Comparative Study of Galvanometer Scanning Laser Welding and TIG Welding of Zinc-Aluminum-Magnesium Coated Steel Plates
Literature Overview and Industrial Context
This study from Gansu Iron and Steel Vocational Technical College and Lanzhou University of Technology compares the joint formation and properties of zinc-aluminum-magnesium coated steel plates welded by galvanometer scanning laser welding (GSL) and tungsten inert gas (TIG) welding. The authors investigated the macro morphology, microstructure, and mechanical properties of the joints produced by both processes.
From my perspective in the steel pipe and fitting industry, the welding of coated steel plates is a perennial challenge. The zinc coating on galvanised steel has a lower melting point than the steel substrate, which causes it to vaporise during welding. This vaporisation creates porosity, spatter, and coating damage that can compromise the corrosion resistance of the joint.
The development of zinc-aluminum-magnesium coatings has improved the corrosion resistance of coated steel plates compared to conventional galvanised steel. However, the welding of these coated steels presents new challenges because the aluminum and magnesium in the coating can react with the steel substrate during welding.
Key Technical Points and Interpretation
The study reports significant differences between the GSL and TIG welded joints. The GSL joint has a finer microstructure with smaller grain size and narrower heat-affected zone (HAZ). The TIG joint exhibits coarser grains and wider HAZ due to the higher heat input of the TIG process.
Comparison of Joint Characteristics
| Characteristic | GSL Joint | TIG Joint |
|---|---|---|
| Weld zone microstructure | Acicular and polygonal ferrite, granular bainite | Irregular blocky ferrite, granular bainite, Widmanstätten structure |
| Grain size | Smaller | Larger |
| HAZ width | Narrower | Wider |
| Coating damage | Less severe | More severe |
| Weld bead appearance | Smooth, uniform | Some undercut, coating burn-off |
The presence of Widmanstätten structure in the TIG joint is a significant finding. Widmanstätten ferrite forms when the cooling rate is relatively slow, allowing the ferrite to grow in a needle-like pattern from the austenite grain boundaries. This structure is generally associated with reduced toughness and ductility.
Mechanical Property Comparison
| Property | GSL Joint | TIG Joint | Base Metal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | Comparable to base metal | Comparable to base metal | Reference |
| Elongation | Higher than TIG joint | Lower than GSL joint | Reference |
| Plasticity | Better | Worse | Reference |
The GSL joint exhibits approximately 6% higher elongation than the TIG joint, indicating better plasticity. This is consistent with the finer grain size and absence of Widmanstätten structure in the GSL joint.
Microstructural Analysis
The GSL joint microstructure consists of acicular and polygonal ferrite with some granular bainite. This is a typical microstructure for low-carbon steel welds produced with low heat input. The acicular ferrite provides good strength and toughness because it has a fine, interlocking structure that resists crack propagation.
The TIG joint microstructure consists of irregular blocky ferrite and granular bainite with Widmanstätten structure. The Widmanstätten structure is a concern because it can reduce the toughness of the joint. The presence of this structure in the TIG joint is attributed to the higher heat input and slower cooling rate of the TIG process.
Microstructural Features and Their Effects
| Feature | GSL Joint | TIG Joint | Effect on Properties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acicular ferrite | Present | Absent | Improves strength and toughness |
| Polygonal ferrite | Present | Present | Provides ductility |
| Granular bainite | Small amount | Present | Reduces toughness |
| Widmanstätten structure | Absent | Present | Reduces toughness and ductility |
Engineering Practice Implications
For the steel pipe and fitting industry, the welding of coated steel is a common operation. The findings of this study have direct relevance to the production of welded pipe and fittings from coated steel.
Applications of Coated Steel in Pipe and Fitting Manufacturing
| Application | Coating Type | Welding Process Consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Pipe for water distribution | Zinc-aluminum-magnesium | GSL preferred for thin wall |
| Fittings for HVAC systems | Zinc-aluminum-magnesium | GSL preferred for thin wall |
| Structural pipe | Zinc-aluminum-magnesium | TIG acceptable for thick wall |
| Pipe for agricultural use | Zinc-aluminum-magnesium | GSL preferred |
The GSL process offers several advantages for welding coated steel:
- Lower heat input reduces coating damage.
- Faster welding speed increases productivity.
- Finer grain size improves joint properties.
- Narrower HAZ reduces the extent of coating damage.
Key Questions and Reflections
The study raises important questions about the practical application of GSL welding for coated steel. The most significant is the effect of the welding process on the corrosion resistance of the joint. The coating damage caused by welding can expose the steel substrate to corrosion, even if the joint has good mechanical properties.
In my experience with galvanised steel pipe, the corrosion resistance of the welded joint is often the limiting factor in the service life of the pipe. The zinc coating is sacrificed to protect the steel, but if the coating is damaged during welding, the steel is exposed and can corrode rapidly.
Potential Issues and Mitigation Strategies
| Issue | Root Cause | Mitigation Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Coating burn-off | High heat input | Use GSL process, minimise heat input |
| Porosity | Zinc vaporisation | Use GSL process, control shielding gas |
| Spatter | Zinc vaporisation | Use GSL process, optimise process parameters |
| Reduced corrosion resistance | Coating damage | Apply repair coating after welding |
Study Insights and Implications for the Industry
This study provides valuable data on the comparative performance of GSL and TIG welding for zinc-aluminum-magnesium coated steel. The findings clearly demonstrate that GSL welding produces joints with better microstructure, finer grain size, and superior mechanical properties compared to TIG welding.
For the pipe and fitting industry, the GSL process offers significant advantages for welding coated steel. The lower heat input reduces coating damage, and the finer grain size improves joint properties. The GSL process should be considered for applications where coated steel is welded and where joint quality is critical.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates that galvanometer scanning laser welding produces superior joints in zinc-aluminum-magnesium coated steel compared to TIG welding. The GSL joint has finer grain size, narrower heat-affected zone, and better mechanical properties, including approximately 6% higher elongation. The TIG joint exhibits Widmanstätten structure, which is associated with reduced toughness and ductility. For the pipe and fitting industry, the GSL process offers significant advantages for welding coated steel, including reduced coating damage, improved joint properties, and higher productivity. The process should be considered for applications where coated steel is welded and where joint quality is critical. Further research is needed to evaluate the long-term corrosion resistance of GSL welded joints in coated steel and to develop process windows for specific applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd