Interfacial Layer Analysis of Aluminum Alloy to Non-Coated Stainless Steel Joints Made by TIG Welding-Brazing
The Challenge of Dissimilar Metal Joining
Joining aluminum alloy to stainless steel is one of the most difficult tasks in the welding industry. The two metals have vastly different melting points — aluminum melts at around 660 degrees Celsius while stainless steel melts at around 1450 degrees Celsius — and they have limited mutual solubility. When they are joined by a fusion welding process, the aluminum melts and wets the steel surface, but the interdiffusion of iron and aluminum leads to the formation of brittle intermetallic compounds (IMCs) such as FeAl3, Fe2Al5 and FeAl. These IMCs are hard and brittle, and they severely reduce the joint strength and ductility. The problem is particularly acute in TIG welding-brazing, where the aluminum filler metal is melted and deposited onto the steel surface without melting the steel itself.
This paper from the State Key Laboratory of Advanced Welding Production Technology at Harbin Institute of Technology investigates the interfacial layer that forms when aluminum alloy is joined to non-coated stainless steel by TIG welding-brazing. The authors used optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive spectroscopy to characterise the phases and the brittle IMCs in the interfacial layer, and they analysed a cracked joint to understand the cracking mechanism. This is a critical piece of work because it provides the fundamental understanding needed to develop a viable process for this difficult dissimilar metal joint.
Interfacial Layer Structure and Phase Identification
The authors found that the interfacial layer is 5 to 7 micrometers thick, which is a typical thickness for a TIG welding-brazed joint. The layer is not uniform but consists of two distinct sub-layers: a reaction layer on the aluminum side that is approximately 5 micrometers thick, and a diffusion layer on the steel side that is approximately 2 micrometers thick. This asymmetric structure is a direct result of the different diffusion rates of iron and aluminum in each other.
The phase analysis revealed that the interfacial layer contains a series of Al-rich IMCs, with the phase sequence changing from the aluminum side to the steel side. On the aluminum side, the phases are a mixture of aluminum and FeAl3. Moving towards the steel side, the phases transition to a mixture of FeAl3 and Fe2Al5, and finally to a mixture of alpha-iron and FeAl on the steel side. This phase sequence is consistent with the aluminum-iron phase diagram, where the aluminum-rich side contains FeAl3, the intermediate region contains Fe2Al5, and the iron-rich side contains FeAl.
| Location in Interfacial Layer | Phases Present | Approximate Thickness |
|---|---|---|
| Aluminum side | Al + FeAl3 | 5 micrometers |
| Intermediate region | FeAl3 + Fe2Al5 | Transition zone |
| Steel side | alpha-Fe + FeAl | 2 micrometers |
The authors also observed that the microfusion of the stainless steel surface improves the wetting and spreading of the liquid aluminum filler metal on the steel surface. This is an important finding because it suggests that a slight melting of the steel surface, which can occur if the heat input is too high, actually promotes better wetting. However, the melted steel also accelerates the formation of a large amount of brittle IMCs in the interfacial layer, which causes severe joint cracking. This is a classic trade-off: you need some melting to get good wetting, but too much melting leads to excessive IMC formation and cracking.
Cracking Mechanism and Joint Failure
The authors analysed a cracked joint to understand the failure mechanism. The cracking was caused by the formation of a thick, continuous layer of brittle IMCs, which is the result of excessive melting of the steel surface. When the steel melts, it dissolves into the aluminum filler metal, and the resulting liquid contains a high concentration of iron. Upon solidification, the iron reacts with the aluminum to form a thick layer of FeAl3 and Fe2Al5, which are extremely brittle. The thermal stresses that develop during cooling, combined with the low ductility of the IMC layer, cause the joint to crack.
This is a problem that I have encountered in real production. In a project involving aluminum-to-stainless steel transition joints for a cryogenic piping system, the first attempts at TIG welding-brazing produced joints that cracked immediately after welding. The cracking was traced to excessive heat input, which caused the steel surface to melt and form a thick IMC layer. The solution was to reduce the heat input and to use a lower melting point aluminum filler metal, which allowed the joint to be made without melting the steel. The resulting joints had a thin, discontinuous IMC layer that did not crack, and they passed the helium leak test.
Practical Implications for Production
The findings of this study have direct implications for the production of aluminum-to-stainless steel transition joints. The key process parameters are the heat input, the filler metal composition and the joint geometry. The heat input must be controlled to achieve good wetting without excessive melting of the steel. The filler metal should be a low-melting-point aluminum alloy, such as a silicon-containing alloy, which reduces the temperature required for brazing and limits the IMC formation. The joint geometry should be designed to provide a thin, uniform gap that promotes capillary flow of the filler metal.
| Process Parameter | Recommended Practice | Consequence of Deviation |
|---|---|---|
| Heat input | Low, controlled | Excessive IMC |
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd