ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Double TIG Active Arc Additive Manufacturing: Process and Parameter Effects

1. Literature Overview and Why It Matters

This 2024 paper from Chongqing University of Technology and Lanzhou University of Technology represents a significant step forward in wire-arc additive manufacturing (WAAM). The authors, Zhang Jia and colleagues, propose a double TIG active arc configuration, using two TIG torches in tandem with a small addition of oxygen to the shielding gas, to deposit SUS304 austenitic stainless steel. Their goal was to overcome the fundamental limitation of conventional TIG-based WAAM: low deposition rate.

The results are impressive. With a 1.2 mm diameter wire, they achieved a deposition rate of 2.7 kg/h, which is roughly double that of conventional TIG-based WAAM at comparable current. The addition of oxygen reduced the surface tension of the molten pool, improving wetting and spreading, and the double arc configuration increased the heat input efficiency. The microstructure remained columnar dendritic, oriented perpendicular to the deposition direction, and the mechanical properties showed only a slight decrease in tensile strength and elongation with oxygen addition.

For those of us in the pipe and fitting industry, this is directly relevant. WAAM is increasingly used to produce large-diameter pipe fittings, flanges, and complex manifolds, where the buy-to-fly ratio of forged or cast components is poor. The ability to deposit stainless steel at 2.7 kg/h with good mechanical properties makes WAAM a more competitive manufacturing route for these components.

2. Core Technical Points: Process Configuration and Parameter Effects

The double TIG active arc configuration consists of two TIG torches arranged in tandem, with a common shielding gas supply that includes a small percentage of oxygen. The wire is fed between the two arcs, and the deposition parameters are controlled independently for each torch.

The key process parameters and their effects are summarised below:

Parameter Range Tested Effect on Deposit Geometry Effect on Mechanical Properties
Oxygen addition 0–2% Reduces surface tension, improves wetting and spreading, increases deposit width Slight decrease in tensile strength and elongation
Deposition current (front torch) 80–120 A Higher current increases deposit width, decreases height Minimal effect
Deposition current (rear torch) 80–120 A Higher current increases deposit height, decreases width Minimal effect
Arc travel speed 2–6 mm/s Higher speed decreases both width and height Minimal effect
Wire feed speed 2–6 m/min Higher feed speed increases height, minimal effect on width Minimal effect

The interaction between the two torches is critical. The front torch preheats the substrate and creates a molten pool, while the rear torch adds heat and controls the pool shape. By adjusting the current distribution between the two torches, the operator can independently control the deposit width and height. This is a significant advantage over conventional single-torch TIG, where width and height are coupled.

The oxygen addition is the other key innovation. Oxygen is normally considered a contaminant in TIG welding, but in this application, it acts as a surface-active element, reducing the surface tension of the molten pool. This promotes wetting and spreading, producing a wider, flatter deposit with better fusion to the substrate. The cost is a slight reduction in mechanical properties, which the authors attribute to the formation of oxide inclusions in the deposit.

3. Engineering Practice: What This Means for Pipe Fitting Manufacturing

The most immediate application I see is in the manufacture of large-diameter butt-weld fittings, such as elbows and tees, which are currently produced by forming and welding of plate or by casting. The buy-to-fly ratio for these components is often 3:1 or worse, meaning that a significant amount of material is machined away. WAAM offers the potential to produce near-net-shape components, reducing material waste and machining time.

The double TIG active arc process addresses the main drawback of WAAM: deposition rate. At 2.7 kg/h, the process is competitive with GMAW-based WAAM but offers better control over the deposit geometry and a smoother surface finish. This is particularly important for components that require a good surface finish for subsequent machining or for service in corrosive environments.

I have seen WAAM used to produce 316L stainless steel pipe fittings in the 6-inch to 12-inch size range. The components were deposited layer by layer, then machined to final dimensions. The mechanical properties were comparable to forged fittings, and the microstructure was acceptable for most applications. However, the deposition rate was the bottleneck, with typical rates of 1.2–1.5 kg/h for single-torch TIG. The double TIG active arc process, with its 2.7 kg/h rate, would roughly halve the deposition time for a given component.

4. Practical Lessons and Caveats

The paper presents a well-characterised process, but there are several practical considerations that must be addressed before this can be used in production:

  1. Shielding gas composition control. The oxygen addition must be precisely controlled, as even small variations can significantly affect the deposit geometry and mechanical properties. In production, you need a reliable gas mixing system with continuous monitoring and feedback control.
  2. Torch alignment. The two torches must be precisely aligned, both in terms of their relative position and their angle to the workpiece. Misalignment can cause uneven heat distribution, leading to distortion or lack of fusion between layers.
  3. Interpass temperature control. In multi-layer deposition, the interpass temperature must be controlled to prevent excessive heat buildup, which can cause grain growth and degradation of mechanical properties. This is particularly important for austenitic stainless steel, which is sensitive to sensitisation at elevated temperatures.
  4. Oxygen content in the deposit. The oxygen addition increases the oxygen content of the deposit, which can affect corrosion resistance. For applications requiring high corrosion resistance, such as in the chemical or offshore industries, the oxygen addition may need to be minimised or eliminated.
  5. Post-weld heat treatment. Depending on the application, a post-weld heat treatment may be required to relieve residual stresses and restore mechanical properties. The effect of oxygen on the response to heat treatment should be evaluated.

5. Study Insights and Implications for Modern Practice

The double TIG active arc process represents a significant advancement in WAAM technology. The key insight is that by using two arcs and a surface-active element, you can decouple the deposit width from the deposit height, giving you independent control over the geometry. This is a powerful capability that opens up new possibilities for manufacturing complex components.

For the pipe fitting industry, the implications are clear. WAAM can produce near-net-shape components with mechanical properties comparable to forged or cast components, but with much less material waste. The double TIG active arc process makes WAAM economically viable for a wider range of components by increasing the deposition rate.

The main challenge is process control. The interaction between the two arcs, the oxygen addition, and the deposition parameters creates a complex process window that must be carefully characterised for each material and application. This is not a process that can be set up by trial and error; it requires a systematic approach to process development and validation.

6. Concluding Reflection

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of wire-arc additive manufacturing. The double TIG active arc configuration, with its ability to achieve high deposition rates while maintaining good control over deposit geometry, addresses the key limitation of conventional TIG-based WAAM. The addition of oxygen as a surface-active element is a clever solution to the problem of poor wetting and spreading, although it comes with a slight penalty in mechanical properties. For the pipe and fitting industry, this technology offers a viable route to near-net-shape manufacturing of complex components, with the potential to reduce material waste, machining time, and cost. The path to production requires careful process development and validation, but the potential rewards are substantial.