TIG Welding of Dissimilar Aluminum Alloys: SLM AlSi10Mg and Wrought 6061-T6
Literature Overview and Additive Manufacturing Context
This paper from AVIC Jincheng Nanjing Engineering Research Center and Nanchang Hangkong University addresses a topic that is becoming increasingly important in the aerospace and automotive industries: joining additively manufactured (AM) aluminum alloys to wrought aluminum alloys. The authors used TIG welding with ER4043 filler wire to join SLM (selective laser melting) AlSi10Mg to wrought 6061-T6 aluminum alloy, and analysed the microstructure and mechanical properties of the joints at different welding currents.
The relevance to pipe and fitting fabricators may not be immediately obvious, but the principles of dissimilar aluminum welding are directly applicable to the joining of different aluminum alloy grades in piping systems, heat exchangers, and structural components. The challenges of welding dissimilar aluminum alloys — differences in melting point, thermal conductivity, and solidification behaviour — are the same whether the alloys are produced by AM or conventional processing.
Technical Analysis of Dissimilar Aluminum Welding
Joint Design and Process Parameters
The authors used a butt joint configuration with ER4043 (Al-Si5) filler wire. The welding was performed with TIG using pulsed current, with peak currents of 125 A and 140 A. The choice of ER4043 filler is significant because it provides good crack resistance and is compatible with both AlSi10Mg and 6061-T6.
The paper reports that both peak current levels produced welds with good appearance and quality. However, the microstructural and mechanical properties differed significantly between the two current levels.
Microstructural Features
The paper identifies several important microstructural features:
- Porosity distribution: On the AlSi10Mg side of the weld, porosity was observed to form in a "chain" pattern, while the 6061-T6 side had lower porosity. The chain-like porosity on the AlSi10Mg side is attributed to the gas content of the SLM material, which may contain entrapped gas from the powder feedstock or the SLM process itself. The lower porosity at low current is attributed to the reduced heat input, which allows less time for gas bubble growth and coalescence.
- Grain structure: The weld metal near the AlSi10Mg side was equiaxed, while the weld metal near the 6061-T6 side was columnar. The centre of the weld was coarse equiaxed. This difference is attributed to the different cooling rates and thermal gradients on each side of the weld. The AlSi10Mg side, with its higher silicon content, provides more nucleation sites for equiaxed grain formation, while the 6061-T6 side, with its lower silicon content, promotes columnar growth.
- HAZ width: The HAZ width on both sides increased with welding current, as did the grain size in the different regions. This is consistent with the higher heat input at higher current.
Mechanical Properties
The mechanical properties of the joints are summarised as follows:
| Parameter | Low Current (125 A) | High Current (140 A) |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | 185 MPa | Lower |
| Elongation | <4% | <4% |
| Fracture location | 6061-T6 HAZ | 6061-T6 HAZ |
| Hardness | Higher | Lower |
The tensile strength of 185 MPa is relatively low compared to the base materials. For comparison, the typical tensile strength of wrought 6061-T6 is around 310 MPa, and SLM AlSi10Mg can achieve 300-350 MPa depending on the heat treatment condition. The joint efficiency is therefore approximately 60%, which is typical for dissimilar aluminum welds.
The low elongation (<4%) indicates that the joints are relatively brittle. This is attributed to the precipitation of brittle intermetallic phases along the grain boundaries in the 6061-T6 HAZ, which reduces the ductility of the joint. The fracture location in the 6061-T6 HAZ confirms that this is the weakest region of the joint.
Effect of Welding Current
The paper reports that increasing the welding current from 125 A to 140 A resulted in a decrease in the average hardness of the weld metal and a decrease in the tensile strength of the joint. This is consistent with the higher heat input at higher current, which causes grain coarsening and over-aging of the 6061-T6 HAZ.
The 6061-T6 alloy is a precipitation-hardened alloy, and the HAZ is susceptible to over-aging when subjected to the thermal cycle of welding. The heat input from welding causes the precipitates to coarsen, reducing the strength of the HAZ. This is a well-known problem in welding 6xxx series aluminum alloys, and it is the primary reason why the fracture occurs in the HAZ.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd