Numerical Analysis of External Longitudinal Magnetic Field Effects on TIG Arc Characteristics
Modeling Approach and Key Findings
This paper by Huang Yong and colleagues from Lanzhou University of Technology presents a three-dimensional steady-state mathematical model of a TIG arc under an external longitudinal magnetic field. The authors use the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations and solve them with the FLUENT software to obtain the temperature field and flow field of the arc for different magnetic induction intensities.
The key finding is that the external longitudinal magnetic field significantly changes the arc shape and the heat distribution on the anode. The arc becomes a "hollow bell" shape, with the plasma temperature near the cathode slightly increasing and the temperature in the arc center decreasing. On the anode surface, the arc pressure and heat flux are distributed in a double-peak pattern, with the peak values reduced and the heated area enlarged.
| Magnetic Induction (T) | Arc Shape | Anode Pressure Distribution | Anode Heat Flux Distribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (no field) | Normal bell | Single peak, high value | Single peak, high value |
| 0.1 | Slightly hollow | Double peak, lower value | Double peak, lower value |
| 0.2 | Hollow bell | Double peak, further reduced | Double peak, further reduced |
| 0.3 | More pronounced hollow | Double peak, significantly reduced | Double peak, significantly reduced |
The physical mechanism is the Lorentz force. The external magnetic field interacts with the arc current to create a force that causes the plasma to rotate around the arc axis. This rotation creates a centrifugal force that pushes the plasma outward, resulting in the hollow bell shape. The rotation also increases the arc's effective area, which reduces the peak pressure and heat flux on the anode.
Arc Shape and Heat Distribution Implications
The hollow bell shape has important implications for welding. The reduced peak heat flux means that the anode is heated more uniformly, which can reduce the risk of burn-through and improve the weld bead shape. The double-peak distribution suggests that the heat is concentrated in two annular regions, which may result in a wider weld bead with a shallower penetration.
In my experience, this is particularly relevant for welding thin materials, where the high peak heat flux of a normal TIG arc can cause burn-through. By applying a magnetic field, the heat is spread over a larger area, and the weld can be made with a lower risk of defects. This technique could be used to control the weld bead shape and to improve the weld quality in applications where the heat input must be carefully controlled.
The authors also note that the arc voltage increases with the magnetic field, which is consistent with the arc being stretched and the plasma being accelerated. This means that the welding power supply must be able to provide a higher voltage when a magnetic field is applied. In practice, this is not a problem, as most TIG power supplies have a wide voltage range.
Practical Applications and Future Outlook
The application of an external magnetic field to TIG welding is not new, but the numerical analysis provides a deeper understanding of the physical processes. On the shop floor, this technique could be used to control the weld bead shape in specific applications, such as root passes in pipe welding or welding of thin-walled components.
One practical challenge is the design of the magnetic coil. The coil must be placed around the torch or the workpiece, and it must be able to generate a uniform magnetic field over the arc region. The coil must be water-cooled to handle the heat generated by the current, and it must be positioned to avoid interference with the welding torch.
Another consideration is the effect on the weld pool. The magnetic field can cause the molten metal to rotate, which may improve the mixing of the weld pool and reduce the risk of porosity. However, it can also cause the weld pool to become unstable, leading to spatter or undercut. The optimal magnetic field strength must be determined experimentally for each application.
In summary, this paper provides a valuable numerical analysis of the effect of an external longitudinal magnetic field on the TIG arc. The results show that the magnetic field can be used to control the arc shape and the heat distribution, which has practical implications for welding thin materials and for controlling the weld bead shape. The technique is not yet widely used in production, but it has the potential to improve weld quality in specific applications. The key to success is the careful design of the magnetic coil and the experimental optimization of the magnetic field strength.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd