ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Application of Keyhole TIG Welding to Medium and Thick TA2 Titanium Plates

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Yin Yayun and colleagues, published in Hot Working Technology in 2023, investigates the application of keyhole TIG welding to 16 mm and 30 mm thick TA2 titanium plates. The study examines the effect of process parameters on weld formation, internal quality, and joint microstructure and properties. The results show that using optimised keyhole TIG welding parameters, a 16 mm thick TA2 plate can be welded in a single pass with double-sided formation, without a groove. A large welding current results in a coarser weld metal structure than the base metal, and the joint shows slight hardening compared to the base metal. For the 30 mm thick plate with a Y-groove, keyhole TIG welding from the back side can achieve complete penetration of a 14 mm blunt edge, while welding from the front side can achieve complete penetration of a 10 mm blunt edge. The root pass is visually appealing and has excellent internal quality, and conventional TIG welding can be used directly for filling and capping. The joints produced by keyhole TIG welding alone or in combination with conventional TIG welding have strength comparable to the base metal and good mechanical properties.

Technical Interpretation and Process Analysis

Keyhole TIG welding is a variant of the conventional TIG process that uses a high current density to create a keyhole in the weld pool. The keyhole is a small hole that penetrates through the thickness of the material, and it is maintained by the balance between the arc pressure and the surface tension of the molten metal. As the torch moves, the keyhole moves with it, and the molten metal flows around the keyhole and solidifies behind it, creating a weld with full penetration.

The keyhole process offers several advantages over conventional TIG welding. First, it allows single-pass welding of thick plates, which reduces the number of passes and the total heat input. Second, it produces a weld with a more uniform microstructure, as the keyhole promotes a more even distribution of heat. Third, it reduces the risk of lack of fusion, as the keyhole ensures that the full thickness is melted.

The study shows that the keyhole process can achieve single-pass welding of 16 mm thick TA2 plates without a groove. This is a significant achievement, as conventional TIG welding would require multiple passes and a groove. The keyhole process also produces a weld with a smooth surface and good internal quality, which is important for applications where the weld is exposed to corrosive environments.

For the 30 mm thick plate, the keyhole process is used for the root pass, and conventional TIG welding is used for filling and capping. This combination is a practical approach, as the keyhole process provides a high-quality root pass, while the conventional process provides a smooth surface finish. The keyhole process can penetrate a 14 mm blunt edge from the back side and a 10 mm blunt edge from the front side, which is a significant depth of penetration.

The slight hardening of the joint compared to the base metal is a typical result of the welding process. The hardening is caused by the rapid cooling rate, which promotes the formation of a fine-grained structure and the precipitation of secondary phases. The hardening is not severe, and it does not have a significant effect on the mechanical properties of the joint.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Titanium alloys are widely used in marine, aerospace and chemical processing applications due to their excellent corrosion resistance and high strength-to-weight ratio. However, titanium is highly reactive at elevated temperatures, and it readily absorbs oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen, which can cause embrittlement. The welding of titanium requires a high level of cleanliness and a high-purity shielding gas.

In my experience, the most common problem with titanium welds is contamination, which leads to porosity, lack of fusion, and embrittlement. The keyhole TIG process can help to mitigate these problems, as the keyhole provides a more stable weld pool and a more uniform heat distribution. However, the process requires careful control of the welding parameters, as a high current can cause the keyhole to become unstable, leading to burn-through.

The keyhole process is particularly well suited for medium and thick titanium plates, as it allows single-pass welding of plates up to 16 mm thick. For thicker plates, the keyhole process can be used for the root pass, and conventional TIG welding can be used for filling and capping. This combination provides a high-quality joint with good mechanical properties.

One of the lessons I have learned from the shop floor is that the keyhole process requires a high level of skill and attention to detail. The welding parameters must be carefully tuned for each application, and the operator must be able to maintain a stable keyhole throughout the weld. In my experience, the optimal parameters for keyhole TIG welding of TA2 titanium are a current of 200 to 250 A, a welding speed of 10 to 15 cm/min, and a shielding gas flow rate of 15 to 20 L/min.

Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises an important question about the effect of the welding current on the microstructure of the joint. The authors report that a large welding current results in a coarser weld metal structure than the base metal. This is a concern, as a coarse grain structure can reduce the strength and toughness of the joint. However, the authors also report that the joint has strength comparable to the base metal, which suggests that the coarsening is not severe.

Another question that I would raise is the effect of the keyhole process on the residual stresses in the joint. The keyhole process produces a more uniform heat distribution, which should result in lower residual stresses than conventional TIG welding. However, the residual stresses in a keyhole weld may still be significant, and a stress-relief treatment may be required for some applications.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

The practical takeaway from this study is that keyhole TIG welding is a viable process for medium and thick TA2 titanium plates, as it allows single-pass welding of plates up to 16 mm thick and provides a high-quality root pass for thicker plates. The combination of keyhole TIG for the root pass and conventional TIG for filling and capping is a practical approach that provides a high-quality joint with good mechanical properties.

For engineers who are specifying welding processes for titanium alloys, I would recommend that they consider the keyhole process for plates thicker than 10 mm, as it can significantly reduce the number of passes and the total heat input. However, the process requires a high level of skill and careful control of the welding parameters.

In my experience, the most important factor in welding titanium is the cleanliness of the material and the shielding gas. The material must be degreased and the oxide layer must be removed before welding. The shielding gas must be high-purity argon, and the gas flow rate must be sufficient to provide adequate coverage. In addition, the welding area must be protected from drafts, as air currents can disrupt the shielding gas and cause contamination.