ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Reheat Cracking in 12Cr1MoVG TIG Welded Joints of Low-Temperature Reheaters

Overview and Significance of the Failure

This paper addresses a cracking failure in a TIG welded joint of 12Cr1MoVG steel used in a low-temperature reheater of a power plant. The authors employed macro observation, metallographic examination, SEM with EDS, and hardness testing to determine the root cause. The conclusion is that the cracks are reheat cracks, and the leakage resulted from improper execution of the welding procedure combined with long-term aging segregation at the fusion line, which reduced toughness and increased brittleness, allowing thermal expansion stress and internal pressure to drive rapid crack propagation.

From my perspective, this is a classic case of a material that is well understood in the laboratory but mishandled on the shop floor. 12Cr1MoVG is a Cr-Mo heat-resistant steel widely used in boiler components, and its weldability is highly sensitive to heat input, preheat, interpass temperature, and post-weld heat treatment (PWHT). The fact that the failure occurred at the fusion line, not in the weld metal or base metal, tells me that the issue is not with the filler wire or the base material chemistry, but with the thermal cycle and the subsequent service exposure.

Technical Analysis of the Failure Mechanism

Material and Joint Configuration

12Cr1MoVG is a low-alloy Cr-Mo steel designed for service temperatures up to 560°C. Its nominal composition is approximately 0.08–0.15% C, 0.9–1.2% Cr, 0.25–0.35% Mo, with V added at 0.15–0.30% for precipitation strengthening. The V and Mo combine with C to form fine carbides that provide creep strength. However, these same carbides can precipitate at grain boundaries during PWHT or long-term service, leading to a phenomenon known as reheat cracking or stress-relief cracking.

The TIG welding process was used for the root and fill passes, which is standard for thin-wall boiler tubes. The joint is a butt joint, and the tube wall thickness is typically in the range of 4–8 mm for low-temperature reheaters. The welding parameters are critical: heat input should be controlled to limit the width of the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and to ensure complete transformation of the base metal to martensite or bainite in the HAZ, which is then tempered by PWHT.

Root Cause Determination

The authors' conclusion that the cracks are reheat cracks is well supported by the evidence. Reheat cracking occurs in the coarse-grained HAZ of Cr-Mo steels when the residual stresses from welding are relieved by PWHT or by service exposure at elevated temperatures. The mechanism involves the precipitation of carbides within the grains, which strengthens the matrix, while the grain boundaries are weakened by the depletion of carbon and the formation of brittle phases. When the stress relaxation strain is accommodated preferentially at the grain boundaries, intergranular cracking occurs.

The key evidence for reheat cracking in this case is:

  1. The crack location at the fusion line, which is the typical site for reheat cracking in the coarse-grained HAZ.
  2. The intergranular morphology of the cracks, as revealed by metallography and SEM.
  3. The presence of aging segregation at the fusion line, which indicates that the material had been in service at elevated temperature for a prolonged period.
  4. The hardness measurements, which would show elevated hardness in the HAZ if the PWHT was inadequate or if the material had been over-aged.

Role of Welding Procedure Execution

The paper states that the welding procedure was not executed properly. This is a critical point. In my experience, the most common cause of reheat cracking in Cr-Mo steels is not the material itself but the failure to maintain the required preheat and interpass temperature. For 12Cr1MoVG, the preheat temperature should be in the range of 150–250°C, and the interpass temperature should not exceed 300°C. If the preheat is too low, the HAZ will transform to martensite, which is hard and susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking. If the interpass temperature is too high, the HAZ will become coarse-grained, increasing the susceptibility to reheat cracking.

Another critical factor is the PWHT. For 12Cr1MoVG, the PWHT temperature is typically 720–750°C with a holding time of 1–2 hours depending on wall thickness. If the PWHT is skipped or performed at too low a temperature, the residual stresses will not be relieved, and the HAZ will remain hard and brittle. The combination of high residual stress and brittle HAZ is a recipe for reheat cracking during service.

Engineering Practice Insights

The Importance of Welding Procedure Qualification

This failure underscores the importance of welding procedure qualification (WPQ) and the need for strict adherence to the approved welding procedure specification (WPS). In many plants, there is a tendency to treat the WPS as a document that exists on paper but is not followed in practice. This is a serious error. The WPS is not a suggestion; it is a legal and technical requirement that ensures the weldment will perform as designed.

For Cr-Mo steels, the WPS must specify:

Any deviation from these parameters, even a small one, can have a significant impact on the mechanical properties and the service life of the joint.

The Role of NDT and Inspection

The failure was detected by leakage, which means that the crack had already propagated through the wall. This is a late-stage failure. The question is: could it have been detected earlier? In my experience, the answer is yes, if the right NDT methods were used. For Cr-Mo steel welds, the most effective methods for detecting reheat cracking are:

  1. Ultrasonic testing (UT) with a high-frequency probe, which can detect the crack before it reaches the surface.
  2. Magnetic particle testing (MT) or penetrant testing (PT) for surface-breaking cracks.
  3. Hardness testing of the HAZ, which can indicate whether the PWHT was effective.

In a power plant, the inspection of reheater tubes is challenging because the tubes are closely spaced and access is limited. However, the use of phased array UT (PAUT) or time-of-flight diffraction (TOFD) can detect cracks in the HAZ with high sensitivity. The key is to perform the inspection at the right time—not just during the initial installation but also during subsequent maintenance outages.

Lessons for the Shop Floor

This case teaches several important lessons:

  1. Never assume that the welding procedure will be followed correctly. Supervision and inspection are essential.
  2. The HAZ is the weakest link in a Cr-Mo steel weldment. It is not the weld metal or the base metal.
  3. Reheat cracking can occur years after the weld was made. The material does not fail immediately; it fails when the combination of stress, temperature, and time reaches a critical point.
  4. The inspection schedule must be based on the actual service conditions, not just on the design life.

Conclusions and Recommendations

This paper provides a clear and well-documented case of reheat cracking in a 12Cr1MoVG TIG welded joint. The root cause is a combination of improper welding procedure execution and long-term service exposure, which led to aging segregation at the fusion line and a reduction in toughness. The failure was ultimately caused by the propagation of a reheat crack under the combined action of thermal expansion stress and internal pressure.

For engineers working with Cr-Mo steels, the key takeaways are:

  1. Strict adherence to the WPS is non-negotiable. Every parameter must be verified and documented.
  2. The HAZ must be inspected after welding and after PWHT to ensure that the hardness is within acceptable limits.
  3. The inspection schedule for Cr-Mo steel components should include UT or PAUT at the fusion line to detect reheat cracks before they propagate through the wall.
  4. The PWHT must be performed correctly, with the temperature verified by thermocouples and the holding time calculated based on the actual wall thickness.

In my experience, reheat cracking is a preventable failure. It occurs when the welding procedure is not followed, when the PWHT is inadequate, or when the material is subjected to service conditions that exceed its design limits. By understanding the mechanism and the factors that contribute to it, we can take the necessary steps to prevent it. This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the welding and inspection of Cr-Mo steel components.