ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Mechanical Properties and Microstructure of T91/12CrMoV Steel Pipe TIG Welded Joints

Introduction and Literature Overview

The paper by Feisen Wang, Shenliu Wen, and Ling Chen from the Department of Mechanical Engineering at Sichuan Chemical Vocational and Technical College presents a comparative study of T91/12CrMoV steel pipe TIG welded joints using two different filler wires. The research addresses a critical issue in the welding of dissimilar steel joints for high-temperature service applications, specifically in power plant piping systems where T91 (modified 9Cr-1Mo) steel is welded to 12CrMoV steel.

The T91 steel is a high-strength, creep-resistant steel used in supercritical and ultra-supercritical power plant applications, while 12CrMoV is a lower-grade creep-resistant steel used in conventional power plant piping. The dissimilar joint between these two steels presents significant welding challenges due to the differences in their chemical composition, mechanical properties, and high-temperature behavior. The choice of filler wire is critical to the performance of the joint, as the filler metal must be compatible with both base materials and provide adequate mechanical properties and creep resistance.

Core Technical Findings and Data Analysis

Filler Wire Comparison

The study compares two filler wires: TGS-9Cb and TIG-R31. The TGS-9Cb wire is a 9Cr-1Mo type filler metal designed for welding T91 steel, while the TIG-R31 wire is a 1.25Cr-0.5Mo type filler metal designed for welding 12CrMoV steel. The selection of filler wire for a dissimilar joint involves a compromise between the properties of the two base materials:

Filler Wire Type Chemical Composition Application
TGS-9Cb 9Cr-1Mo High Cr, Mo content Designed for T91 steel
TIG-R31 1.25Cr-0.5Mo Lower Cr, Mo content Designed for 12CrMoV steel

Mechanical Properties

The mechanical testing results show that both filler wires produce joints that meet the specification requirements for tensile strength and bending strength. However, there are significant differences in the microstructure and resulting properties:

Property TGS-9Cb Joint TIG-R31 Joint Specification Requirement
Tensile Strength Meets requirement Meets requirement Per applicable standard
Bending Strength Meets requirement Meets requirement Per applicable standard
Microstructure Carbide aggregation, brittle phases Fine, uniform microstructure No brittle phases

The key finding is that the TGS-9Cb filler wire produces a joint with carbide aggregation and the presence of brittle phases, while the TIG-R31 filler wire produces a joint with a finer and more uniform microstructure. The TIG-R31 wire is therefore considered to provide superior joint performance.

Microstructural Analysis

The microstructural examination reveals that the TGS-9Cb joint contains carbide aggregation and brittle phases, which are detrimental to the mechanical properties and service performance of the joint. The TIG-R31 joint exhibits a fine, uniform microstructure without these detrimental features. The difference in microstructure is attributed to the different chemical compositions of the filler wires and their interaction with the base materials during welding.

Engineering Practice Interpretation and Lessons Learned

The Challenge of Dissimilar Steel Welding

From my extensive experience in the power plant piping industry, dissimilar steel welding is one of the most challenging and failure-prone operations in the fabrication of high-temperature piping systems. The differences in thermal expansion coefficients, creep properties, and metallurgical behavior between T91 and 12CrMoV steels create a complex situation where the joint must accommodate significant differences in material behavior at elevated temperatures.

The Importance of Filler Wire Selection

The choice of filler wire for dissimilar steel joints is critical to the long-term performance of the joint. The filler wire must provide adequate mechanical properties at both room temperature and elevated temperatures, be compatible with both base materials, and exhibit appropriate creep resistance. The findings of this study indicate that the TIG-R31 filler wire provides superior joint quality compared to TGS-9Cb for the T91/12CrMoV dissimilar joint.

Practical Considerations for Power Plant Piping

In power plant piping applications, the joint must withstand high-temperature, high-pressure service conditions for extended periods. The presence of carbide aggregation and brittle phases in the TGS-9Cb joint would be a cause for concern, as these features can lead to premature failure through cracking or reduced creep resistance. The TIG-R31 filler wire, with its finer and more uniform microstructure, provides a more reliable joint for this demanding application.

Lessons from the Field

In my experience, dissimilar steel joints in power plant piping have been a source of recurring problems, including premature failure through creep cracking, hydrogen-induced cracking, and thermal fatigue. The selection of the appropriate filler wire is one of the most important decisions in the welding procedure qualification process. This study provides valuable data that can inform that decision.

Key Questions and Reflections

This study raises several important questions about the welding of T91/12CrMoV dissimilar joints. The study does not address the high-temperature creep properties of the joints, which are critical for power plant service. Additionally, the long-term microstructural stability of the joints at elevated temperatures is not evaluated. These are important gaps that must be addressed through additional testing before the welding procedure can be confidently qualified for service.

The study also does not address the effect of post-weld heat treatment on the joint properties. In power plant piping applications, post-weld heat treatment is typically required to relieve residual stresses and temper the martensitic structure of the T91 steel. The interaction between the post-weld heat treatment and the filler wire selection must be evaluated to ensure optimal joint performance.

Study Insights and Implications

The key insight from this study is that the selection of filler wire for dissimilar steel joints is not simply a matter of matching the chemical composition to one of the base materials. The filler wire must be compatible with both base materials and provide the desired combination of mechanical properties, microstructural stability, and service performance. The TIG-R31 filler wire demonstrates superior performance for the T91/12CrMoV joint, providing a fine, uniform microstructure without the detrimental carbide aggregation and brittle phases observed with the TGS-9Cb wire.

For our industry, this study highlights the importance of thorough welding procedure qualification for dissimilar steel joints. The selection of filler wire must be based on a comprehensive evaluation of the joint properties, including not only room-temperature mechanical properties but also high-temperature creep resistance, microstructural stability, and long-term service performance.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper provides valuable data on the comparative performance of two filler wires for T91/12CrMoV dissimilar steel joints. The findings have direct implications for the welding procedure qualification in power plant piping applications. However, the study would benefit from additional testing that includes high-temperature creep properties, long-term microstructural stability, and the effect of post-weld heat treatment.

Future work should focus on evaluating the long-term performance of the TIG-R31 filler wire joints under simulated service conditions, including high-temperature exposure and cyclic loading. The continued development of filler wires for dissimilar steel welding will be essential for ensuring the reliability of power plant piping systems.