ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

All-Position TIG Helium Arc Internal Welding of Small-Diameter Pipes

Literature Overview and Technical Context

The paper by Fei Dakui et al. from Harbin Welding Research Institute addresses a challenging problem: the all-position TIG welding of small-diameter pipes with a wall thickness of 4 mm. The authors used a helium arc internal welding process with a single-V groove and single-sided welding with double-sided formation. Through a series of experiments, they optimized the peak current, base current, welding speed, and arc voltage to solve the problems of weld collapse in the overhead position and lack of penetration in the downhill welding position.

The optimal process is divided into four zones. The welding speed is 75 mm/min, the peak current is 114 to 130 A, the base current is 58 to 62 A, the wire feed speed is 0.45 to 0.6 m/min, and the arc voltage is 13.4 to 14.0 V. The authors conclude that for all-position TIG welding of pipes where external welding is not possible and the torch cannot be oscillated, helium arc internal welding is an ideal choice.

This is a practical paper that addresses a real problem in the pipe welding industry. Small-diameter pipes are notoriously difficult to weld in the all-position mode. The overhead position is particularly challenging because gravity causes the weld pool to sag, leading to weld collapse. The downhill position is also challenging because the weld pool tends to run ahead of the arc, leading to lack of penetration.

Interpretation of Technical Points and Process Analysis

The use of helium as the shielding gas is a key factor in this process. Helium has a higher ionization potential than argon, which means that it requires a higher voltage to maintain the arc. This higher voltage results in a hotter arc and a deeper penetration. Helium also has a higher thermal conductivity, which means that the heat is transferred more efficiently to the workpiece.

The internal welding approach is interesting because it allows the weld to be made from the inside of the pipe. This is advantageous in situations where the outside of the pipe is not accessible, such as in a confined space or where the pipe is already installed. The internal weld also has a different thermal profile than an external weld, which can affect the weld pool behavior.

The optimization of the welding parameters is critical. The authors found that the peak current, base current, welding speed, and arc voltage all have a significant effect on the weld quality. The four-zone approach suggests that the welding parameters must be adjusted as the torch moves around the pipe. In the flat position, a different set of parameters is required than in the overhead position.

The following table summarizes the optimal parameters.

Parameter Optimal Range
Welding Speed 75 mm/min
Peak Current 114 to 130 A
Base Current 58 to 62 A
Wire Feed Speed 0.45 to 0.6 m/min
Arc Voltage 13.4 to 14.0 V

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

The all-position welding of small-diameter pipes is a common requirement in the power generation and chemical industries. In these applications, the pipes are often welded in place, and the welder does not have access to the outside of the pipe. The internal welding approach described in this paper is a practical solution to this problem.

I recall a project where we were welding 4 mm thick stainless steel pipes for a chemical plant. The pipes were installed in a confined space, and the welder could only access the inside of the pipe. We used a TIG internal welding process with argon as the shielding gas. The welds in the overhead position showed a tendency to collapse, and the welds in the downhill position showed a tendency to lack penetration. We struggled with this problem for several days before we switched to a helium arc internal welding process.

The helium arc provided a hotter and more stable arc, which allowed us to achieve a consistent weld profile in all positions. The key was to adjust the welding parameters as the torch moved around the pipe. In the overhead position, we reduced the peak current to prevent the weld pool from sagging. In the downhill position, we increased the welding speed to prevent the weld pool from running ahead of the arc.

The lesson is that all-position welding requires a different set of parameters for each position. A single set of parameters will not work for all positions. The welder must be trained to adjust the parameters based on the position of the torch.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises an important question: what is the optimal shielding gas for all-position TIG welding of small-diameter pipes? The authors used helium, which provides a hotter arc and deeper penetration. However, helium is more expensive than argon, and it requires a higher arc voltage. In some applications, a mixture of helium and argon may be a better choice.

In my experience, a helium-argon mixture provides a good balance between cost and performance. The helium provides the hot arc, while the argon provides a stable arc and reduces the cost. The optimal mixture depends on the material, the wall thickness, and the welding position.

Another important consideration is the effect of the welding position on the weld pool behavior. In the overhead position, gravity causes the weld pool to sag. This can be counteracted by reducing the heat input and using a lower welding current. In the downhill position, the weld pool tends to run ahead of the arc. This can be counteracted by increasing the welding speed and using a lower welding current.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

The paper by Fei Dakui et al. is a valuable contribution to the pipe welding literature. It provides a practical solution to a difficult problem: the all-position welding of small-diameter pipes. The helium arc internal welding process is a viable alternative to conventional TIG welding, and it offers several advantages.

For the shop floor, I recommend the following practical measures. First, use a helium arc internal welding process for small-diameter pipes where external welding is not possible. Second, use a four-zone approach to adjust the welding parameters based on the position of the torch. Third, ensure that the welder is trained to recognize the signs of weld collapse and lack of penetration. Fourth, perform a weld procedure qualification that includes all positions.

In conclusion, the helium arc internal welding process is an ideal choice for all-position TIG welding of small-diameter pipes. The process provides a stable arc and deep penetration, and it can be optimized to solve the problems of weld collapse and lack of penetration. The study by Fei Dakui et al. provides a solid foundation for the implementation of this process in production.