Underwater Local Dry TIG Welding of Duplex Stainless Steel: Process Development and Weld Quality Assessment
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This study by Ma Zhaoxuan and colleagues from Harbin Institute of Technology (Weihai) addresses the challenge of underwater welding for repair and maintenance of offshore structures. The authors developed a small, movable gas-shielded local dry TIG welding torch with a double-layer gas shielding design and tested it on 2507 duplex stainless steel.
The key findings are practical and significant. The optimal gas flow rates are 10 L/min for the inner gas and 5 L/min for the outer gas, resulting in the best weld formation and the highest depth-to-width ratio. Increasing welding current reduces molten pool stability, but excessive current causes the arc to be constrained by the inner nozzle and inner shielding gas, which actually increases penetration and depth-to-width ratio. Pulsed welding improves arc stability in the underwater environment. Compared to onshore welding, the rapid cooling in water causes the austenite precipitates within ferrite grains to change from acicular to granular, with austenite precipitation shifting from grain boundaries to intragranular sites, and the austenite precipitates become smaller with grain refinement. The study confirms that this torch can achieve stable underwater TIG welding, and with appropriate parameters, the weld quality is similar to onshore welds.
Technical Points and Process Analysis
Underwater Welding Challenges
Underwater welding presents several unique challenges:
- Water cooling: The rapid heat extraction by water causes faster cooling rates, which can lead to hard, brittle microstructures and hydrogen cracking.
- Arc instability: The presence of water and bubbles disrupts the arc, causing instability and poor weld quality.
- Shielding gas loss: The shielding gas is rapidly dispersed in water, making it difficult to maintain an effective protective atmosphere.
- Visibility: The water and bubbles obscure the weld pool, making it difficult for the welder to see.
The local dry method addresses these challenges by creating a small dry cavity around the weld using a gas-shielded torch. The double-layer gas shielding design is critical: the inner gas protects the weld pool and arc, while the outer gas forms a curtain that displaces water and maintains the dry cavity.
Gas Flow and Arc Stability
The optimal gas flow rates of 10 L/min inner and 5 L/min outer are a good starting point. The inner gas must be sufficient to maintain a stable arc and protect the weld pool, but not so high that it causes turbulence and disrupts the molten pool. The outer gas must be sufficient to maintain the dry cavity, but not so high that it creates excessive pressure and disturbs the weld.
The finding that increasing welding current reduces molten pool stability is expected—higher current increases heat input and agitation. However, the observation that excessive current increases penetration due to arc constriction is interesting. This suggests that the inner nozzle and shielding gas create a "plasma-like" effect that focuses the arc, increasing penetration.
Pulsed Welding Benefits
Pulsed welding is a well-established technique for improving arc stability and controlling heat input. In the underwater environment, where arc stability is a major challenge, pulsed welding provides additional benefits. The pulse current creates a more stable arc, reduces spatter, and allows better control of the molten pool.
Microstructural Differences Between Underwater and Onshore Welds
The microstructural differences are a direct consequence of the faster cooling rate in water. The austenite precipitates within ferrite grains change from acicular to granular, and the precipitation site shifts from grain boundaries to intragranular. This is significant because it affects the mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of the weld.
| Parameter | Underwater Weld | Onshore Weld | Practical Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooling rate | Faster | Slower | Finer grains, higher hardness |
| Austenite morphology | Granular, intragranular | Acicular, grain boundary | Different mechanical properties |
| Austenite size | Smaller | Larger | Higher strength, lower toughness |
| Grain size | Refined | Coarser | Higher strength |
| Corrosion resistance | Potentially reduced | Baseline | Requires verification |
The finer grain size and intragranular austenite may improve strength but could reduce toughness and corrosion resistance. This must be verified through testing.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Shop Floor Considerations
Underwater welding is a specialized operation with significant safety and quality challenges. The local dry method offers a viable approach for repair and maintenance, but it requires specialized equipment and skilled operators.
The following factors are critical for successful underwater TIG welding:
- Torch design: The double-layer gas shielding design is essential. The torch must be small enough to maneuver in confined spaces but robust enough to withstand the underwater environment.
- Gas flow control: Precise control of inner and outer gas flow rates is essential. The optimal values will vary with water depth, current, and joint geometry.
- Welding parameters: Pulsed welding is recommended for arc stability. Current, pulse frequency, and duty cycle must be optimized for the specific application.
- Diver safety: The diver must be properly trained and equipped. The welding operation must be coordinated with the diver's movements.
- Quality control: The weld must be inspected using appropriate NDT methods, including visual inspection, penetrant testing, and ultrasonic testing.
Standards and Acceptance Criteria
Underwater welding is governed by standards such as AWS D3.6M, which specifies the requirements for underwater welding. The acceptance criteria for weld quality are generally similar to onshore welding, but the inspection methods may differ. For duplex stainless steel, the corrosion resistance and toughness requirements are particularly important.
Case Study: Offshore Repair
In my experience, underwater welding is often used for emergency repairs on offshore structures. The ability to perform a high-quality weld in situ can save significant time and cost compared to dry docking. However, the quality of the weld must be verified through rigorous testing, and the repair must be designed to withstand the service conditions.
Reflections and Implications
This study represents a significant advancement in underwater welding technology. The development of a small, movable gas-shielded local dry TIG torch with double-layer gas shielding is a practical solution to a challenging problem. The demonstration that weld quality can be similar to onshore welds is particularly encouraging.
The key lesson is that underwater welding is no longer a "last resort" for repairs. With the right equipment and process control, it can produce high-quality welds that meet the same standards as onshore welds. This has significant implications for the offshore industry, where downtime is expensive and repairs must be performed quickly.
For our industry, the practical takeaway is that underwater TIG welding with local dry shielding should be considered for offshore repair and maintenance. The investment in specialized equipment and training is justified by the potential savings in time and cost. However, the process must be qualified for each specific application, and the weld quality must be verified through testing.
The study's contribution is its systematic development of the torch and process parameters, providing a solid foundation for practical application. The microstructural analysis is also valuable, as it highlights the differences between underwater and onshore welds and the need for careful evaluation of properties.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd