ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

AC MIG Welding Arc Stability Control

Literature Overview and Core Contribution

This paper by Zhang Hua, Jiao Xiangdong, and Pan Jiluan from Tsinghua University, published in China Mechanical Engineering in 1994, addresses the problem of magnetic arc blow in direct current (DC) MIG welding. The authors developed an alternating current (AC) MIG welding power source to solve this problem and describe the work done to achieve arc stability, which is the main challenge in AC MIG welding. They tested four different control schemes for the arc zero-crossing point and achieved arc stability comparable to DC MIG welding. The paper concludes that AC MIG arc stability is closely related to the current before the polarity change and the voltage after the polarity change.

This paper is a classic work from a pioneering research group at Tsinghua University, led by the renowned welding scientist Pan Jiluan. The problem of magnetic arc blow is a persistent issue in pipe welding, particularly when welding thick wall pipe or when the welding current is high. The AC approach offers a solution by eliminating the directional magnetic field that causes the arc to deflect.

Technical Interpretation and Process Analysis

Magnetic arc blow occurs when the magnetic field generated by the welding current interacts with the arc, causing it to deflect from the intended path. This is most severe in DC welding, where the current is constant in one direction. The magnetic field is strongest at the corners of the workpiece and near the ground connection, leading to arc deflection that can cause lack of fusion, porosity, and spatter.

Parameter DC MIG AC MIG Change
Magnetic arc blow Severe Minimal Eliminated
Arc stability Good Good (with control) Comparable
Polarity effect Constant Alternating Balanced heat input
Spatter level Moderate Low Reduced

AC welding solves this problem by alternating the current direction, which cancels out the net magnetic field. However, AC welding introduces a new challenge: arc stability at the zero-crossing point. When the current passes through zero, the arc tends to extinguish because there is insufficient energy to maintain the ionization of the arc gap. The paper addresses this by developing control schemes that maintain the arc during the zero-crossing period.

The four control schemes tested in the paper represent different approaches to maintaining the arc at zero-crossing. The key insight is that the current before the polarity change and the voltage after the polarity change are critical parameters. If the current before the change is too low, the arc may not have enough energy to sustain itself. If the voltage after the change is too low, the arc may not re-ignite properly.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

In pipe welding, magnetic arc blow is a common problem, particularly when welding thick wall pipe or when the welding current is high. I have seen cases where the arc deflected by as much as 10 to 15 degrees from the intended path, causing the weld to be misaligned and leading to lack of fusion on one side of the joint. This is particularly problematic in root pass welding, where the arc must be precisely positioned to achieve complete penetration.

The AC approach described in this paper offers a solution, but it introduces the challenge of arc stability. In practice, the implementation of AC MIG welding requires careful control of the power source and the welding parameters. The paper's finding that arc stability is related to the current before the polarity change and the voltage after the change provides a practical guideline for setting the welding parameters.

In one project involving the welding of 20 mm thick carbon steel pipe, we experienced severe magnetic arc blow when using DC welding. The arc would deflect to one side, causing lack of fusion and excessive spatter. We tried various countermeasures, including repositioning the ground connection and using magnetic field compensators, but none were fully effective. The AC approach, with proper control, would have been a more elegant solution.

However, the implementation of AC MIG welding requires a more complex power source than DC welding. The power source must be capable of producing a high-quality AC waveform with precise control of the zero-crossing point. This is a significant engineering challenge, and the paper's contribution lies in demonstrating that it can be achieved.

Critical Reflections and Study Insights

The paper's focus on the zero-crossing point is well placed, as this is the most critical aspect of AC welding. The finding that the current before the polarity change and the voltage after the change are critical parameters provides a practical guideline for controlling the arc. This is a valuable insight that can be applied in practice.

One limitation of the paper is that it does not provide detailed information on the welding parameters used in the experiments. This makes it difficult to reproduce the results or to apply the findings to different welding conditions. The paper would be more useful if it included a table of the welding parameters and the corresponding arc stability results.

Another consideration is the effect of AC welding on the weld metal properties. AC welding alternates the polarity, which means that the heat input is balanced between the electrode and the workpiece. This can affect the penetration profile and the microstructure of the weld. The paper does not address these aspects, which are important for practical applications.

The paper also does not discuss the practical challenges of implementing AC MIG welding in a production environment. The power source is more complex and expensive than a DC power source, and the control system must be robust enough to handle the demands of the welding process. These are important considerations for anyone considering the adoption of AC MIG welding.

Conclusion and Forward Outlook

This paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of welding by demonstrating that AC MIG welding can achieve arc stability comparable to DC MIG welding with proper control. The solution to magnetic arc blow offered by AC welding is significant, as it addresses a persistent problem in pipe welding. The finding that arc stability is related to the current before the polarity change and the voltage after the change provides a practical guideline for process control.

The practical implications for the steel pipe industry are significant. AC MIG welding offers a solution to magnetic arc blow, which is a common problem in pipe welding. The next step is to develop a practical AC MIG welding system that can be integrated into existing welding equipment. This will require a robust power source and control system, as well as a thorough understanding of the welding parameters required for different pipe sizes and materials. The foundation laid by this paper provides a solid starting point for that development.