Xi'an Aeronautical Vocational and Technical College and Lanzhou University of Technology, published in 2018, addresses a problem that I have encountered on countless projects: how do you join aluminum to steel and get a joint that will survive in a corrosive environment? The paper uses a double-electrode gas metal arc welding (DE-GMAW) MIG brazing process with ER5356 aluminum alloy filler wire to join 1060 aluminum to Q235 galvanized steel in a lap joint configuration. The corrosion behavior of the joint is investigated using immersion corrosion tests and electrochemical corrosion tests, and the effect of welding heat input on corrosion performance is analyzed.

The core finding is that a significant galvanic corrosion effect occurs at the aluminum/steel joint, and that increasing welding heat input decreases the corrosion resistance of the joint. The paper also finds that the formation of intermetallic compounds (IMCs) at the interface reaction layer is detrimental to corrosion performance, and that excessive IMC formation should be avoided.

This is a critical paper for anyone involved in aluminum/steel dissimilar metal welding. The automotive industry has been trying to join aluminum to steel for decades, and the challenge is fundamental: aluminum and steel have very different melting points (660°C vs. 1538°C), very different coefficients of thermal expansion (23.1 μm/m·K vs. 11.7 μm/m·K), and they form brittle intermetallic compounds (FeAl, FeAl2, FeAl3, Fe2Al5, Fe3Al) when they are melted together. The MIG brazing process addresses this by melting only the aluminum filler wire, not the steel base metal, so that the steel remains solid and the joint is formed by brazing rather than fusion welding.

Technical Interpretation: Galvanic Corrosion and Intermetallic Compounds

The galvanic corrosion effect at the aluminum/steel joint is a fundamental problem that cannot be completely eliminated, only mitigated. Aluminum is anodic to steel in the galvanic series, so when the two metals are in electrical contact in a corrosive environment, the aluminum will corrode preferentially. The rate of galvanic corrosion depends on the area ratio of the two metals, the conductivity of the electrolyte, and the presence of any protective coatings.

The paper's finding that increasing welding heat input decreases corrosion resistance is important. Higher heat input means more IMC formation at the interface, and IMCs are typically brittle and have different electrochemical properties than the base metals. The IMC layer can act as a cathode, accelerating the corrosion of the adjacent aluminum. The paper's recommendation to minimize IMC formation is sound, but it must be balanced against the need for sufficient heat input to achieve good wetting and bonding.

The use of ER5356 filler wire is interesting. ER5356 is a 5xxx series aluminum alloy with 5% magnesium. It is a common choice for aluminum welding because it has good strength and corrosion resistance. However, when used for brazing aluminum to steel, the magnesium in the filler wire can react with the zinc coating on the galvanized steel, forming volatile compounds that can cause porosity. The paper does not discuss this issue in detail, but it is a practical concern.

Engineering Practice: What This Means on the Shop Floor

Parameter Low Heat Input High Heat Input Practical Implication
IMC Layer Thickness Thinner Thicker Thicker IMC is more brittle and more corrosive
Corrosion Resistance Better Worse High heat input degrades joint performance
Weld Penetration Shallower Deeper Need balance for adequate bonding
Galvanic Corrosion Rate Lower Higher More IMC accelerates galvanic corrosion
Joint Strength Lower Higher Trade-off between strength and corrosion

When I look at this table, I see the classic trade-off in dissimilar metal welding: you need enough heat to achieve good bonding, but not so much that you form excessive IMCs. This is a delicate balance that requires careful process control. In practice, I would specify the welding parameters based on the results of a welding procedure qualification (WPQ) that includes corrosion testing, not just mechanical testing.

The galvanic corrosion issue is particularly important for applications where the joint will be exposed to a corrosive environment. If the aluminum/steel joint is used in a marine environment, for example, the galvanic corrosion rate will be significant, and the joint will require additional protection such as coatings, cathodic protection, or the use of insulating barriers. The paper does not address these mitigation measures, but they are essential for practical applications.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that I have seen cause problems in real projects: what is the acceptable IMC layer thickness for an aluminum/steel brazed joint? The paper recommends minimizing IMC formation, but it does not provide a specific threshold. In my experience, an IMC layer thickness of less than 10 μm is generally acceptable, but this depends on the application. For structural joints, a thicker IMC layer may be acceptable if the joint is not exposed to a corrosive environment. For corrosion-critical applications, a thinner IMC layer is preferred.

Another question is about the long-term performance of the joint. The paper uses accelerated corrosion tests, which provide useful comparative data but do not necessarily predict long-term service performance. In practice, I would recommend additional testing such as salt spray testing or exposure to a representative service environment to validate the joint performance.

The paper also does not address the issue of the zinc coating on the galvanized steel. The zinc coating is important for the brazing process because it promotes wetting of the steel by the aluminum filler wire. However, the zinc can also cause problems, such as porosity and the formation of zinc-aluminum intermetallic compounds. The paper's use of galvanized steel is appropriate for the application, but the reader should be aware of the potential issues.

Study Insights and Implications

The most important takeaway from this paper is that aluminum/steel dissimilar metal joints are inherently susceptible to galvanic corrosion, and the welding process has a significant effect on the corrosion resistance. The paper demonstrates that controlling welding heat input is critical for minimizing IMC formation and maximizing corrosion resistance. This is a practical insight that can be applied directly on the shop floor.

From a standards perspective, this paper highlights the need for corrosion testing in welding procedure qualifications for dissimilar metal joints. Neither ASME Section IX nor AWS D1.2 requires corrosion testing for welding procedure qualification, but for aluminum/steel joints, corrosion testing is essential. I would recommend that any WPQ for aluminum/steel brazing include corrosion testing in addition to the standard mechanical tests.

In my experience, aluminum/steel dissimilar metal joints are often used in applications where corrosion resistance is not a primary concern, such as electrical connections or structural brackets. However, for applications where the joint will be exposed to a corrosive environment, the findings of this paper are directly applicable. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in aluminum/steel brazing, and I would use its findings as a basis for developing welding procedures that minimize IMC formation and maximize corrosion resistance.