Metallurgical and Mechanical Behaviour of the Fusion Zone in Hypereutectic ZA Alloy TIG Welds
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper by Liu Xiuzhong and colleagues, published in the Journal of Welding in 2001, addresses a question that has troubled many of us in the non-ferrous fabrication business: what actually happens in the fusion zone when you TIG weld a hypereutectic zinc-aluminium alloy? The authors used optical microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive spectroscopy and microhardness testing to characterise the fusion zone of ZA alloy welds made with a matching filler. The key finding is that the fusion zone has a lower zinc content than both the weld metal and the base metal, while aluminium and copper contents are higher. The microstructure is predominantly columnar dendritic, with room-temperature phases consisting of the Zn phase, the α phase, and intermetallic compounds including Al₄Cu₉, CuTi₂ and Al₇Cu₃Mg₆. The fusion zone shows considerable morphological variation: near the weld the structure is finer, with thin pearlite-like lamellar Zn and α structures, while near the base metal it is coarser but still finer than the parent material. Critically, no coarse-grained zone similar to that seen in low-alloy steel welds was observed.
Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis
The composition shift in the fusion zone is a direct consequence of the melting and solidification sequence. During TIG welding, the filler wire and the base metal both melt, but the higher vapour pressure of zinc relative to aluminium and copper means that a portion of the zinc is lost through volatilisation from the weld pool. This is not a trivial effect; in a hypereutectic alloy where zinc is the dominant element, even a small loss shifts the local composition significantly. The result is a fusion zone that is enriched in aluminium and copper, which in turn promotes the formation of the intermetallic compounds identified. The presence of CuTi₂ is particularly interesting, as it suggests that titanium from the filler or from trace impurities is participating in compound formation, which would not be expected from a simple binary Zn-Al system.
The columnar dendritic morphology is typical of a fusion zone where the thermal gradient is steep and the cooling rate is relatively high. The finer structure near the weld metal boundary is due to the higher cooling rate in that region, where the weld pool is in direct contact with the arc heat source. The coarser structure near the base metal reflects the slower cooling rate further from the heat source. The absence of a coarse-grained zone, which is a common problem in steel welding due to grain growth in the heat-affected zone, is a significant advantage for ZA alloys. This is because the ZA alloy has a relatively low melting point and a narrow solidification range, so the heat-affected zone does not experience the prolonged high-temperature exposure that drives grain growth in steels.
The microhardness results show that the fine intermetallic compounds in the fusion zone have higher hardness than the matrix, which provides a strengthening effect. This is a classic dispersion-strengthening mechanism, where hard, brittle particles impede dislocation motion and thereby increase the local strength. The practical implication is that the fusion zone can have higher hardness than the base metal, which is generally beneficial for wear resistance but can be a concern for ductility and toughness.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
In my experience with zinc-aluminium alloys, which are often used in bearing applications and in the manufacture of dies and moulds, the welding behaviour is always a balance between the need for a sound joint and the risk of zinc volatilisation. The finding that the fusion zone is enriched in aluminium and copper suggests that the choice of filler material is critical. A matching filler, as used in this study, produces a fusion zone with a composition that is not identical to the base metal, but the mechanical properties are still acceptable. In practice, I would recommend that engineers specify a filler with a slightly higher aluminium content to compensate for the zinc loss, but this must be balanced against the risk of hot cracking, which is more likely in aluminium-rich compositions.
The absence of a coarse-grained zone is a practical advantage, as it means that the heat-affected zone does not become a weak link in the joint. In steel welding, the coarse-grained heat-affected zone is often the site of brittle fracture, but in ZA alloys, the relatively low melting point and the narrow solidification range prevent this problem. However, the fusion zone still has a columnar structure, which can be a concern for fatigue performance, as columnar grains have a directional anisotropy that can lead to preferential crack propagation.
One of the lessons I have learned from the shop floor is that the welding of ZA alloys requires careful control of the heat input. Too high a heat input will cause excessive zinc volatilisation, leading to porosity and a rough weld surface. Too low a heat input will result in lack of fusion and a weak joint. The optimal heat input is typically in the range of 10 to 15 kJ/cm, depending on the thickness of the material. In this study, the authors do not provide the specific welding parameters, but the fact that they achieved sound joints with a matching filler suggests that they used a moderate heat input.
Key Questions and Reflections
The study raises an important question about the role of titanium in the fusion zone. The presence of CuTi₂ suggests that titanium is either present in the base metal as an impurity or is introduced through the filler. In my experience, titanium is sometimes added to zinc-aluminium alloys as a grain refiner, but its presence in the fusion zone as an intermetallic compound can have both positive and negative effects. On the positive side, it can act as a nucleation site for the α phase, promoting a finer structure. On the negative side, it can reduce the ductility of the joint, as intermetallic compounds are typically brittle.
Another question that I would raise is the long-term stability of the fusion zone. The intermetallic compounds identified in this study are all relatively stable at room temperature, but the fusion zone may undergo phase transformations over time, particularly if the joint is exposed to elevated temperatures. In bearing applications, where the joint may be subjected to frictional heating, this could lead to a gradual degradation of the mechanical properties.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
The practical takeaway from this study is that TIG welding of hypereutectic ZA alloys with a matching filler produces a fusion zone with acceptable mechanical properties, but the composition and microstructure are not identical to the base metal. This is a normal consequence of the welding process, and it should not be a cause for concern as long as the joint is designed with the fusion zone properties in mind. The absence of a coarse-grained zone is a significant advantage, and the fine intermetallic compounds provide a strengthening effect that can be beneficial in wear applications.
For engineers who are specifying ZA alloy welds, I would recommend that they pay particular attention to the filler material selection and the heat input control. The filler should be matched to the base metal composition, but with a slight adjustment to compensate for zinc loss. The heat input should be kept in the moderate range to avoid excessive volatilisation and porosity. Post-weld heat treatment is not typically required for ZA alloys, but if the joint is to be used in a high-temperature application, a stress-relief treatment may be beneficial.
In my experience, the most common problem with ZA alloy welds is porosity, which is caused by zinc volatilisation. The best way to avoid this is to use a high-purity shielding gas, such as argon with a low oxygen content, and to ensure that the welding area is clean and free of moisture. The welding technique should also be adjusted to minimise the time that the weld pool is exposed to the atmosphere, which means using a short arc length and a relatively fast travel speed.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd