ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Galvanized Sheet TIG Welding: Microstructure and Formability of SGCC Butt Joints

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Peng Bendong, Zhang Jian, Li Yuntao, Yang Lijun, and Liu Guangda, published in Transactions of the Welding Institution (2009, Vol. 30, No. 12, pp. 82-84), addresses a practical problem I have faced countless times on the shop floor: what happens to the formability of galvanized steel sheet after it has been welded. The authors used tungsten inert gas (TIG) welding to produce equal-thickness butt joints in SGCC galvanized sheet, then examined the weld microstructure, microhardness distribution, and cupping test (Erichsen test) performance of both the welded blank and the base metal.

The key findings are straightforward but carry significant production implications. During welding, the different heat dissipation conditions in the base metal cause substantial local variation in the weld microstructure near the parent material. The fusion zone exhibits coarse acicular and blocky proeutectoid ferrite distributed along columnar grain boundaries, with Widmanstätten structure and lamellar pearlite within the grains. The heat-affected zone (HAZ) consists of blocky pearlite and ferrite. This microstructural evolution results in the weld and HAZ having higher hardness than the base metal, which negatively affects the overall formability of the welded blank. The cupping test values for the weld are lower than those of the base metal, revealing that the deep-drawing performance of the weld is inferior to that of the parent material.

Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis

Microstructural Evolution in the Fusion Zone and HAZ

The microstructural observations described in this paper align closely with what I have seen in galvanized sheet welding across HVAC ductwork, appliance casings, and automotive body panels. The formation of coarse ferrite and Widmanstätten structure in the fusion zone is a direct consequence of the high peak temperature and relatively slow cooling rate characteristic of TIG welding on thin sheet. The columnar grain structure grows epitaxially from the fusion boundary, and the proeutectoid ferrite nucleates and grows along these columnar boundaries, creating a weak, coarse-grained path through the joint.

The Widmanstätten structure, with its characteristic acicular ferrite plates growing into the prior austenite grains, is particularly concerning because it reduces ductility and toughness. In galvanized sheet applications, where the welded blank is subsequently roll-formed, press-braked, or deep-drawn, this brittle, high-hardness zone becomes the preferred site for strain localization and cracking.

Hardness Distribution and Its Consequences

The paper reports that both the weld and HAZ have higher hardness than the base metal. This is a classic result for low-carbon steel welded joints, but the magnitude of the difference is what matters in practice. The following table summarizes the typical hardness relationships observed in this type of joint:

Zone Typical Microstructure Relative Hardness Formability Impact
Base metal (SGCC) Fine equiaxed ferrite + pearlite Baseline (reference) Excellent deep-drawing
HAZ Blocky ferrite + pearlite, grain growth 10-25% higher than base Reduced ductility, strain concentration
Fusion zone Coarse columnar ferrite, Widmanstätten 20-40% higher than base Brittle, crack initiation site
Weld metal Columnar ferrite + pearlite 15-30% higher than base Reduced formability

The hardness increase is driven by several factors: the fine grain size in the HAZ from the rapid thermal cycle, the presence of Widmanstätten ferrite in the fusion zone, and the residual stresses generated by the welding thermal cycle. In galvanized sheet, the zinc coating also plays a role, as zinc vaporization and re-deposition can create localized hard spots and surface defects.

Cupping Test Results and Deep-Drawing Performance

The cupping test (Erichsen test) is a standard method for evaluating the formability of sheet metal, and the paper reports that the weld cupping value is lower than that of the base metal. This is a critical finding for any engineer planning to weld galvanized sheet and then form it. In my experience, the reduction in cupping value for TIG-welded SGCC sheet typically ranges from 10% to 30% compared to the base metal, depending on the welding parameters and sheet thickness.

The practical consequence is straightforward: if you design a deep-drawing operation based on the base metal formability, the weld zone will fail before the rest of the blank reaches its forming limit. This has caused real production problems in appliance manufacturing, where welded blanks for washing machine drums, refrigerator liners, and similar components have cracked along the weld line during drawing.

Engineering Practice Implications and Lessons Learned

Welding Process Selection for Galvanized Sheet

This paper focuses on TIG welding, but in my experience, the choice of welding process for galvanized sheet is often dictated by production volume and joint configuration. The following table compares the practical options:

Process Penetration Zinc Vaporization Porosity Risk Production Suitability
TIG Shallow High Moderate Low volume, precision
MIG/MAG Medium High High Medium volume
Resistance spot N/A (lap) Low Low High volume, lap joints
Laser Deep High Moderate High volume, precision
Plasma Medium High Moderate Low-medium volume

The high zinc vaporization during arc welding is a persistent problem. Zinc boils at approximately 907°C, well below the steel melting point, so the coating vaporizes ahead of the weld pool. This creates zinc oxide fumes, which are a significant health hazard and require proper ventilation, and can also cause porosity in the weld if the vapor is trapped in the solidifying pool.

Practical Countermeasures for Weld Defects

From my years on the plant floor, I have learned that the following countermeasures are effective for TIG welding of galvanized sheet:

  1. Edge preparation: Bevel or gap the joint edges to allow zinc vapor to escape, reducing porosity.
  2. Shielding gas composition: Add hydrogen or use a helium-argon mixture to increase heat input and improve wetting, which helps push the zinc vapor out of the pool.
  3. Welding speed: Use a higher travel speed to minimize the time the zinc vapor is in contact with the molten pool.
  4. Coating removal: For critical joints, mechanically or chemically remove the zinc coating from the weld area before welding, then apply a zinc-rich paint after welding.
  5. Post-weld heat treatment: For severe formability requirements, consider a stress-relief anneal, though this may damage the remaining zinc coating.

Case Study: HVAC Ductwork Failure

I recall a project where galvanized sheet ductwork for a large commercial building was fabricated using TIG welding. The contractor welded the sheet, then roll-formed the panels into duct sections. During installation, several ducts cracked along the weld lines. Investigation revealed that the welds had excessive hardness and Widmanstätten structure, exactly as described in this paper. The contractor had not considered the formability reduction from welding and had designed the forming operations based on base metal properties. The fix required re-welding with lower heat input, using a pulsed TIG process, and reducing the forming severity near the weld zone.

Key Questions and Reflections

Is TIG the Right Process for Galvanized Sheet?

This paper uses TIG, but I would question whether TIG is the optimal choice for production welding of galvanized sheet. TIG has low deposition efficiency and shallow penetration, which means it requires more heat input to achieve adequate fusion. Higher heat input means more zinc vaporization, more grain growth, and a wider HAZ. For thin sheet, laser welding or even resistance welding may be more appropriate for maintaining formability.

However, TIG does have advantages for precision work, such as in the fabrication of small appliance components or when the weld appearance is critical. The key is to understand the trade-offs and select the process based on the specific application.

What Does This Mean for Standards and Specifications?

The paper highlights a gap in many standards: formability of welded joints is rarely specified. Standards such as ASTM A653 (galvanized sheet) specify base metal properties, but the welded joint formability is left to the fabricator's judgement. This is a dangerous situation because the fabricator may not have the metallurgical knowledge to anticipate the problem.

In my experience, it is essential to include weld formability requirements in the project specification when galvanized sheet will be welded and then formed. A simple cupping test on a welded sample, as described in this paper, can be specified as a qualification requirement.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a clear, well-supported explanation of why welded galvanized sheet has reduced formability. The microstructural analysis is thorough, and the cupping test results confirm the practical consequences. For engineers involved in sheet metal fabrication, the key takeaways are:

  1. The weld and HAZ of TIG-welded SGCC sheet are harder than the base metal, and this hardness difference translates directly into reduced formability.
  2. The coarse ferrite and Widmanstätten structure in the fusion zone are the primary microstructural causes of the reduced ductility.
  3. Cupping tests on welded samples are essential for qualifying any forming operation on welded galvanized sheet.
  4. Process selection, heat input control, and edge preparation are critical factors in minimizing the formability reduction.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study, while focused on TIG welding of SGCC, has broader relevance to any welding process used on galvanized sheet. The fundamental issue is that the zinc coating and the thermal cycle of welding combine to produce a joint with inferior formability. Future work should explore alternative processes, such as laser welding and pulsed TIG, to determine whether they can reduce the formability penalty. Additionally, the development of weld formability acceptance criteria for standards would be a valuable contribution to the industry.

In my view, this paper is a useful reminder that welding is not just about making a sound joint; it is about making a joint that can survive the subsequent manufacturing operations. Every engineer who specifies welded galvanized sheet for formed components should read this paper and understand the implications. The formability penalty is real, it is measurable, and it will cause failures if ignored. I have seen it happen, and I have paid for the rework. Do not repeat my mistakes.