ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Dissimilar Titanium Alloy TA22/TA2 Thick Plate TIG Welding: Microstructure, Hardness and Mechanical Performance

Overview and Context

This paper by Ma Zhaowei and colleagues from Luoyang Ship Material Research Institute addresses a challenging problem: welding dissimilar titanium alloys in a 20 mm thick plate. The alloys are TA22 (a near-α titanium alloy) and TA2 (commercially pure titanium). The authors used multi-pass, multi-layer TIG welding and then examined the microstructure, hardness distribution, and mechanical properties of the joint.

Dissimilar titanium welding is not for the faint-hearted. Titanium is highly reactive at elevated temperatures, and it requires excellent shielding gas coverage to prevent contamination. The fact that the authors achieved a sound joint with no porosity, lack of fusion, or cracking is a testament to their process control.

Microstructural and Hardness Analysis

The authors examined the microstructure in four regions: the TA22 base metal, the TA22 heat-affected zone (HAZ), the weld metal, and the TA2 HAZ. The findings are summarised below.

Region Microstructure Hardness trend
TA22 base metal Equiaxed α grains Reference
TA22 HAZ Widmanstätten structure (grain boundary α + lamellar α) Increases from base to HAZ
Weld metal (near TA22 fusion line) Coarse lath α Highest in root, lower in fill, slight rise at surface
Weld metal (centre) Blocky α with serrated grain boundaries Lower than root
TA2 HAZ Blocky α, decreasing grain size towards base Slightly lower than base

The Widmanstätten structure in the TA22 HAZ is a classic result of heating a near-α titanium alloy above the β-transus temperature and then cooling at a moderate rate. The grain boundary α and the lamellar α form a basket-weave pattern that is characteristic of this transformation.

The weld metal shows two distinct microstructures depending on the location. Near the TA22 fusion line, the structure is coarse lath α, which is typical of the high-temperature β phase transforming to α on cooling. In the centre of the weld and near the TA2 side, the structure is blocky α with serrated grain boundaries. The serrated boundaries are a result of the α phase nucleating and growing from the β phase during cooling.

The hardness distribution is particularly interesting. The root pass has the highest hardness, which is consistent with the fact that the root pass cools faster and has a finer microstructure. The fill passes have lower hardness because they are subjected to a slower cooling rate and a coarser microstructure. The hardness at the surface increases slightly, which is likely due to the final pass being cooled more rapidly than the fill passes.

Mechanical Performance and Joint Integrity

The tensile test results are excellent. The average tensile strength is 501.5 MPa, and the fracture occurs in the TA2 base metal. This means that the weld is stronger than the weaker of the two base metals, which is the ideal outcome for a dissimilar joint. The side bend test showed no cracks, confirming that the joint has adequate ductility.

Property Result Acceptance criterion
Tensile strength 501.5 MPa Fracture in TA2 base metal
Fracture location TA2 base metal Acceptable
Side bend No cracks No cracks permitted
Visual inspection Bright silver, fish-scale, no defects Acceptable
Low-power inspection No porosity, lack of fusion, cracks Acceptable

The fact that the fracture occurs in the TA2 base metal is a strong indicator that the weld is sound. In dissimilar metal welding, the weakest link is usually the lower-strength base metal, and if the weld is stronger than that, the joint is considered satisfactory.

Practical Lessons and Concluding Remarks

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in welding titanium components for marine or offshore applications. The authors have demonstrated that a 20 mm thick dissimilar titanium joint can be welded with TIG, provided that the process is carefully controlled.

The key lessons are:

  1. Shielding is everything. Titanium must be shielded from the atmosphere not only during welding but also during cooling. The authors achieved a bright silver weld, which is the visual indicator of good shielding. A blue or grey weld would indicate contamination.
  2. Multi-pass welding requires careful interpass control. The hardness distribution shows that the root pass is harder than the fill passes. This is a result of the different cooling rates. If the hardness variation is unacceptable, the welding parameters may need to be adjusted.
  3. Dissimilar joints are not symmetrical. The microstructure on the TA22 side is different from the TA2 side. This means that the joint is not symmetric, and the properties will vary across the weld. This must be taken into account in the design.
  4. The weld is stronger than the weaker base metal. This is the goal of any dissimilar weld. If the fracture occurs in the base metal, the weld is doing its job.

In conclusion, this is a well-executed study that demonstrates the feasibility of welding thick dissimilar titanium plates with TIG. The microstructural and mechanical data provide a solid basis for developing a welding procedure specification (WPS) for this type of joint. For anyone working with titanium in a shipyard or offshore environment, this paper is a must-read.