Effect of Filler Wire Selection on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Al-Zn-Mg Alloy Pulsed MIG Welds
Overview of the Study
Diao Guangyun, Wang Dianlong, Li Haichuan, and Liang Zhimin from Hebei University of Science and Technology have conducted a comparative study of three filler wires—ER5356, ER5087, and ER4043—for pulsed MIG welding of a 12 mm thick T4-temper Al-Zn-Mg alloy. This is a highly practical study because filler wire selection is one of the most important decisions in aluminum welding, and the differences between these three wires are not always well understood by fabricators. The Al-Zn-Mg alloy is a high-strength aluminum alloy used in structural applications, and the choice of filler wire can make the difference between a joint that meets specification and one that fails.
Test Setup and Procedure
The authors used a 12 mm thick T4-temper Al-Zn-Mg alloy plate, which is a typical thickness for structural applications. The T4 temper means the alloy has been solution heat treated and naturally aged, giving it moderate strength but good formability. The three filler wires represent the three main families of aluminum filler wires.
| Filler Wire | Composition | Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| ER5356 | Al-Mg (5% Mg) | General purpose, good ductility, moderate strength |
| ER5087 | Al-Mg (5% Mg + Zr) | High strength, grain refining effect from Zr |
| ER4043 | Al-Si (5% Si) | Good fluidity, low melting point, poor strength |
The welding was performed with pulsed MIG, which is the standard process for aluminum welding in most modern fabrication shops. The authors then characterized the microstructure and mechanical properties of the joints.
Microstructure Comparison
The microstructural differences between the three filler wires are striking and have a direct impact on mechanical properties.
| Filler Wire | Weld Microstructure | Grain Size | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| ER5356 | Fine equiaxed grains | Fine | Most uniform structure |
| ER5087 | Coarse columnar grains | Coarse | Zr addition did not refine grains as expected |
| ER4043 | Eutectic dendritic structure | Coarse | Si forms brittle eutectic phase |
The ER5087 weld showed coarse columnar grains, which is surprising because zirconium is typically added to aluminum alloys as a grain refiner. The authors suggest that the zirconium may not have been fully effective in this welding condition, possibly because the cooling rate was too fast for the zirconium to act as a nucleation site. This is a valuable observation because it challenges the common assumption that Zr-containing fillers always produce finer grains.
The ER5356 weld showed fine equiaxed grains, which is consistent with the grain refining effect of magnesium. This is the best microstructure from a mechanical property standpoint.
The ER4043 weld showed a typical eutectic dendritic structure, with silicon particles distributed in an aluminum matrix. The silicon particles are hard and brittle, and they act as crack initiation sites, which explains the poor ductility of this joint.
Mechanical Properties
The mechanical property results are the most important part of this study, and they clearly demonstrate the superiority of the Mg-containing fillers.
| Filler Wire | Tensile Strength (MPa) | Elongation (%) | Fracture Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| ER5356 | 294 | 7.9 | Weld metal |
| ER5087 | 313 | 7.6 | Weld metal |
| ER4043 | 237 | 1.6 | Weld metal |
The ER5087 weld achieved the highest strength at 313 MPa, which is 6.5% higher than ER5356 and 32% higher than ER4043. However, the ER5356 weld had the highest elongation at 7.9%, which is only marginally better than ER5087 at 7.6%. The ER4043 weld was clearly inferior, with only 1.6% elongation—a value that is unacceptable for any structural application.
The fact that all fractures occurred in the weld metal confirms that the weld is the weakest link in the joint, regardless of filler wire. This is consistent with the findings of the other papers in this series.
Engineering Practice Implications
This study has direct implications for filler wire selection in production welding of Al-Zn-Mg alloys.
- ER4043 should not be used for strength-critical applications. The 237 MPa strength and 1.6% elongation are simply too low for structural use. ER4043 is best suited for non-structural applications where weld appearance and fluidity are more important than strength, such as cosmetic welds or castings repairs.
- ER5087 is the best choice for strength-critical applications. The 313 MPa strength is the highest of the three, and the elongation is acceptable. However, the coarse columnar grain structure is a concern for fatigue performance, so I would want to see fatigue data before specifying ER5087 for a dynamically loaded structure.
- ER5356 is the best all-round choice. The 294 MPa strength and 7.9% elongation are both respectable, and the fine equiaxed grain structure is the best of the three for fatigue resistance. If I had to choose one filler wire for a general-purpose Al-Zn-Mg welding application, it would be ER5356.
- The T4 temper of the base metal is a consideration. T4 aluminum has lower strength than T6, but it is more formable. When welding T4 material, the HAZ will over-age and soften, but the base metal itself is already in a relatively soft condition. This means the joint efficiency will be lower than for T6 base metal, and the design must account for this.
Conclusions and Reflections
This is a well-designed study that provides clear, actionable guidance on filler wire selection for Al-Zn-Mg alloys. The key finding is that ER5087 gives the highest strength, ER5356 gives the best combination of strength and ductility, and ER4043 is unsuitable for structural applications. The microstructural analysis explains these differences: Mg-containing fillers produce fine equiaxed grains, while Si-containing fillers produce brittle eutectic structures. For production welding, I would recommend ER5356 as the default choice for Al-Zn-Mg alloys, with ER5087 reserved for applications where maximum strength is required and fatigue is not a concern. I would also recommend that any welding procedure qualification include fatigue testing, because the coarse columnar grains in ER5087 welds may be a concern for cyclic loading. Filler wire selection is not a trivial decision—it can make or break a project.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd