Repair Welding of Titanium Tube Components by TIG: A Practical Study Note
Introduction and Problem Definition
This 1993 paper from the welding technology journal describes a repair situation I have seen more times than I care to count: a titanium tube, in this case φ36×1 mm TA1, used as a cooling water coil inside a plating tank, has been punctured by an electrical short circuit. The tube carries cooling water internally while its external surface is exposed to acid, alkali and salt media. The hole is small and localised, but the service environment is aggressive, so the repair must restore both pressure tightness and corrosion resistance. The author chose manual TIG welding, and the logic is sound. Titanium is highly reactive with oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen at elevated temperatures, and any repair method that does not provide full inert gas shielding, both on the weld face and on the root side, will produce brittle oxide and nitride films that crack under thermal stress.
Welding Process and Parameters
The paper does not give a full parameter table, but from the description and from my own shop floor experience with titanium repair, the following ranges are what I would expect to see and what I would recommend.
| Parameter | Recommended Value | Practical Note |
|---|---|---|
| Filler wire | ERTi-1 or matching TA1 wire | Must be degreased and pickled before use |
| Shielding gas | Argon, purity ≥ 99.99% | Dew point below -40°C is mandatory |
| Polarity | DCEN (straight polarity) | Best for titanium, gives deep penetration with minimal heat |
| Current | 60–90 A for 1 mm wall | Keep heat input low to avoid burn-through |
| Voltage | 10–12 V | Short arc, low energy |
| Welding speed | 80–120 mm/min | Steady travel, no weaving |
| Root shielding | Argon purge at 5–8 L/min | Critical for the back side of the weld |
| Trailing shield | Argon at 10–15 L/min | Protects the hot weld and HAZ until below 300°C |
The critical point is that the weld zone, including the heat-affected zone, must remain under argon protection until it cools below roughly 300°C. If the weld turns silver or straw coloured, oxidation has occurred and the joint is compromised. The author's approach of using a small repair patch or simply filling the hole with filler wire is acceptable for a localised defect, but I would always insist on a full visual and penetrant inspection of the repaired area before returning the coil to service.
Practical Considerations and Lessons
The first thing that strikes me is that this is a repair on a thin-walled tube with a wall thickness of only 1 mm. At that thickness, the margin for error is almost zero. The welding current must be set precisely, and the operator must have a steady hand. In my experience, the most common failure mode in such repairs is not lack of fusion but burn-through, where the arc melts through the opposite wall of the tube. The second common failure is contamination: any trace of oil, grease or finger marks on the titanium surface will cause porosity and discoloration. The third is insufficient root shielding, which leads to oxidation on the inside of the tube and a subsequent corrosion failure within months.
I would also note that the paper does not mention post-weld heat treatment or stress relief. For a 1 mm tube in a cooling service, this is generally not necessary, but the weld should be allowed to cool naturally under argon. Forced cooling with air or water is absolutely forbidden on titanium, as it can cause cracking due to the rapid thermal contraction.
Summary
This paper is a concise and practical account of a repair that many shops would shy away from. The author correctly identifies TIG as the only viable process for titanium tube repair and lays out a process that, if followed with discipline, will produce a sound joint. My own experience confirms that the key to success is not the welding machine but the preparation and the shielding. If the surface is clean, the gas is pure, and the operator is patient, the repair will hold. If any of those three conditions is compromised, the weld will fail, and the failure will be more expensive than the repair. I would add one recommendation to the author's work: after repair, the tube should be hydrostatically tested at 1.5 times the working pressure, and the weld zone should be examined by penetrant testing to confirm that no surface cracks or porosity exist. This is a small step that saves a great deal of trouble later.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd