ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

TIG Brazing-Welding of AZ61 Magnesium Alloy to DP590 Galvanized Steel

Literature Overview and Core Significance

This paper by Jiang Li and Liu Hui, published in Hot Working Technology in 2018, investigates the TIG brazing-welding process for joining AZ61 magnesium alloy to DP590 galvanized steel. This is a dissimilar metal joint with significant industrial relevance, particularly in the automotive industry, where the combination of lightweight magnesium alloys with high-strength steel offers potential for weight reduction while maintaining structural integrity. The challenge is that magnesium and steel have vastly different melting points (650°C for magnesium vs. 1500°C for steel) and are metallurgically incompatible, forming no solid solutions or intermetallic compounds that would enable a conventional fusion weld. The authors use AZ31 magnesium alloy wire as filler material and employ TIG brazing-welding, which combines a fusion weld on the magnesium side with a brazed joint on the steel side. The paper systematically investigates the effect of welding current on joint microstructure and mechanical properties, identifying the optimal current for maximum shear strength.

Technical Points and Process Interpretation

The Brazing-Welding Mechanism

The TIG brazing-welding process exploits the difference in melting points between the two base metals. The welding arc is directed primarily at the magnesium alloy, which melts and forms a fusion weld pool. The molten magnesium then flows onto the surface of the galvanized steel, where it reacts with the zinc coating to form a brazed joint. The zinc coating, with a melting point of approximately 420°C, melts at the interface and promotes wetting of the steel surface by the molten magnesium. This creates a metallurgical bond between the magnesium weld metal and the steel substrate, with the zinc serving as a braze filler metal. The resulting joint has a fusion-welded section on the magnesium side and a brazed section on the steel side, hence the term "brazing-welding." This approach avoids the formation of brittle Fe-Mg intermetallic compounds that would occur if the steel were melted, as the steel remains solid throughout the process.

Effect of Welding Current on Joint Quality

Welding Current (A) Joint Appearance Brazed Interface Shear Strength (MPa) Failure Mode
60 Incomplete wetting; visible gaps Discontinuous reaction layer 120–150 Interfacial failure at brazed region
70 Better wetting; some porosity Partially continuous layer 180–210 Mixed failure (brazed and fusion regions)
80 Good wetting; uniform bead Continuous, uniform reaction layer 243 Failure in fusion weld region (ductile)
90 Excessive heat; burn-through on magnesium Over-thick reaction layer; spalling 180–200 Interfacial failure with brittle characteristics
100 Severe burn-through; weld collapse Degraded interface <150 Interfacial failure; severe distortion

The results clearly show that welding current has a critical effect on joint quality. At low currents (60 A), the heat input is insufficient to fully melt the magnesium and promote adequate wetting of the steel surface. The brazed interface has numerous unfilled voids and gaps, resulting in low shear strength and interfacial failure. As current increases to 80 A, the heat input is sufficient to create a uniform, continuous reaction layer at the magnesium-steel interface, and the joint achieves its maximum shear strength of 243 MPa. At this current, failure occurs in the fusion weld region of the magnesium, indicating that the brazed interface is stronger than the magnesium weld metal itself. The fracture surface shows typical ductile dimples, confirming that the joint is not limited by the brazed interface. At higher currents (90 A and above), excessive heat input causes burn-through of the thin magnesium sheet and degradation of the zinc coating, leading to brittle interfacial failure and reduced strength.

Microstructural Analysis and Reaction Layer Formation

Current (A) Reaction Layer Thickness (μm) Intermetallic Phases Layer Uniformity
60 2–5 Mg-Zn phases (MgZn2, Mg2Zn11) Discontinuous, with voids
70 5–8 Mg-Zn phases with some Al-Zn Partially continuous
80 8–12 Mg-Zn phases, uniform distribution Continuous and uniform
90 15–20 Mg-Zn with Fe-Al phases Over-thick, with spalling
100 >20 Fe-Al phases dominant Degraded, non-uniform

The microstructural analysis reveals that the reaction layer at the magnesium-steel interface consists primarily of Mg-Zn intermetallic compounds formed by the reaction between the molten magnesium and the zinc coating. At the optimal current of 80 A, the reaction layer is uniform and continuous, providing good metallurgical bonding. The thickness of 8–12 μm is sufficient to ensure adhesion without being so thick as to cause brittleness. At higher currents, the reaction layer becomes excessively thick and begins to incorporate Fe-Al phases from the steel substrate, which are brittle and lead to interfacial failure. This explains why the shear strength decreases at currents above 80 A despite the apparent increase in bonding area.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

The brazing-welding process described in this paper is a practical solution for joining magnesium to steel, but it requires careful process control to achieve consistent results. In production, the welding current must be precisely controlled to maintain the heat input within the narrow window that produces a uniform reaction layer without burn-through. This is particularly challenging for thin magnesium sheets, which have a low melting point and high thermal conductivity, making them susceptible to burn-through at even slight current variations. The use of a pulsed TIG current or a current ramp-up/ramp-down profile can help mitigate this issue by allowing the operator to establish the molten pool gradually before the arc moves along the joint. The paper also highlights the importance of the zinc coating on the steel side, as it serves as the braze filler metal. This means that the galvanized coating must be present and of adequate thickness at the joint area. If the coating is damaged or removed during handling, the brazing mechanism will not work, and the joint will fail. Fabricators should ensure that the galvanized steel is handled carefully and that the joint area is not subjected to excessive cleaning or grinding that would remove the zinc coating.

Study Insights and Implications

The paper provides valuable data on the effect of welding current on joint quality, but it does not address the effect of other important process parameters such as travel speed, filler wire feed rate, or shielding gas composition. In practice, these parameters must be optimized in conjunction with welding current to achieve the best results. The paper also does not investigate the effect of joint geometry, such as the gap between the magnesium and steel components, which can significantly affect the flow of molten magnesium onto the steel surface. For production applications, fabricators should conduct their own process qualification trials to establish the full parameter window and ensure that the process is robust to normal production variations. The maximum shear strength of 243 MPa reported in this paper is respectable for a dissimilar metal joint, but it is important to note that this is a shear strength, not a tensile strength. For structural applications, the joint may be subjected to tensile, peel, or fatigue loads, which may behave differently. Additional testing is needed to fully characterize the joint performance under service conditions.

Conclusion and Outlook

This paper demonstrates that TIG brazing-welding is a viable process for joining AZ61 magnesium alloy to DP590 galvanized steel, with the optimal welding current of 80 A producing a joint with 243 MPa shear strength and ductile failure in the magnesium weld region. The process relies on the zinc coating on the steel to promote wetting and form a continuous reaction layer at the interface. The key to success is controlling the heat input to ensure that the reaction layer is uniform and continuous without excessive thickness or burn-through of the magnesium. For production application, the process requires precise control of welding parameters and careful handling of the galvanized steel to preserve the zinc coating. Future work should investigate the effect of other process parameters, joint geometries, and service conditions to fully validate the process for automotive and other structural applications. The paper is a valuable reference for engineers working on dissimilar metal joining, as it provides a clear understanding of the brazing-welding mechanism and the critical role of welding current in determining joint quality.