Microstructural Characteristics of TIG Welded Zinc-Based Alloy Joints
Material and Welding Challenges
The paper by Li Xueshun, Sun Fuyang, Guo Qingchao, Hou Bin and Zhang Mengfei, published in Hot Working Technology (2016, Vol. 45, No. 21, pp. 207–209), examines the microstructure of TIG welded zinc-based alloy joints. Zinc-based alloys, particularly the Zn–Al system, are used in a variety of applications including die casting, bearing materials, and corrosion-resistant coatings. They are also found in galvanised steel products, where the zinc coating is applied to protect the underlying steel from corrosion.
Welding zinc-based alloys is notoriously difficult. The melting point of zinc is only 419 °C, and the boiling point is 907 °C. This means that the temperature range between solid and vapour is narrow, and the arc heat from a TIG torch can easily vaporise the zinc, creating porosity and fume. The high thermal expansion coefficient of zinc also leads to significant distortion and residual stress. In the case of galvanised steel, the zinc coating vaporises during welding and can cause porosity in the weld metal if it is not properly removed or controlled.
The authors welded a zinc-based alloy using TIG and then examined the joint using optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, energy dispersive spectroscopy, and Vickers hardness testing. Their goal was to characterise the microstructure of the weld, the fusion zone, and the heat-affected zone, and to relate the microstructure to the hardness distribution.
Microstructure Observations
The authors found that the TIG welded zinc-based alloy joint was smooth and complete, with a clear interface between the weld and the heat-affected zone. The weld metal consisted of fine equiaxed grains and elongated columnar grains, with no evidence of overheated coarse grains. This is a positive finding, because coarse grains in the weld metal would reduce the toughness and ductility of the joint.
| Zone | Microstructural Features | Grain Size | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weld metal | Fine equiaxed + columnar grains | Fine | No overheating |
| Fusion zone | α1 phase + Zn solid solution | Fine | Non-uniform volume expansion causes internal stress |
| Heat-affected zone | Refined grains | Fine | Improved plasticity |
| Base metal | Equiaxed grains | Coarse | Original structure |
The fusion zone is the critical region. The authors identified the microstructure as a mixture of the α1 phase and a zinc-based solid solution. The non-uniform volume expansion during solidification creates internal stress in the fusion zone, which reduces its strength and plasticity. This is a classic problem in welding dissimilar or complex alloys: the solidification shrinkage and thermal contraction are not uniform, and the result is a zone that is weaker than both the weld metal and the base metal.
The heat-affected zone showed grain refinement, which is unusual. In most steels, the HAZ is coarser than the base metal because of the high peak temperature. In this zinc-based alloy, the authors found that the HAZ grains were actually finer than the base metal, which they attribute to the rapid cooling and possibly to recrystallisation during the thermal cycle. This grain refinement improves the plasticity of the HAZ, which is beneficial for the overall joint performance.
Hardness Distribution and Its Meaning
The hardness distribution across the joint is the most practical finding in the paper. The authors measured the hardness in the weld metal, the HAZ, the base metal, and the fusion zone, and found the following order, from highest to lowest: weld metal > HAZ > base metal > fusion zone.
| Zone | Relative Hardness | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Weld metal | Highest | Fine grains + solid solution strengthening |
| Heat-affected zone | Second highest | Grain refinement |
| Base metal | Third highest | Original coarse grain structure |
| Fusion zone | Lowest | Internal stress + microstructural weakness |
This hardness distribution is unusual. In most welded joints, the fusion zone is the hardest region because it has the finest microstructure and the highest cooling rate. In this zinc-based alloy, the fusion zone is the softest, which the authors attribute to the internal stress caused by non-uniform volume expansion. The internal stress reduces the effective load-bearing capacity of the fusion zone, and the hardness measurement reflects this weakness.
From a practical standpoint, the fusion zone is the weakest link in the joint. If the joint is loaded in tension, the fusion zone will be the first to yield and the first to fail. This is a critical consideration for any design that relies on the strength of a welded zinc-based alloy joint.
Practical Implications for Zinc-Coated Pipe
For the pipe and fitting industry, this paper has direct relevance to the welding of galvanised steel pipe. When you weld galvanised pipe, the zinc coating vaporises at the arc, and the zinc vapour can be drawn into the weld pool, causing porosity and cracking. The authors' observation that the fusion zone is the weakest region is a reminder that the weld quality in galvanised pipe is not just about the weld metal — it is also about the interface between the weld and the base metal.
In practice, the standard approach for welding galvanised pipe is to grind back the zinc coating at least 25 mm from the joint on both sides, weld the bare steel, and then repair the coating with a zinc-rich paint. This is a well-established procedure, but it is often not followed as strictly as it should be. I have seen galvanised pipe welds where the zinc was not fully removed, and the result was porosity and lack of fusion that was only detected by radiography after the pipe was already installed. The cost of repairing those welds was many times the cost of properly grinding back the coating in the first place.
The paper also highlights the importance of controlling the heat input when welding zinc-based alloys. Because zinc has a low boiling point, excessive heat input will vaporise the zinc and create porosity. The TIG process, with its precise heat control, is well-suited for this application, but the operator must use a low current and a short arc time to minimise the heat input. This is a lesson that applies equally to galvanised pipe welding and to the welding of zinc-based alloy components.
In summary, this paper provides a detailed microstructural characterisation of TIG welded zinc-based alloy joints. The key findings are that the weld metal has a fine grain structure with no overheating, the HAZ shows grain refinement, and the fusion zone is the weakest region due to internal stress from non-uniform volume expansion. For production, the lesson is to control heat input carefully, ensure proper joint preparation, and pay special attention to the fusion zone when evaluating joint quality.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd