Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of a New Aluminum Alloy MIG Welded Joint
Literature Overview and Core Message
This paper by Jin Congcong and colleagues from Dalian University of Technology and the Air Force Equipment Department, published in Transactions of the China Welding Institution in 2024, investigates the microstructure and mechanical properties of a new aluminum alloy MIG welded joint. The study focuses on a 10 mm thick aluminum alloy and compares two welding procedures: two-layer three-pass and three-layer four-pass single-side MIG welding. The key findings are that both procedures produce good weld appearance, with phases of α-Al, Al6(Fe,Mn), and Mg2Si present in the weld metal. The heat-affected zone near the fusion line contains large equiaxed grains, while the weld edges have columnar grains perpendicular to the fusion line, and the weld center has dendritic grains. The grain size in each layer is different, with the previous layer being smaller than the subsequent layer. Fe and Mn elements segregate in the heat-affected zone to form Al6(Fe,Mn) phase, while Mg tends to precipitate along grain boundaries or distribute in the weld structure as a balanced phase.
The mechanical properties show a significant difference between the two procedures. Joint 1 (two-layer three-pass) has an average tensile strength of 294 MPa, which is 78.4% of the base metal's tensile strength, with an elongation of 6.56%. Joint 2 (three-layer four-pass) has an average tensile strength of 350 MPa, which is 93.3% of the base metal's tensile strength, with an elongation of 12.3%. The hardness distribution shows that the weld metal has the lowest hardness, followed by the heat-affected zone, with the base metal having the highest hardness. The hardness of each layer in the multi-layer weld is related to the welding sequence, with the first layer having the highest hardness.
This paper is directly relevant to the shipbuilding industry, where the trend towards lightweight construction is driving the use of aluminum alloys instead of steel. The authors' comparison of two different welding procedures provides valuable data for selecting the right procedure for a given application.
Technical Interpretation of Microstructure and Mechanical Properties
Microstructural Evolution in Multi-Pass Welding
The microstructural observations are consistent with what we would expect from a multi-pass weld in an aluminum alloy. The heat-affected zone near the fusion line has large equiaxed grains, which are the result of the high temperature experienced during welding. The weld edges have columnar grains that grow perpendicular to the fusion line, which is the direction of maximum heat extraction. The weld center has dendritic grains, which are typical of the last region to solidify.
The observation that the grain size in each layer is different is interesting. The previous layer has a smaller grain size than the subsequent layer. This is because the subsequent layer reheats the previous layer, causing grain growth. This is a well-known phenomenon in multi-pass welding, but the authors have quantified it and linked it to the mechanical properties.
Phase Formation and Element Segregation
The presence of α-Al, Al6(Fe,Mn), and Mg2Si phases is typical for this type of aluminum alloy. The Al6(Fe,Mn) phase forms in the heat-affected zone due to the segregation of Fe and Mn, which are insoluble in the aluminum matrix. The Mg2Si phase is the main strengthening phase in this alloy, and it precipitates during solidification and subsequent aging.
The segregation of Fe and Mn in the heat-affected zone is a concern because it can lead to the formation of coarse, brittle phases that reduce the ductility of the joint. The authors found that the Fe and Mn segregate to form Al6(Fe,Mn) phase, which is a common intermetallic compound in aluminum alloys.
Mechanical Properties and Fracture Behavior
The tensile strength of the joints is a key indicator of the welding procedure's effectiveness. Joint 2 (three-layer four-pass) has a significantly higher tensile strength (350 MPa vs. 294 MPa) and elongation (12.3% vs. 6.56%) than Joint 1 (two-layer three-pass). This is a substantial difference, and it suggests that the three-layer four-pass procedure produces a better joint.
The authors describe the fracture behavior as ductile fracture, which is consistent with the elongation values. The higher elongation of Joint 2 indicates that the weld metal has better ductility, which is likely due to the finer grain structure and more uniform distribution of phases.
Table: Comparison of Mechanical Properties for Two Welding Procedures
| Property | Joint 1 (Two-Layer Three-Pass) | Joint 2 (Three-Layer Four-Pass) |
|---|---|---|
| Average tensile strength | 294 MPa | 350 MPa |
| Percentage of base metal strength | 78.4% | 93.3% |
| Elongation | 6.56% | 12.3% |
| Fracture behavior | Ductile fracture | Ductile fracture |
| Hardness distribution | Weld metal lowest, base metal highest | Weld metal lowest, base metal highest |
Practical Implications for the Shop Floor
Selecting the Right Welding Procedure
The most important practical takeaway from this paper is that the welding procedure has a significant effect on the mechanical properties of the joint. For a 10 mm thick aluminum alloy, the three-layer four-pass procedure produces a joint with 93.3% of the base metal's tensile strength, which is a very good result. The two-layer three-pass procedure produces a joint with only 78.4% of the base metal's tensile strength, which may not be acceptable for some applications.
This is a classic example of the trade-off between productivity and quality. The two-layer three-pass procedure is faster and uses less filler wire, but it produces a weaker joint. The three-layer four-pass procedure is slower and uses more filler wire, but it produces a stronger joint. For a shipbuilding application where the joint is critical to the structural integrity of the vessel, the three-layer four-pass procedure is likely the better choice.
Controlling Interpass Temperature
The observation that the grain size in each layer is different, with the previous layer being smaller than the subsequent layer, highlights the importance of controlling the interpass temperature. If the interpass temperature is too high, the previous layer will experience grain growth, which will reduce the mechanical properties of the joint. The welder should be instructed to allow the joint to cool to a specified interpass temperature before starting the next pass.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Porosity | Hydrogen gas, moisture on the wire or base metal | Ensure the base metal and filler wire are clean and dry, use proper shielding gas flow |
| Lack of fusion | Low heat input, incorrect torch angle | Increase heat input, ensure proper torch angle and travel speed |
| Undercut | High heat input, incorrect torch angle | Reduce heat input, adjust torch angle |
| Grain coarsening in HAZ | High heat input, high interpass temperature | Reduce heat input, control interpass temperature |
Study Insights and Reflections
This paper is a good example of how to evaluate a welding procedure by combining microstructural analysis with mechanical testing. The authors did not just measure the tensile strength; they also examined the microstructure to understand why one procedure produces a better joint than the other. This is the kind of thorough investigation that is necessary when you are dealing with a new material or a new application.
The finding that the three-layer four-pass procedure produces a joint with 93.3% of the base metal's tensile strength is a significant result. For a shipbuilding application, this is a very good result, and it suggests that this procedure could be used for critical structural welds. However, I would like to see additional data on the fatigue properties of the joint, as fatigue is often the critical failure mode in ship structures.
Conclusion
This study on the microstructure and mechanical properties of a new aluminum alloy MIG welded joint provides valuable data for the shipbuilding industry. The authors compared two welding procedures and found that the three-layer four-pass procedure produces a joint with significantly better mechanical properties than the two-layer three-pass procedure. The microstructural analysis explains the difference: the three-layer four-pass procedure produces a finer grain structure and a more uniform distribution of phases. The key practical takeaway is that the welding procedure must be carefully selected based on the application's requirements, and the interpass temperature must be controlled to avoid grain coarsening. This paper is a good example of how to link microstructure to properties and how to use that link to make informed decisions on the shop floor.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd