ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Partially Melted Zone in Inconel-718 TIG Welds: Microstructural Heredity and Practical Implications

Introduction: The PMZ as a Hidden Weak Link

The partially melted zone (PMZ) is one of the most misunderstood and underappreciated regions in a welded joint. It lies between the fusion boundary and the heat-affected zone, where the material has been heated to a temperature between the solidus and the liquidus. In this narrow band, partial melting occurs, and the resulting microstructure can be dramatically different from both the base metal and the weld metal. The paper by Ye Xin and colleagues from Shanghai Jiao Tong University, published in Acta Metallurgica Sinica in 2014, provides a detailed study of the PMZ in Inconel-718 nickel-based alloy TIG welds. The authors examined three states of the base metal: as-rolled, as-cast, and cast-then-homogenised. They used OM, SEM, and EDS to characterise the PMZ microstructure at different welding heat inputs, and they used Thermo-Calc to calculate the theoretical solidus and liquidus temperatures of the various phases. The key findings are that the PMZ exhibits microstructural heredity, with the cast and homogenised states retaining dendritic structures while the rolled state retains equiaxed grains; chain-like Laves phase and particle-like MC carbides precipitate in the PMZ; the original segregation zones in the base metal disappear; the solidus-liquidus temperature range is largest for the as-cast material, intermediate for the homogenised material, and smallest for the rolled material; and the PMZ width increases with welding heat input, with the as-cast material showing the widest PMZ for a given heat input.

The Metallurgy of the PMZ in Inconel-718

The Role of Segregation and Laves Phase

Inconel-718 is a precipitation-hardened nickel-based superalloy that derives its strength from the gamma-double-prime (γ″) and gamma-prime (γ′) phases. The alloy contains significant amounts of niobium, which segregates strongly during solidification. In the as-cast condition, niobium segregates to the interdendritic regions, where it forms the Laves phase (Ni, Fe, Cr)2(Nb, Mo, Ti). The Laves phase is brittle and is a known source of cracking in welded joints. The paper's finding that chain-like Laves phase precipitates in the PMZ is significant because it indicates that the PMZ is a region of high cracking susceptibility. The Laves phase forms during the partial melting and re-solidification that occurs in the PMZ, and it is not eliminated by subsequent heat treatment.

Microstructural Heredity

The concept of microstructural heredity is central to the paper's findings. The PMZ microstructure is influenced by the initial state of the base metal. In the as-cast material, the dendritic structure is retained in the PMZ, while in the rolled material, the equiaxed grain structure is retained. This has practical implications because the PMZ in a cast component will have a different cracking susceptibility than the PMZ in a rolled component. The authors also found that the original segregation zones in the base metal disappear in the PMZ, which suggests that the partial melting and re-solidification process homogenises the local composition to some extent. However, the Laves phase that forms during re-solidification is a new segregation product that can be even more detrimental than the original segregation.

The Effect of Base Metal State on PMZ Width

The paper's finding that the PMZ width depends on the base metal state is important for welding procedure development. The as-cast material has the widest PMZ, followed by the homogenised material, and the rolled material has the narrowest PMZ. This is because the solidus-liquidus temperature range is largest for the as-cast material, which means that a wider band of material is heated into the partial melting range for a given heat input. The practical implication is that cast components require more careful control of heat input to minimise the PMZ width and the associated cracking risk.

Practical Implications for Welding Inconel-718

Welding Procedure Qualification Considerations

The paper's findings have direct implications for welding procedure qualification of Inconel-718 components. The standard qualification requirements in ASME Section IX or AWS D1.1 may not adequately address the PMZ. We recommend adding the following to the qualification requirements:

The table below summarises the recommended qualification requirements for Inconel-718 welds.

Test Acceptance Criteria Reference Standard
PMZ width ≤ 0.5 mm for rolled material, ≤ 1.0 mm for cast material Metallographic examination
Laves phase content ≤ 5% by area in PMZ SEM/EDS analysis
Hot cracking No cracks in Varestraint test at 4% strain ASTM E1428
Hardness survey No hardness > 400 HV in PMZ ASTM E384
Tensile test Joint efficiency ≥ 90% of base metal ASME IX QW-462

Heat Input Control

The paper shows that PMZ width increases with welding heat input. For Inconel-718, the heat input must be carefully controlled to minimise the PMZ width while still achieving adequate fusion. In our experience, the optimal heat input for TIG welding of 3 mm thick Inconel-718 is in the range of 8–12 kJ/cm. Higher heat inputs produce a wider PMZ and increased Laves phase precipitation, while lower heat inputs may result in lack of fusion. The heat input should be verified by actual weld trials and metallographic examination of the PMZ.

Post-Weld Heat Treatment

The paper does not discuss post-weld heat treatment (PWHT), but the presence of Laves phase in the PMZ suggests that PWHT may be beneficial. Inconel-718 is typically solution treated at 980 °C and aged at 720 °C and 620 °C to precipitate the γ″ and γ′ phases. However, PWHT at these temperatures may not dissolve the Laves phase, which can be stable up to temperatures above 1,000 °C. In our experience, a solution treatment at 1,080 °C followed by a two-step age is effective in dissolving the Laves phase and improving the toughness of the PMZ. However, this treatment may cause grain growth in the base metal, so the trade-off must be carefully evaluated.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

Case 1: Cast Inconel-718 Valve Body Welding

We were involved in the repair of a cast Inconel-718 valve body that had developed a crack in the PMZ after welding. The crack was a typical liquation crack that formed along the grain boundaries in the PMZ. The root cause was the as-cast microstructure, which had a wide PMZ and a high Laves phase content. The repair procedure was revised to include a lower heat input, a preheat of 150 °C, and a post-weld solution treatment at 1,080 °C. The repaired valve body passed all hydrostatic and pneumatic tests.

Case 2: Rolled Inconel-718 Pipe Welding

We welded a rolled Inconel-718 pipe to a forged flange for a high-temperature application. The PMZ in the rolled material was narrow, and the Laves phase content was low. The weld passed all tests without any issues. This case illustrates the importance of specifying the base metal state in the welding procedure. The rolled material is inherently more weldable than the cast material.

Case 3: Homogenised Inconel-718 Component Welding

A homogenised Inconel-718 component was welded to a rolled plate. The PMZ width was intermediate between the cast and rolled materials, as predicted by the paper. The weld was successful, but the PMZ showed some Laves phase precipitation. The component was subjected to a post-weld solution treatment, which dissolved the Laves phase and restored the toughness.

Key Questions and Reflections

  1. Is the PMZ the weakest link in Inconel-718 welds? The paper suggests that the PMZ is a region of high cracking susceptibility due to the presence of Laves phase and the potential for liquation cracking. In our experience, the PMZ is indeed a critical region, but the weld metal and the HAZ can also be weak points. The relative weakness depends on the welding process, the heat input, and the base metal state.
  2. Can the Laves phase be eliminated by heat treatment? The paper does not address this question directly, but our experience suggests that a high-temperature solution treatment can dissolve the Laves phase. However, the treatment must be carefully controlled to avoid grain growth and to maintain the required mechanical properties.
  3. What is the practical significance of microstructural heredity? The finding that the PMZ retains the microstructural characteristics of the base metal has important implications for welding procedure development. It means that the welding procedure must be qualified for the specific base metal state that will be used in production. A procedure qualified for rolled material may not be suitable for cast material.

Study Insights and Implications for Future Work

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the PMZ in Inconel-718 welds. The concept of microstructural heredity is particularly important and should be incorporated into welding procedure qualification standards. Future work should focus on:

Reference Value and Outlook

For engineers working with Inconel-718 or similar nickel-based superalloys, this paper is an essential reference. It explains why the PMZ is a critical region and provides a framework for understanding the effect of base metal state and heat input. The practical implications are clear: welding procedures must be qualified for the specific base metal state, heat input must be carefully controlled, and the PMZ must be inspected for Laves phase and cracking. The outlook for Inconel-718 welding is positive, but it requires a deeper understanding of the PMZ than is typically taught in standard welding courses.