1Cr17 Stainless Steel Surface TIG Cold Welding Remelting and Wire Deposition Processes and Modified Layer Microstructure and Properties
Literature Overview and Core Problem
1Cr17 is a ferritic stainless steel with approximately 17% chromium. It is used in applications where corrosion resistance is required but the material does not need the full austenitic structure of a 304 or 316 stainless. The problem with 1Cr17 is that it is prone to grain growth in the heat-affected zone when welded, and the coarse grains lead to reduced toughness and reduced corrosion resistance. The material also has a high thermal conductivity, which means the heat from welding spreads quickly and the HAZ can be wide.
The paper by Zheng Shaoxian and colleagues from Lanzhou Jiaotong University addresses this problem by using a technique called TIG cold welding. This is not a conventional welding process; it is a surface modification technique that uses a very short duration, high current pulse to melt a small area of the surface, which then rapidly solidifies. The "cold" in the name refers to the fact that the bulk of the material remains at a low temperature because the heat input is concentrated and the cooling rate is extremely fast.
The authors compared two variants of this process: remelting (no filler wire added) and wire deposition (ER347L stainless steel filler wire added). The goal is to produce a surface layer with a fine microstructure and improved corrosion resistance, without the grain coarsening that would occur with conventional TIG welding.
Technical Points and Experimental Findings
The authors first established the process window for obtaining a well-formed remelted layer or deposited layer. They varied the cold welding time (the duration of the current pulse) and the cold welding current (the amplitude of the pulse), and recorded the minimum current required to achieve a good surface appearance.
| Process | Cold Welding Time (ms) | Minimum Cold Welding Current (A) |
|---|---|---|
| Remelting | 200 - 150 | 40 |
| Remelting | 150 - 100 | 70 |
| Remelting | 100 - 50 | 100 |
| Deposition | 50 | 230 |
| Deposition | 100 | 190 |
| Deposition | 160 | 150 |
| Deposition | 200 | 120 |
The trend is clear: for remelting, a shorter pulse time requires a higher current to achieve the same melting effect. For deposition, the same relationship holds, but the current levels are much higher because the filler wire must be melted in addition to the base metal.
The microstructural analysis shows that both the remelted layer and the deposited layer have a finer grain size than the base metal. The HAZ is narrow, with a width of less than 250 μm, and the grains in the HAZ are not significantly coarsened compared to the base metal. This is a remarkable result, because conventional TIG welding of ferritic stainless steel typically produces a HAZ with significant grain growth.
The hardness testing shows that both the remelted and deposited layers are harder than the base metal. This is attributed to the fine grain size and, in the case of the deposited layer, the presence of the ER347L filler metal, which contains niobium for stabilisation and may form fine precipitates.
The corrosion testing in 3.5% NaCl solution shows that both the remelted and deposited layers have better corrosion resistance than the base metal. This is likely due to the finer grain size, which reduces the tendency for localised corrosion at grain boundaries, and the more uniform composition of the modified layer.
Practical Implications for the Shop Floor
This paper has significant implications for the repair and surface modification of ferritic stainless steel components. In my experience, ferritic stainless steel is used in heat exchangers, furnace components and chemical processing equipment, and the main failure mode is often surface corrosion or erosion. The ability to produce a fine-grained, corrosion-resistant surface layer without damaging the underlying material is valuable.
The key practical points are:
- The process window is narrow. The relationship between pulse time and current is critical, and operating outside the window produces either an incomplete melted layer or an excessively rough surface.
- The HAZ is narrow, which is a major advantage. For a component that is already at its dimensional limit, a narrow HAZ means less distortion and less risk of damaging the base material.
- The process is best suited for surface repair and modification, not for structural welding. The deposited layer thickness is limited, and the process is not designed for joining two components together.
- The ER347L filler is a good choice for this application. It is a stabilised stainless steel that resists sensitisation, and it produces a deposit with good corrosion resistance.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that the paper does not address is the effect of the process on the fatigue properties of the component. The surface layer has a different microstructure and hardness than the base metal, which creates a residual stress field. This could be beneficial (compressive residual stress improves fatigue life) or detrimental (tensile residual stress reduces fatigue life). The authors do not measure residual stress, so this remains an open question.
Another question is the repeatability of the process. The cold welding technique relies on precise control of the pulse time and current. In a production environment, the power source must be capable of delivering consistent pulses, and the torch position must be accurately controlled. Any variation in arc length or travel speed will affect the result.
The paper also does not discuss the effect of the process on the surface finish. The remelted layer will have a rippled surface, and the deposited layer will have a bead-like appearance. If the component requires a smooth surface, a subsequent machining or grinding operation will be necessary, which may remove part of the modified layer.
Study Insights and Practical Recommendations
This paper is a good example of how process parameters can be optimised to achieve a specific microstructural outcome. The authors did not just try a single set of parameters; they systematically varied the pulse time and current to establish the process window, and then characterised the resulting layers.
For a production engineer, I would offer the following advice:
- This process is best suited for surface repair of ferritic stainless steel components, where the goal is to restore corrosion resistance or build up a worn surface.
- The process window must be established for each material and thickness. Do not assume that the parameters given in the paper will work for a different component.
- The surface preparation is critical. The surface must be clean and free of oxides before cold welding, otherwise the layer will not bond properly.
- After cold welding, inspect the layer for cracks and porosity. The rapid solidification can trap gas, so a careful visual inspection and possibly a dye penetrant test are recommended.
- Consider the effect on the component dimensions. The deposited layer adds material, which may require subsequent machining to achieve the final dimensions.
Concluding Summary
This study demonstrates that TIG cold welding is an effective technique for producing a fine-grained, corrosion-resistant surface layer on 1Cr17 ferritic stainless steel. The process window is narrow, with the minimum current required for a good layer increasing as the pulse time decreases. Both remelting and wire deposition produce a layer with finer grains than the base metal, a narrow HAZ of less than 250 μm, and improved hardness and corrosion resistance. The ER347L filler wire is a suitable choice for deposition, providing a stabilised deposit with good corrosion properties. The practical value of this technique lies in surface repair and modification of ferritic stainless steel components, where the narrow HAZ and fine grain size offer significant advantages over conventional welding. However, the process requires precise control of pulse parameters, and the effect on fatigue properties and residual stress remains to be investigated.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd