TIG Welding Low-Current Contact Arc Striking Control Circuit: Design and Application
Literature Overview and Study Context
This paper by Chenfu Fang, Fangming Zhou, Jun Qiu, and Tingbin Wu from East China Shipbuilding Institute, published in Power Electronics (1999, Vol. 33, Issue 2, pages 23-25), addresses a problem that is familiar to every TIG welder who has ever worked on thin-wall tubing or precision components: how to strike an arc reliably at low current without damaging the tungsten electrode or the workpiece. The authors analyse the physics of contact arc striking, identify the key electrical parameters that govern success, and present a control circuit that is simple, reliable, and practical. This is a fundamental paper in the field of TIG welding power supply design, and its relevance extends far beyond the 1999 context. In modern TIG welding, high-frequency (HF) arc starting is the most common method, but HF can interfere with electronic control systems, cause electrical noise, and is not suitable for all applications. Contact arc striking, where the tungsten electrode is brought into contact with the workpiece and then withdrawn, is an alternative that avoids HF interference, but it requires precise control of the short-circuit current and the arc initiation voltage. This paper provides the theoretical basis and the practical circuit design for achieving reliable contact arc striking at low currents.
Key Technical Points and Circuit Design Analysis
The authors analyse the contact arc striking process by breaking it down into three phases: (1) the initial contact between the tungsten and the workpiece, which creates a short circuit; (2) the withdrawal of the tungsten, which stretches the molten metal bridge and creates a high electric field; and (3) the establishment of the arc, which requires a sufficient electric field to ionise the gas and sustain the discharge. The critical parameters are the instantaneous short-circuit current, the steady-state short-circuit current, the arc current and its rate of change, and the electric field strength between the tungsten and the workpiece and its rate of change.
| Parameter | Influence on Arc Striking |
|---|---|
| Instantaneous short-circuit current | Must be high enough to melt the tungsten-workpiece contact point and form a molten metal bridge |
| Steady-state short-circuit current | Must be limited to prevent excessive tungsten erosion and workpiece damage |
| Arc current and its rate of change | Must be controlled to ensure smooth transition from short circuit to arc |
| Electric field strength | Must be high enough to ionise the shielding gas and initiate the arc |
| Rate of change of electric field | Must be fast enough to ensure arc establishment before the tungsten cools |
The authors present a control circuit that regulates the short-circuit current to a precise value, controls the rate of current rise during arc establishment, and provides a high-voltage pulse to assist arc initiation. The circuit is designed to be simple, using standard components, and is claimed to be reliable in practice. The key innovation is the precise control of the current waveform during the contact and withdrawal phases, which ensures that the arc is established with minimal tungsten loss and without spatter or workpiece damage.
Practical Application and Shop Floor Experience
In my experience, contact arc striking is the preferred method for welding thin-wall stainless steel tubing, particularly in the pharmaceutical, food processing, and semiconductor industries, where HF interference can damage sensitive electronic equipment and where the weld quality requirements are extremely high. The problem with conventional contact arc striking is that the tungsten electrode tends to stick to the workpiece, or the arc is established at a high current, causing a burn-through on thin-wall material. This paper's control circuit solves both problems by limiting the short-circuit current and by controlling the rate of current rise.
I have also seen the consequences of poor arc striking in the field. On a project involving the welding of small-diameter heat exchanger tubes, the welders were using a TIG power supply with a simple contact arc striking circuit that did not have the current control described in this paper. The result was frequent tungsten contamination, burn-through on the tube walls, and a high rejection rate. The welders resorted to using a higher arc current to compensate for the unreliable arc starting, which made the burn-through problem worse. The solution was to retrofit the power supplies with a control circuit similar to the one described in this paper, which allowed the welders to use the correct low current for the tube wall thickness and to strike the arc reliably without tungsten contamination.
Common Defects and Countermeasures in Contact Arc Striking
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Tungsten contamination | Excessive short-circuit current, tungsten sticking to workpiece | Limit short-circuit current, use a control circuit that regulates the current during contact |
| Burn-through on thin wall | Arc established at high current, excessive heat input | Control the rate of current rise, use a low arc current for thin-wall material |
| Arc failure to start | Insufficient electric field, tungsten cooled before arc establishment | Provide a high-voltage pulse to assist arc initiation, ensure rapid tungsten withdrawal |
| Spatter and weld contamination | Unstable arc, excessive current during arc establishment | Control the current waveform, ensure a smooth transition from short circuit to arc |
| Tungsten electrode erosion | Repeated high-current arc strikes, poor current control | Use a control circuit that limits the arc current during establishment, use a larger tungsten diameter |
Study Insights and Recommendations
This paper is a classic example of practical engineering research: it identifies a problem, analyses the physics, designs a solution, and validates it in practice. The control circuit described is simple, reliable, and effective, and it addresses a real need in the TIG welding industry. For the practising engineer, the key takeaway is that arc starting is not a trivial matter; it is a process that requires precise control of electrical parameters to achieve consistent results. The paper's analysis of the short-circuit current, the rate of current change, and the electric field strength provides a theoretical framework that can be used to design or select TIG power supplies for specific applications. In my view, every welding engineer who works with thin-wall material or with HF-sensitive equipment should be familiar with the principles of contact arc striking and with the control circuits that make it reliable. The paper is also a reminder that simple, well-designed solutions are often more effective than complex ones, and that a control circuit that is "simple and reliable" is worth more than a sophisticated one that is difficult to maintain. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in the design or selection of TIG welding power supplies, and I would encourage them to apply the principles of controlled short-circuit current and controlled current rise to their own welding processes.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd