ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of TIG Welded FeCrAl Alloy Plate Joints

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Wang Henglin and colleagues, published in Materials Reports in 2023, investigates the TIG welding of FeCrAl alloy plates using a matching filler wire. The study compares two welding approaches: double-sided TIG welding and multi-pass multilayer TIG welding. After welding, the joints were heat-treated, and the tensile properties were evaluated. The results show that the double-sided TIG welded joint achieved a maximum tensile strength of 400 MPa, which is approximately 52.2% of the base metal strength. The multi-pass multilayer TIG welded joint achieved a maximum tensile strength of 482 MPa, which is approximately 62.3% of the base metal strength. The authors conclude that the multi-pass multilayer joint can meet the mechanical property requirements for load-bearing structural applications.

Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis

The FeCrAl alloy is a ferritic stainless steel with high chromium and aluminium content, which provides excellent oxidation resistance at high temperatures. However, the alloy is known to be difficult to weld due to the high aluminium content, which promotes the formation of coarse ferrite grains in the weld metal and the heat-affected zone. The coarse grains lead to a significant reduction in strength and toughness, which is a major concern for structural applications.

The microstructural analysis shows that the weld metal consists of coarse ferrite grains, while the heat-affected zone consists of fine equiaxed grains. The coarse ferrite grains in the weld metal are a direct consequence of the high heat input and the slow cooling rate, which allow the grains to grow to a large size. The fine equiaxed grains in the heat-affected zone are due to the recrystallisation of the deformed base metal, which occurs during the welding thermal cycle.

The difference in tensile strength between the double-sided and multi-pass joints can be attributed to the difference in the weld metal grain size. The multi-pass multilayer welding process involves multiple thermal cycles, which refine the grain structure of the weld metal. Each pass partially recrystallises the previous pass, resulting in a finer grain size and a higher strength. In contrast, the double-sided welding process involves only two passes, which results in a coarser grain structure and a lower strength.

The heat treatment after welding is a critical step in the process. The authors do not specify the exact heat treatment parameters, but it is likely a stress-relief treatment or an annealing treatment. The heat treatment helps to relieve the residual stresses in the joint and may also promote the precipitation of secondary phases, which can strengthen the material.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

FeCrAl alloys are increasingly used in nuclear applications, particularly as cladding materials for fuel rods, due to their excellent oxidation resistance and high-temperature strength. However, the welding of these alloys is a significant challenge, as the high aluminium content makes the material susceptible to grain growth and embrittlement.

In my experience, the most common problem with FeCrAl alloy welds is the formation of coarse grains in the weld metal, which leads to a significant reduction in strength. The use of multi-pass multilayer welding can help to mitigate this problem, as the multiple thermal cycles refine the grain structure. However, the multi-pass process is more time-consuming and requires more skill, which can increase the cost of fabrication.

Another problem that I have encountered is the formation of porosity, which is caused by the entrapment of hydrogen gas. The hydrogen can come from moisture in the shielding gas, from the filler wire, or from the base metal. The best way to avoid porosity is to ensure that the material is clean and dry, and that the shielding gas is high-purity argon.

The heat treatment after welding is essential for relieving the residual stresses in the joint. In my experience, a stress-relief treatment at a temperature of 600 to 700°C for 1 to 2 hours is typically sufficient. However, the heat treatment must be carefully controlled to avoid grain growth, which can negate the benefits of the multi-pass welding process.

Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises an important question about the effect of the heat treatment on the mechanical properties of the joint. The authors report that the heat-treated joints have a maximum tensile strength of 400 MPa for the double-sided welds and 482 MPa for the multi-pass welds. However, it is not clear whether the heat treatment improves or degrades the properties. In my experience, a stress-relief treatment can improve the ductility of the joint by relieving the residual stresses, but it can also reduce the strength if the temperature is too high.

Another question that I would raise is the effect of the welding process on the corrosion resistance of the joint. FeCrAl alloys are designed for high-temperature oxidation resistance, but the welding process can affect the chromium and aluminium distribution in the joint. The heat-affected zone may be depleted in chromium, which can reduce the corrosion resistance.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

The practical takeaway from this study is that multi-pass multilayer TIG welding is a viable process for FeCrAl alloy plates, as it produces a joint with sufficient strength for load-bearing structural applications. The double-sided welding process produces a weaker joint, but it may be suitable for non-structural applications where the strength requirement is lower.

For engineers who are specifying welding processes for FeCrAl alloys, I would recommend that they consider the multi-pass multilayer process for structural applications, as it provides a higher strength and a finer grain structure. However, the process is more time-consuming and requires more skill, so the cost must be carefully evaluated.

In my experience, the most important factor in welding FeCrAl alloys is the control of the heat input. Too high a heat input will cause excessive grain growth, while too low a heat input will result in lack of fusion. The optimal heat input is typically in the range of 8 to 12 kJ/cm, depending on the thickness of the material.