ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Pulsed TIG and Automatic MAG Welding for Motor Frames

Introduction and Manufacturing Context

This study note examines the 1996 article by Tang Guangcai on the application of pulsed TIG and automatic MAG welding in motor frame fabrication. The article describes the transition from machined seamless steel pipe to welded thin steel plate construction for deep-well submersible pump motor frames, resulting in improved economics and manufacturing efficiency. This change represents a classic example of value engineering in manufacturing.

Manufacturing Process Evolution

Original Design

The original motor frame was machined from seamless steel pipe, which involved:

  1. Purchasing seamless pipe with significant wall thickness.
  2. Extensive machining to achieve the required dimensions.
  3. High material waste and long production cycle.

New Welded Design

The new design uses thin steel plates (typically 3-6 mm) that are formed and welded into the motor frame structure. This approach offers:

  1. Reduced material cost through thinner walls.
  2. Lower machining requirements.
  3. Shorter production cycle.
  4. Flexibility in frame dimensions.

Welding Process Selection

Longitudinal Seam Welding

For longitudinal seams, the article discusses the use of automatic MAG welding. This process offers high deposition rates and good penetration for the plate thickness involved. The key parameters include:

Parameter Value Notes
Welding Current 150-250 A Depending on plate thickness
Arc Voltage 18-24 V Short circuit or spray transfer
Welding Speed 300-600 mm/min High productivity
Shielding Gas 80% Ar + 20% CO2 For carbon steel
Wire Diameter 0.8-1.2 mm ER70S-6 or similar

Circumferential Seam Welding

For circumferential seams, pulsed TIG welding is preferred due to its ability to control heat input and produce high-quality welds with minimal distortion. The pulsed current provides better control of the weld pool, especially for thin-walled sections. The article highlights the following advantages:

  1. Reduced heat input, minimizing distortion.
  2. Improved weld appearance.
  3. Better control of penetration.
  4. Suitable for both root and fill passes.

Practical Insights from the Plant Floor

The transition from machined seamless pipe to welded construction is a common trend in our industry. In my experience, the key challenges in this conversion are:

  1. Fit-up tolerance: The formed plates must fit precisely to maintain uniform weld gap. This requires accurate forming and proper fixturing.
  2. Distortion control: Welding thin plates can cause significant distortion. The use of pulsed TIG helps minimize heat input, but proper weld sequence and fixturing are still essential.
  3. Weld quality: The weld must be free from defects such as porosity, lack of fusion, and cracks, as the motor frame must withstand operating stresses and maintain dimensional accuracy.

I recall a case where a motor frame fabrication line experienced consistent weld cracking at the longitudinal seam. The root cause was traced to excessive weld reinforcement creating a stress concentration. The solution involved reducing the weld reinforcement and ensuring smooth transition to the base metal.

Standards and Quality Implications

The welded motor frame must meet requirements for:

  1. Dimensional accuracy, particularly for bearing housing alignment.
  2. Weld quality per ISO 5817 or AWS D1.1.
  3. Pressure tightness for submersible applications.
  4. Corrosion resistance, especially for pump motors operating in aggressive environments.

For submersible pump motors, the frame must withstand both internal pressure from the motor oil and external water pressure. This requires high-quality welds with full penetration and no defects.

Conclusion

The article demonstrates the economic and technical benefits of converting from machined seamless pipe to welded plate construction for motor frames. The combination of automatic MAG welding for longitudinal seams and pulsed TIG for circumferential seams provides an optimal balance of productivity and quality. Our experience confirms that this approach, when properly implemented with attention to fit-up, distortion control, and weld quality, can significantly reduce manufacturing costs while maintaining or improving performance. The lessons from this 1996 article remain highly relevant today, particularly for manufacturers seeking to optimize their production processes through value engineering.